The first time they played match making was with David and Wes. They had for a whole week tried to make the two boys meet up at the weirdest times, but David and Wes didn't fall for it.
Jeff and Nick dropped that tactic and decided it was time to play "truth and dare".
When Nick picked David there was no doubt what he would say. Both Nick and Jeff had thought the two boys would blush and then get together. They kissed and that was the end.
It backfired when David said Jeff should kiss Nick. Their first kiss.