Meanwhile in the sewers, two shellcreepers, one with red shell and one with green shell, arrive to the scene where Shelley was killed. "Our poor leader." said the Red Shellcreeper. "King Bowser isn't gonna be happy about this." said Green. "That's why we Koopa Troopas are going to find the guys that did this to Shelley and bring them to the king." said Red. "Why are you giving me commands?" Red then got in his face and threatened "Because Bowser made me the boss of you now and I will feed you to Bowser's Piranha Plant if you don't listen to my instructions!" Green gulps after what Red said "Okay, Great leader. Where do we start?" Red then answered, "Let's start by searching around this New York City?" Then, Green corrected him "Uh, actually it's Brooklyn." Red rolls his eyes at Green gripes "Shut up and get moving!"
The shellcreepers A.K.A. Koopa Troopas quickly sneak out of the sewer hole and start going around searching or the man that killed Shelley. "So, who are we looking for?" Green asked Red reaching in shell and showing Green a picture of the guys their looking for "These guys." Red shows Mario and Luigi. "They call themselves the Mario Brothers." Red explained "Once we capture them, Bowser is going to feed them to the Piranha Plant after we capture the princess. Now, let's start searching."
The two Koopa Troopas, they walk on the sidewalk in Brooklyn and people start staring at the two turtles. "Red?" Green asked shaking as he is uncomfortable "Why are they staring at us?" Then Red explained "They just think we're weird midgets in Ninja Turtle costumes. Just ignore them."Green sees a child looking at him. "Look, Mommy!" said the child pointing at the green Koopa Troopa "It's a Ninja Turtle!" Then Green answered "Actually, I'm a..." Red grabs Green by the arm as he is aggravated "You idiot! Don't talk to them!" Red griped "We have work to do."