"YOUR SUPPOSED TO BE DEAD" shouted Paige looking at him angrily. "well if it makes you fell better i was dead." said Cole clearly angry at the situation he's in.

"well you know what Cole,it doesn't make me feel better"said Paige as she paused then asked "what do you mean was dead,what did you do escape from the wasteland again."

"no actually, i didn't get sent to the wasteland i was stuck in limbo having watch you guys live your lives." said Cole getting a bit agitated by Paige's comments.

"Limbo how the hell did you get stuck there?" asked Paige.

Then Cole started to explain " well when you guys vanquished me My soul was apparently sent straight to limbo as punishment you know, to watch you guys living happily as a family and phoebe moving on from me"he added the last part with a sigh but Paige didn't feel the least bit sad for him.

"crappy punishment i don't think it involved enough physical pain"

"hang on if you were in limbo how did you escape." Paige added.

"i didn't , i was let out by the elders." said Cole looking at Paige to see her reaction.

"THE ELDERS,YOU WERE LET OUT BY THE ELDERS,NO WAY YOUR LYING."shouted Paige.

"GO AHEAD AND SUMMON ONE IF YOU DON'T BELIEVE ME."shouted back Cole.

"you know what i will." said Paige. She then closed her eyes with concentration for a few seconds then when she opened her eyes a woman Orbed in more precisely, an Elder.

"what is the meaning of this" said the Elder looking from Paige to Cole "you was specifically told NOT to let the sisters know you were alive.that was part of our deal.."

" WHAT SO IT'S TRUE ,YOU BROUGHT HIM BACK, ARE YOU GUYS STUPID HE'S A DEMON."

"Ex- demon actually" Cole said looking at Paige then turned to the Elder "and i never went looking for her she found me."

"Ex-demon,so what are you like mortal ?" questioned questioned Paige.

"No he's a witch." said the elder answering Paige's question.

"I''M HOME"called phoebe entering the house. She walks in to the kitchen find Piper making dinner "how's Paige" asked phoebe. "I'm not sure i haven't checked on her since she went to rest in her room but i was just going to call her for dinner" replied piper.

"oh that's OK I'll just go get her." said Phoebe heading out of the kitchen and upstairs to get Paige to come down for dinner.

Phoebe stood outside Paige's bedroom door and knocked gently "Paige honey are you awake, Pipers made dinner." When phoebe heard no reply she twisted the door knob and oped the door "Paige" said phoebe looking around noticing Paige wasn't in her bed when she heard no reply again she went back down stairs.

"where's Paige" said piper as phoebe walked back into the kitchen

"i don't know she wasn't in her room and i don't think she's anywhere in the house either" replied phoebe

"well lets try calling for her" said piper

"A witch what do you mean he's a wi-" said Paige as she was interrupted by her sisters calls. "i have to go now my sisters are calling me,but this isn't over." said Paige as she orbed out

The Elder turned to Cole "Go after her. " said the elder

"What" questioned Cole.

"well you can materialize cant you so go,go after her and explain to her"

"but i cant her sisters will be there ." said Cole suddenly looking scared.

"well its too late to hide now so go after her"said the sighed and materialized to the manor to face the sisters .