What if Spottedleaf never died and Firestar rejected Sandstorm to have her? What if Tigerclaw killed Bluestar and became leader of ThunderClan? What if Ivypool refused to spy on the Dark Forest? WHAT IF I'M ONLY ALLOWED TO ASK ONE QUESTION?! XD Snowsong


Dear Snowsong of Snowclan,

You can ask as many questions as you like!


What If Spottedlead never died and Firestar rejected Sandstorm to have her?

"Will she live?" Fireheart asked Yellowfan anxiously. Spottedleaf lay wounded on the ground covered in cobwebs, her usual sweet scent was blocked by the strentch of herbs.

"Yes she will look she is stirring" Yellowfang pointed out. Spottedleaf did not wake for a 5 sunrises but today seemed like it would be the day she finally woke.

"Firepaw..."she whispered. Yellowfang smiled weakly and left the two alone.

"Its Fireheart now Spottedleaf" Fireheart purred licking the injured medicine cats head.

"Fireheart there is something I need to tell you"

"Yes Spottedleaf?"

"I love you"

Moons later

Spottedleaf padded beside her mate Fireheart. Spottedleaf became a warrior allowing Yellowfang to be the only medicine cat once again.

"Fireheart are you worried about the two leggeds coming so close?" she asked. Fireheart looked far away.

"Everything will be fine...you should be in the nursery though what if you kittened early?" Fireheart meowed. Spottedleaf smiled

"I would not worry so much Fireheart I would never leave you alone. You know that we will leave together when we go to Starclan your just upset because of what happened to Silverstream"

"I would die to protect you Spottedleaf"

a few moons later

Firestar ran over the the nursery.

"LEAFKIT SQUIRRELKIT IM BACK" Firestar called. the two she-cats tumbled over each other as they ran toward their father. Spottedleaf purred happily. Leafkit was named after her mother, she looked just like spottedleaf too. Squirrelkit got her fathers looks. Firestar purred happily as they jumped around him begging him to tell them stories. Firestar opened his mouth to start a story when he noticed Sandstorm was look enviously at Spottedleaf. He shrugged it off because Sandstorm and Dustpelt where mates so why should he worry. Firestar smiled happily as he told his kits the story of Tigerclan and how they tried to take over the forest. As he talked he thought of what it would be like if he had chosen Sandstorm as his mate. He supressed a shiver thinking of what his and Sandstorms kits would look like. They would definitely not be Leafkit and Squirrelkit. "Man I am so lucky things turned out as they did I can't bear the thought of not having Leafkit and Squirrelkit with me"

What if Tigerstar killed Bluestar and became leader of Thunderclan

Fireheart casted a nervous glance at their new leader. Tigerstar. Fireheart knew that Tigerstar murdered Bluestar over and over so he could become leader.

"WE WILL TAKE OVER THE FOREST" howled Tigerstar everyone was silent. "IF YOU REFUSE TO OBEY ME YOU SHALL PAY"

Tigerstar stalked away there was no deputy for Tigerstar felt as if he did not need one. Once the dark tom was gone everyone mob toward Fireheart he had organized his own clan Fireclan they where plotting on how to get rid of Tigerstar, Tigerclan and his rouges once and for all.

"Firestar the elders are not safe here" Longtail whispered.

"I'm not leader yet but I agree we must murder Tigerstar then we wont need to worry anymore. This is getting out of paw. Tigerstar has gained trust of Shadowclan this is horrible I agree" Fireheart meowed.

"You don't say" hisses a black Tom. A group of cats follow Tigerstar and the black Tom. Firehearts eyes widen with fear.

"Take them to the dogs" Tigerstar orders with a sleek smile. "I have won"

what if Ivypool refused to spy on Darkforest.

"NOOOOOOO I REFUSE" wails Ivypool flicking her tail "I won't I keep getting hurt"

"Ivypool you keep getting sent to Darkforest why won't you spy" Lionblaze snaps his orange ears flick with annoyance.

"I found a away out, if I go to sleep there I will be sent home." Ivypool retorted.

"Fine be that way"hissed Jayfather angrily stomping away. Ivypool swayed on spot "was this really the Right choice?"

"no it was not" Ivypool thought sadly. Because of her foolish actions Firestar had died along with Mousefur and Ferncloud. What would the clans think of her now? Jayfeather ignored her and Lionblaze treated her with hostility even Dovewing was upset with her. "what would it have been like if I did spy on them" holding back tears Ivypool looked at the ground.

"You should have spied on Darkforest look at the commotion you have created" hissed Dovewing. Tears stung in Ivypools eyes for once she wished that she was anywhere but Thunderclan.

"I'm sorry Dovew-"

"SORRY DOES NOT BRING BACK DEAD CATS" Ivypool collapsed in a pool of tears. "this is all my fault. I will never be the perfect warrior, I never was a warrior I was a mouse" Ivypool stayed there in the middle of Thunderclan territory. Crying Ivypool raced to an enterance to the tunnels.

"I will be an outcast if I stay" she whispered with that she took a large step forward and was swallowed up by darkness.


Regarding If Tigerclaw killed Bluestar and became leader of Thunderclan:

I made that one short because I wanted to show that Fireheart would die along with most of the cats from Thunderclan (now Tigerclan).

disclaimer: I don't own the characters mentioned in any of the What If...'s they belong to Erin Hunter.

A special thanks to everyone who writes me what if's.