He kissed her lips softly, sliding his hands slowly over her naked back. "This is between you and me, all right?" He whispered softly into her ear. She nodded and moaned softly in agreement.

"Between us…"

"And Kitty will never know," he whispered seductively, kissing the curve of her neck softly and dragging his hands over her hips.

"Never…" she replied, tilting her head back and giving into him.

XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

It doesn't matter

That you had the courage to tell me

The easy way out

Was to free up your guilt, laid it on me

What do I care?

If it didn't really mean a thing why'd you do it?

I'm standing here

Looking at someone who doesn't

Know they blew it, yeah

"Kitty, please. C'mon Kitty, wait," Zack called after her.

Kitty rushed down the hallway, her books clutched to her chest, tears picking her eyes. She turned the corner and walked into the girls' room. She slammed her books onto the rim of the sink and began to sob.

Of course that didn't stop the ever stupid Zack. He barged in and the girls that didn't stop and bat their eyelashes at him quickly ran out of the bathroom, a few having enough wit to scream or shout at him.

"Kitty I said I was sorry. I mean at least I told you." Zack pulled his cap off and ran his fingers through his hair in aggravation before placing it back on his head. He obviously wasn't getting what her 'problem' was.

Kitty's head snapped up, her hair fanning over her shoulders, and she glared at him. "You think that makes it okay? Do you think that everything is going to be all better just because you told me?" She shouted at him, throwing her algebra book. "How many other girls don't I know about Zack, hmm? How many!" She threw another book at him. They both missed and hit the wall behind him instead.

"Only like...two," Zack said stupidly. Kitty looked at him dumbstruck at his stupidity. How had she dated someone like him?

You should have lied

Cause' your stupid mistake

Made my world crash down

Now its goodbye

No you can't take it back

Once the truth has come out of your mouth

So you tried to be honest

But honesty blew it this time

You should have lied

"You're kidding me?" Kitty shouted again, grabbing her remaining books and pushing past him out the door and rushing back down the hall to the entrance of the school.

"Uh…yeah! Of course, babe, I'd never cheat on you." Zack said, rushing after her and trying to take her books from her, holding the other two under his arm.

"Oh, no. You can't take it back now. I'm not falling for that one." Kitty pushed through the front doors and a little crowd of people that stood in front of them. She pulled open the car door, threw all her books in the front seat and slammed the door shut. "You should have just kept it to yourself! With prom coming up and me being elected queen! Now I have to get a new date. I might as well not even show up."

If a tree falls inside of a forest and nobody hears it

It wont affect anybody 'cause no one will miss it

What would I care

If you were dying from the guilt of keeping a secret?

This isn't fair

'cause now I've gotta be the one dealing with it, oh

"What do you mean 'new date'?" Zack leaned against the side of her car blocking her exit around the back.

"You heard me. I am not going with you." Kitty quickly turned and walked around the front. She climbed in her car and was about to slam that door when Zack grabbed it.

"Hold on, why the hell not?"

"You cheated on me, you stupid—Ugh!" Kitty pulled on her door and Zack fell forward a bit, but kept a firm hold on it.

"Babe, what's the damage?" Zack leaned against her car again, leaning forward so he could see her. Kitty's fingers tightened around the steering wheel.

"Why did you even tell me?" Kitty looked up at him, her knuckles turning white.

"Because…" Zack hesitated, glancing away, then glancing back at her. "I felt guilty."

"Ha!" Kitty let out a cold, bitter laugh. "Why would I care? You cheated on me! And know everyone's gonna be questioning me and my rep is going to be ruined! God…" Kitty's eyes darted frantically around her car. "What if the school news wants to do an article?"

You should have lied

Cause' your stupid mistake

Made my world crash down

Now its goodbye

No you can't take it back

Once the truth has come out of your mouth

So you tried to be honest

But honesty blew it this time

You should have lied

"So what if they do? Just lie. Nothing has to change, babe." Zack grinned down at her and she rolled her eyes.

"Everything's gonna change. You honestly have no idea how bad you blew it do you?" Kitty's tone was full of disgust.

Zack looked down at her in confusion.

Kitty leaned back against the car seat exasperated. "I didn't think so."

I don't get it

Where was your conscience when

You were with her

Couldn't you hear it scream out?

A few moments of silence passed and eventually Kitty breathed out a slow and calming breath. Her eyes were closed and she refused to look at him anymore. "Where was your conscience?"

"I don't get it," Zack said blankly.

"You know the little voice in your head? Right or wrong? Good or bad?" Kitty glared up at him. Zack still wasn't getting it. She sighed and pulled on her door again. "Get off."

Zack stepped back and Kitty slammed the door shut. She buckled her seatbelt, revved the engine, and…Zack tapped on her window. Despite her best efforts at self control, she rolled it down.

You should have lied

Cause' your stupid mistake

Made my world crash down

Now its goodbye

No you can't take it back

Once the truth has come out of your mouth

So you tried to be honest

But honesty blew it this time

You should have lied

"C'mon Kitty. We can work this out. I love you." Zack sounded so helplessly pathetic she probably would have given in if Crissy hadn't appeared by his side at that second.

Kitty looked from her to him and back to the arm she slowly wrapped around his waist. Crissy smiled smugly at her as Zack slowly wrapped his arm around her shoulders. She opened her mouth to say something, but Kitty's window was already rolled up and she was long gone.

It doesn't matter

That you had the courage to tell me

About tow hours later Zack got home and he found his door opened. He quickly rushed inside and grabbed his gun. He looked through every room in the house finding nothing missing and no one home. The last room he checked was his bathroom and the only thing out of place was the writing in siren red lipstick on his bathroom mirror, You should have lied.