A/N: So the people have spoken, almost everyone said that it was going to be the person I used so I used them it would have been almost the same conversation either way, and I'll give my reason for using this person versus another in my next A/N.
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG
"Lorelai?" The person asked quietly from across the dinning room. Lorelai whipped her head around to face…
…Christopher Hayden.
"Chris?" Lorelai asked incredulously.
"What the hell?"
"What the hell is right what the hell are you doing here, I don't remember giving you an invitation and I'm pretty sure Rory didn't either, how did you even know about this?"
"Your mom,"
"Oh of course it was Emily even when she's on the outs with dad she still has time to medal in my affairs…Chris leave," Lorelai practically yelled while everyone was watching, kind of like a train wreck.
"No, this is a big day for you and Rory so I think I have a right to be here,"
"Hey don't bring me into this," Rory said from the table thinking that maybe they should just finally have it out and that would maybe get rid of all of there left over…emotional energy.
"Yeah Chris this is between me and you, now your right this is a huge day for me, like the third biggest day in my life, and you are not invited." Lorelai yelled
"What are you doing with this guy?" Chris said ignoring the glares he was getting from the entire table.
"You do not have the right to ask me that question, you gave it up a long time ago…but you wanna have this out then fine lets have this out," Lorelai said grabbing Luke's hand and stomping of to her office with Chris close behind.
"Lorelai what are we doing?" Luke asked when all three were safely locked inside.
"We are having this out…now Chris as soon as we do this you forfeit all of your rights in my life, okay?" Lorelai asked looking dead serious.
"I'm not sure what's going on but okay," Chris said uncertain.
"Chris what's my favorite color?" Lorelai asked very serious.
"What are we doing?" Chris asked confused.
"Well the only reason you could ever possibly have objections to me dating Luke is you think your better for me than Luke…well I'm trying to see who knows me better, you or Luke, so once again what's my favorite color?"
"Purple?" Chris guessed.
"Eh, wrong Luke?"
"Pink," Luke answered confidently looking at Chris like he was stupid.
"What is my favorite present of all time?" Lorelai asked looking straight at Chris.
"Um…the Jeep?" Chris asked not even sure if that was a gift.
"I bought the Jeep my self…Luke?"
"The coffee mug I helped Rory paint when she was five," Luke said starting to like this game. (I don't know if they knew Luke then but just work with me)
"What's my least favorite day of the week?" Lorelai asked now smiling in a sadistic sort of way.
"Um, Tuesdays," Chris said in a complete guess.
"No," Lorelai then prompted at Luke.
"Fridays, dinner with the parents," Luke said still looking at Chris like he was an idiot.
"Chris do you really want to continue this humiliation or are you ready to leave me alone yet?" Lorelai said looking incredulous.
"So he knows your favorite color what does that mean?" Chris asked still not giving up.
"It means everything, it means he bothered to get to know me, it means that he'll know when I'm upset and when I need to talk about something, versus when I need some time to myself…he knows me, Chris and I've known you for over 20 years and in all that time you don't know what my favorite band is… that just shows me how little you really care, but if you want to go on deeds instead of knowledge that's fine with me…Luke has been to every single birthday party for me and Rory since we met while you barely even send her gifts, Luke took in a pretty troubled kid who's know responsible and a tiny bit respectful because of him while you can't even find time for your own kid, Chris there is no way you can win so why are you even trying?" Lorelai asked looking for an answer to why he always just showed up and left, and hurt everyone.
"I don't know," Chris said quietly and left, hopefully for good.
"I'm so drained," Lorelai whispered leaning against Luke.
"Getting rid of the father of your kid can do that to you," Luke laughed, happy about all the things Lorelai just said about him.
"Luke,"
"Yeah,"
"I love you,"
"Lorelai I've loved since the day you gave me that horoscope," Luke smiled and hugged her.
A/N: Okay now I used Chris because he's the reason the broke up for a while after Richard and Emily's wedding, so if the settled everything here then he won't be coming to the wedding so they can get engaged sooner, so then they can get married before the whole April thing, and have sort of a butterfly effect.
Okay now next chapter your going to get kind of a little shock…maybe two, but review with some ideas and I'll see what I can do.