Okay, the votes are in, Andy will not be in this story. Sorry for those who wanted him to be in it, the votes were very close. Unfortunately the numbers favored him not being put in and I also feel that if I put him in I would take away from the plot between Prue and the twins. Sorry if I've disappointed you and I hope this won't affect the liking of the story.
A WEEK LATER
Piper was at the manor alone. Phoebe had returned for her first day at work since the demon attack. Piper however, didn't have to go back to work and didn't want to. Leo was talking to the Elders and Cole went wherever he was going now these days. Piper sat on the couch looking at probably the last photo that had been taken of Prue. She was pregnant but you could only tell if you were looking for it. Phoebe had been messing around with Prue's camera when it had accidentally gone off. Oddly enough it had taken a great shot of Prue laughing. Prue had protested when Piper asked her to develop it so she could frame it but she did it anyway. Now that Prue was gone Piper was glad she had made Prue develop it.
"I always loved that picture of her" Phoebe said.
Piper jumped.
"Phoebe, I didn't hear you come in" Piper said.
"I came in the back" Phoebe said. "I had left something out there"
"I thought you were going to work?" Piper asked.
"I couldn't concentrate" Phoebe said. "Kept thinking about what happened"
Piper nodded and looked back down at the picture. She heard a sniffle from Phoebe and looked back up.
"Do think that was the last time we'll see her?" Phoebe asked, crying.
Piper set the picture down and got up and hugged Phoebe.
"I keep seeing her face" Phoebe said, crying harder. "She looked so sad and the way he treated her…She asked us for help and we failed"
Phoebe started to sob and Piper hugged her tighter. Tears rolled down her face now too.
"We'll see her again" Piper said. "I promise"
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
UNDERWORLD
Prue sat at the vanity that had been put in her room. She stared at the mirror while she brushed her hair. She hated having her hair done. Everyday Madelia and her group of minions would come in and fix her hair and everyday Prue would take it out as soon as they left. She hadn't seen the Source since the day after the wedding and she was glad. Madelia however came more than once every day.
"Why do you insist on taking it out?" Madelia asked annoyed.
"Why do you insist on putting it up?" Prue asked.
"Because, you have to look like a queen" Madelia said. "Not some pathetic human"
"Well I don't want to be a queen so…" Prue said.
"You've been here for over a week, maybe you start accepting that things will never change" Madelia said.
"Just because I have to be down here doesn't mean I'll ever accept that I have to be down here" Prue said. "Now did you come here for a reason?"
"To tell you that if you know what's good for you you'll fix your hair back up because the Source is going to pay you a visit" Madelia said.
"Well I do know what's good for me and it's not putting my hair back up" Prue said.
Madelia rolled her eyes.
"Just leave" Prue said. "And don't bow on your way out"
"How many times do I have to tell you it's required?" Madelia asked bowing.
She left the room and Prue sighed. She got up and laid down on her bed. She heard footsteps come into her room.
"What do want?" Prue asked.
"Do you know how hard it is to get in here?" Cole asked.
Prue's head shot up.
"What the hell do you think you're doing?" Prue asked.
"Well that's always a nice way to be greeted" Cole said sarcastically.
"You're going to get someone killed" Prue said. "The Source is coming soon"
"I thought you'd like to know that if you agree I'll keep coming back with messages from your sisters" Cole said. "I can do it every month so it's less suspicious"
"Cole, he'll kill them if finds out" Prue said. "I can't risk that"
"I won't get caught" Cole said.
"You don't know that" Prue said.
"I'll I know is Phoebe's hurting and I'm trying to help her" Cole said.
"Then tell her that I'm fine and tell her to forget me" Prue said. "Their job now is when Anna comes, raise her to be the person she wants to be"
"They can't forget you Prue" Cole said.
"They have to or else they'll never move on" Prue said.
She heard footsteps coming.
"Quick, leave" Prue said, panicked.
"If I shimmer out he'll sense it" Cole said.
"Object of objection, become but a dream, as I cause the seen to be unseen" Prue whispered.
Cole disappeared from Prue's sight, right as the Source walked in.
"Madelia said you wanted to see me" Prue said.
"Tomorrow I need you to come with me" the Source said. "I have business that involves the queen's presence"
"What kind of business?" Prue asked.
"None that is of your concern" the Source said. "And leave your hair up tomorrow or I'll let Madelia handle you"
"Ooo, big threat" Prue said sarcastically.
"It'd be in your best interest to not say that when she's around" the Source said.
He got up and was about to leave when he stopped.
"Have you been casting spells?" the Source asked.
"No" Prue said.
The Source starting coming closer again.
"I know you're lying" the Source said. "What spell did you cast?"
"I didn't cast a spell" Prue said.
The Source grabbed her throat and pushed her against a wall.
"I'm not stupid" the Source asked. "What spell did you cast?"
"It was just a little one to help with the nausea" Prue said.
"Well stop casting them" the Source said. "I told you the only magic I want you to use is Caleb's, it's that understood?"
"Yes" Prue said.
The Source let her go and she fell to the floor. He left the room without looking back. Prue stood up back up and rubbed her throat.
"Leave Cole" Prue said. "And please never come back"
"It took me a week to get in here" Cole said. "And you want me to leave just like that"
Prue held up her left hand.
"I have this" Prue said, pointing at the bracelet. "That isn't going to let me out of the underworld"
She then pointed to the ring on her finger.
"This doesn't let me leave him" Prue said. "I'm not getting out of here ever so just leave!"
"Fine" Cole said.
"Wait, I should reverse the spell" Prue said.
"No, he'll sense that and next time a sore neck won't be your only problem" Cole said.
Prue nodded.
"Tell them I love them" Prue said softly. "And please, don't let them come after me"
Prue saw a picture appear.
"I thought you might want this" Cole said.
Prue took it and saw it was a picture of her with her sisters. It was quiet for a second.
"If you ever marry Phoebe…you have my blessing" Prue said softly.
"Thank you, that'll mean a lot to her" Cole said. "I should go"
Prue felt the air stir as Cole shimmered out. She took the picture and placed it under her pillow. Before she knew it tears were cascading down her cheeks.
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
MANOR
Phoebe and Piper were both in the attic when Cole shimmered in.
"Phoebe" Cole said.
Phoebe and Piper jumped.
"Cole?" Phoebe asked.
"I'm right here" Cole said. "I'm invisible"
"Well obviously" Piper said.
"I need you to reverse the object of objection spell" Cole said. "You can ask questions later"
Phoebe chanted the reversal spell and Cole appeared.
"Why do I get the feeling you're going to tell me you've been in the underworld" Phoebe said.
Cole didn't respond.
"Cole, I told you not to go down there" Phoebe said, upset.
"I saw Prue" Cole said.
"What?" Piper asked. "How?"
"For a week I've been observing how to get in and I found a way to shimmer in" Cole said.
"You could've gotten yourself killed!" Phoebe exclaimed.
"You could've gotten her killed" Piper said. "What the hell did you think you were doing?"
"I was trying to help" Cole said. "Every since she left all you two do is wander around like zombies"
Phoebe was quiet for a second.
"Did you figure out a way to get her back here?" Phoebe asked.
"She's not coming back" Cole said. "I tried to talk to her but she's bound both magically and emotionally"
"She has to come back" Phoebe said.
"Do you know what would happen if the Source ever caught her with you two again?" Cole asked. "The two of you would be murdered and most likely he'd torture Prue until she would wish she was dead. Right now she's safe and so are the two of you"
"So you want us to abandon our sister?" Piper asked in disbelief.
"You wouldn't be abandoning her" Cole said. "She begged me to make you stay away"
"We won't" Piper said.
Phoebe took Cole's hand and was instantly hit with a premonition.
Prue was standing in her room in the underworld. Piper, Phoebe, Cole, and Leo stood in the corner. Prue looked panicked as the door to her room opened. She yelled something to Piper and Phoebe and Leo tried to orb them out but it was too late. The Source threw a fireball at Piper. Prue tried to stop him but she was thrown backwards. Phoebe watched as a guard picked Prue up and held her back. She was screaming and kicking as she watched another fireball be thrown at Phoebe. Slowly Prue watched hysterical, as each member of her family was killed. Finally she got free and ran over to Piper and Phoebe's bodies. She started sobbing and the Source motioned for the demon to grab hold of her. When the guard got hold of her the Source threw fireball after fireball at her. Her screams echoed through the room. Finally the Source left her on the ground, barely alive.
"Phoebe!" Piper shouted over her sister's screams. "Phoebe!"
Phoebe fell to the ground in sobs. Piper held her sister until her sobs subsided.
"Phoebe, what did you see?" Piper asked.
"We can't bring her back" Phoebe sobbed. "We can't"
Piper looked up at Cole who looked worried. Phoebe stood up and headed to her room. Piper watched the empty doorway for a second before going to her own.
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
REPLIES:
Mony19: Thanks for your help, I agree that this is a story that maybe Andy shouldn't be in.
Charmed4eva1990: Glad you liked the chapter. Thanks for reviewing!
Wicked-Lady18: I always love getting new readers and I especially love ones that review. I'm so glad you like and you were in no way crossing any lines. I welcome all opinions as long as they're phrased politely. You could tell me my story was horrible and if you said it politely, I wouldn't hate you. That was probably far too much information to give you in this reply but I'm a very energetic person right now. Thanks for reviewing!
ToxicDuck77: You did not review chapter 10, so ha ha, you were wrong, you're not awesome.
Hally: Glad you like it. Thanks for the review!
Slash: I guess this is like Phoebe and Cole. Only Phoebe and Cole loved each other and Phoebe was pregnant with one baby. But it's the same concept kind of. Glad you liked the story and thanks for reviewing!
PrueTrudeau: True, I did get sick of Phoebe's obsessive need to have a husband and kids, that got a little weird. And Alyssa probably is a little witchy (no pun intended). I always liked the scene from 4x01 because it really showed the real Piper and how close she was to Prue. As you see in this chapter again I've securely made sure Prue isn't escaping. I'm attempting to make this as realistic as possible. Glad you don't mind me not putting Andy in. I have three chapters written after this one and I just don't see how I could fit him in. Thanks for your review!
Prucole: You're very much in agreement with me on that one.
Lucrecia Almasy: Thank you, it's always a huge compliment to me when reviewers tell me I've made the characteristics of all of the characters realistic. I hope I can continue doing that. Ooo, med school, sounds fun, I'm not even close to being done with high school. Thanks for your review and I'm glad you like the story.
Brittany: Okay, so I've been waiting to update until I got your review. So I waited and waited, and I get online today and I think, hmm, that's strange, she still hasn't reviewed. So I glanced at my story and it says I have 90 reviews. That confused me because before it said I only had 87, so I look and I had 3 more reviews than what fanfiction said, yours being one of them. That so ticked me off. Anyway, I thought I should warn you about the last chapter, I almost cried while writing it. Yeah, my friends haven't held me down yet because I have one friend who is so obsessed with Gilmore Girls, it's scary. She can recite episodes line for line. So if I start quoting lines they'll probably hold me down. And because it's my standard line I have to say it, thanks for the review!
TheSecondStake: Hope I haven't disappointed you too much with not putting Andy in. I just really felt like it would interfere with my plans. Thanks for your review!
PaigeMatthews06: I'm so, so, so, so, sorry. I just didn't want to mess with my future plans for this story and put Andy in. You had some really great ideas on how to bring him in but I think I'm going to leave the Prue Andy romance for future stories. In fact I'm planning one right now with super Andy Prue romance in it. So I hope you'll still enjoy this story and thanks for reviewing.