26th Dec Prompt 2022 from YoughaltheJust: Holmes meets [a famous historical figure from your country and/or of your choice].

Tales

Tales are tales,

And facts are facts,

And ne'er the twain shall meet.

Till two opposing views collide

In a flat in Baker Street…

~0~

Lestrade is out with his Yarders bold, to track a killer down;

He has searched in vain through the vilest lanes, the worst in London Town,

Where the alleys ring as the drunkards sing and the smoke-stained lights burn low

And the cobbles are trod by those spurned by God and nobody sane would go.

~0~

He had picked up the trail on his friend's advice, on the great detective's word;

They have chased their prey every night and day, but naught have they seen nor heard;

There has been no rest on this parlous quest; since the fiend's first kill was found;

He has struck thrice more, such a dreadful score, and has swiftly gone to ground.

~0~

They are focused now, on their one true chance, from the clues Sherlock Holmes has gleaned;

There are lives at stake, if they makes mistakes in the hunt for this heartless fiend,

They are closing in, there are lights within an address the detective marked;

There are few who might be abroad this night, full of fear which this crime has sparked…

~0~

The speaker stops, then he turns to Holmes. "This is how I'd begin your case;

Let your readers thrill, at your nerves and skill, for romance has a vital place."

Holmes replies with heat, "Though I'm pleased to meet the author my friend admires

And this might, I know suit your tales, Just So; but clear fact's what my work inspires."

~0~

The doctor laughs at his friend's response; at his stubborn, rigid stance.

"Holmes, just take a look at his Jungle Books, give his writing style a chance.

Let this poet's pen, tell your story then you can bask in your new-found fame.

With his words you see, I can guarantee, that the world won't forget your name."

~0~

Holmes brief response to the pair is clear; "Your suggestion is doomed to fail."

The author sighs, "Why not compromise? Let the doctor record each tale.

He's a science man, I am sure he can make your life's work a great success."

There's a lengthy pause, as Holmes checks for flaws, then a history-defining "Yes!"

~0~

So…

Tales are tales,

And facts are facts,

And ne'er the twain shall meet.

Till two opposing views collide

In a flat in Baker Street…

~0~