So many reviewers and Alerts/favorites! You guys make us so happy! :D:D This story has been a lot of fun to write. Should Eli keep in touch with Willow and Clare? Should Clare and Willow go with Jake? Read and find out! And contact us at our tumblr account (links on the profile) and our email cake_collaborationyahoo .com :D

Eli's POV:
"Why didn't you tell me?" I asked my voice thick and just above a whisper.

"What was I supposed to do? You had so much on your plate. Imogen, university, your health... I couldn't ruin it all for you," she murmured, looking towards Willow.

"Clare that is the dumbest thing I have ever heard!" I yelled loudly, earning some stares from other customers "And I've heard a lot of things, considering I'm friends with Adam," I quickly added.
"Is it really, Eli?" she said in a reasoning tone. "I mean what was I supposed to say, 'Eli, I know we broke up, but I'm pregnant and I wanna get back together again'?" Her voice sounded as if she was imitating a childish teenager
"I was young, you wanted nothing to do with me, and I didn't want to be rejected," she explained quietly.
"You should've told me," I whispered looking down at the table.
"I'm sorry," I heard her whisper, putting her hand on mine.

"You know, it didn't mean that we had to get back together. ...There are a lot of parents who aren't in a relationship anymore."

"But it wouldn't have felt right. I didn't want Willow to wonder why her father wouldn't be living with us."

"But it's just as bad for her if I'm not there at all."

She opened her mouth to speak, but Imogen came over with Aiden and sat down next to me. "He's getting tired, and I think he wants his dad."

I sighed, taking Aiden from Imogen and letting him rest his head on my shoulder.