Kali sat in the car looking at the ring box John had given her. She couldn't get the thought of it out of her head. Here she was confused at what she really wanted and the whole time John had already known. Then there was Randy who had also already known what he wanted. Kali never thought in a million years she would have to choose between two gorgeous men.

"Kali?" Torrie asked driving the car to the next show. "Are you going to be okay?"

"John and Randy are going to be on the same show. Not just the same show, but I'm on that show. And now I have this ring haunting me. Torrie what did I get myself into?" Kali asked looking away from the box and out the window.

"You want to know that I think?" When Kali nodded she went on. "You have two men almost fighting over you. Now I can't say that I'm not jealous, but it's not fair to either one of them. Who do you love?"

Kali laughed. "If it were that easy don't you think I would have chosen by now?" she paused. "Truth is I love them both, but in very different ways. Randy and I have something that goes back a long time ago. But John and I have something new and exciting. I'd be happy with either one."

Torrie laughed. "Kali we both know that you wouldn't not be in the situation if you were happy with either one. I mean you went behind Randy's back and started seeing John. Then you kissed Randy and wanted to break up with John. If John had not given you that ring, would you be sitting there wondering if you love him?"

"I guess your right." Kali sat back in her seat. Torrie had a very good point. Last week she went to see John to break things off. Why would she feel any different because John wanted to get married. Then again it was only a kiss between her and Randy. Did that really mean that she could trust him again?

Kali's cell phone started ringing. She reached into her purse and looked at the caller id. Sighing she answered it. "Randy I really don't want to talk about it." was all she said.

"Kali please listen to me. I know that John gave you a ring and I think that you should be with him." Randy sounded sad.

"Wait what are you talking about? How did you know that he gave me a ring?" Kali asked a little concerned. "I never told you that John was going to propose to me."

"I know, John told me. Look Kali he really wants to be with you, and I don't think that I can take that away from him or you."

"How do you know getting married is what I want? It's not like I knew that John was going to propose."

Randy laughed. "Kali I know you remember. Ever since we were little all you have wanted was to get married and have a family. Truth is I don't know if I want to get married anytime soon. And if you and John are at a place where you can, then you should."

Kali was really confused now. Randy went on and on about how he never wanted to lose her and that she was what he was missing in his life. Now he was telling her that he's walking away and letting her be with John. "Randy I don't know what I want. And to be honest with you," she paused. "To be honest with you, you are confusing the hell out of me. Can we please just talk about this later?"

She heard Randy sigh. "Kali I know what I am doing is the right thing. Please don't make this harder on me than it already is." With that he hung up the phone.

"Did that really just happen?" she asked.

"What did he say?" Torrie asked interested now.

"He's leaving me. He knows that John proposed to me and he wants me to be with him."

Torrie laughed. "Randy walk away? That boy has something up his sleeve."

"I don't know Torrie."

Randy sighed as he hung up the cell phone. That was probably the hardest thing he'll ever have to do.

"How did it go?" Edge asked.

"What does it matter?" Randy stated walking away. He never wanted to tell Kali that he didn't want her. He didn't want to tell her that he'd never want to get married. Truth was the moment that he and Kali would have gotten back together, he was going to propose. Kali was the kind of girl that you never let go.

"Randy!" John yelled at him.

Randy turned around. "What do you want John?"

"Just wanted to see how things were going with you and Kali?" he laughed.

"She's all yours." Randy said.

John looked confused. "What do you mean she's all mine?"

"I told her that I can't be with her. You are the right guy for her. So that's it." Randy started to walk away.

"Why would you do that?" John asked.

"All I ever wanted was for Kali to be happy. Yeah I know how that sounds, but its true. It was never about competing with you. She must be happy with you and so I'm happy with that."

"You can't be serious. When does Randy Orton care about what a girl wants?"

Randy looked away. "When the girl is the only one to make me fall in love with her." With that Randy walked away.

So what's going to happen now? Is Kali going to go to John, or is Randy just making her want him? Please review and let me know who you think she should be with.