I know Niff week has passed but I had prom so I didn't get to update it! So Niff week is extended! For this story anyway lol. This prompt is Mistake. First there is confrontation between Jeff and Nick about the mistake and then there's a flashback to the mistake. Enjoy! :)
Niff Week, Day 5: Mistakes
"I'm so sorry, Nick…" Jeff pleads, begging for his boyfriend to just look at him.
"Save it, Jeff." Nick replies coldly. Jeff frowns.
"Nicky, please. I need you." Jeff says, practically on his knees in front of his boyfriend.
"Do you? Then why would you do this to me? Do you know how bad you've hurt me?" Nick questions, willing his tears not to fall.
"I know, Nick, I do. I was drunk. But, no, that's not an excuse. I still shouldn't have done it. You have to know how sorry I am. You're the love of my life and no stupid kiss could come between that. Right?" Jeff begs. Nick sighs and slumps down onto his bed.
"You're right. It just hurts. I mean…what is it? What did I do wrong to make you cheat? Was I not a good enough boyfriend? Am I not hot enough? I just don't understand…" Nick says as a stray tear falls down his cheek. Jeff can feel the tears coming.
"I hate that you think that. You are the most wonderful, perfect, sexiest boyfriend ever. Never think otherwise. You are absolutely perfect. You will always be perfect to me and nothing can change that," Jeff sighs, "The only reason I did it was because I had never kissed another guy before. And you are more than enough for me, believe me, you're all I could ever want. But…the alcohol in me liked the attention. I wanted to know how it felt to kiss someone else. And I just didn't pull away when he leaned in. I'm so sorry, Nick…" Jeff's tears finally fall as he lowers his head.
"H-How was the kiss?" Nick asked, eyes not daring to look at Jeff. Jeff can't help but chuckle.
"It was awful. Completely terrible. No one's kisses compare to yours. You're the single best kisser there ever was." Jeff says, not looking away from the spot on the floor. Nick smiles some. He always loved when Jeff complimented him on his kissing.
"Okay, Jeff. Promise me that this will never happen again. Sober or drunk." Nick tilts Jeff's chin up so they lock eyes. Jeff nods.
"I promise, baby. Never again." Jeff says as he wipes his tears from his eyes. Nick smiles and leans down to give Jeff a peck on the lips. Jeff smiles into the kiss and moves up to sit next to Nick on the bed. "I love you, Nicky."
"I love you too, Jeffy."
"Guys, I don't know about this…" Jeff says, looking out the window to the bar Sebastian drug Blaine and him to.
"Oh, come on, Nick said it was fine if you came," Sebastian reminded him, getting out of the car.
"But he's sick, I should be there taking care of him," Jeff rebuttals.
"Jeff, he wanted you to come out and have fun. Why not enjoy it?" Blaine says, getting out of the car and helping his best friend.
"I know…" Jeff replies, still looking at the building ,timidly.
"Blaine, please tell him that this place is not bad. We frequent Scandals all the time, Jeff!" Sebastian states, getting slightly annoyed with Jeff's buzz-kill mood.
"Yeah, Jeff. We come here a lot, it's cool," Blaine tells him, hoping to assure his best friend.
"How do you keep guys from hitting on you?" Jeff asks as they approach the door. Jeff nervously fumbles with his fake ID Sebastian got him.
"Well, after a while all the guys figured out if they even look at my boyfriend the wrong way, I'll pin them up against the wall and knee them in the balls to hard they won't have sex for a month," Sebastian smirks and playfully smacks Blaine on the ass. Blaine blushes and rolls his eyes.
"Calm down, big boy. His boyfriend isn't here so he'll need protecting. Some of those guys are ruthless," Blaine reminds his boyfriend.
"Right, right. Well most of the guys know not to mess with me so just stick close to me and Blaine and you'll be fine," Sebastian says as he pulls the two of them over to the bar after successfully getting inside. That doesn't comfort Jeff as much as he'd like. But he had to admit, this place wasn't that bad. He imagined much worse. The three of them sat at the bar for a while, just drinking and having a few laughs. But eventually a Katy Perry song came on.
"Oh! I love this song! Sebby, come dance with me! Jeff, you'll be alright for a few minutes, right?" Blaine pleads, already a bit drunk.
"Of course, go ahead, have fun!" Jeff told them, already drunk himself. The couple smiled at him and made their way to the dance floor. As soon as they were gone, a rather attractive man sat down next to Jeff.
"Hey, sexy," the man said, smirking at Jeff.
"Uh…hi," Jeff responded, instantly uncomfortable.
"Do you come here a lot? This is my first time here and I'm sure glad I came tonight," the man commented, winking at Jeff. Jeff shifted uncomfortably in his seat.
"Actually, it's my first time here. I have a boyfriend," Jeff knew that didn't fit into the conversation but he needed to get that out there.
"Damn. All the good looking ones are taken. Is one of them your boyfriend?" the man asks, pointing to Sebastian and Blaine grinding up against each other on the dance floor.
"No, they're my best friends. They're a couple," Jeff tells him.
"So why isn't your boyfriend here? He can't possibly trust a bunch of gay men around you. You're pretty irresistible," he informs Jeff, scooting his seat closer. Jeff takes a good look at the man. He was young. Maybe 22. He was attractive, that's for sure. Light brown hair with light brown eyes to match. He was tan but not too tan. He had muscles but not too much. He'd be exactly Jeff's type if Jeff were single.
"He's sick. And he trusts me." Jeff replies. The man nods some, seeming disappointed that Nick would trust Jeff.
"What's your name, hot stuff?" the man asks.
"I'm Jeff," he answers.
"I'm Zach," Zach said, extending his hand for Jeff to shake. Jeff shook it but then dropped his hand when Zach tried to hold it.
"Relax, cutie. After all, aren't you here for some fun?" Zach smirked, inching closer to Jeff.
"Well…yeah. But not that kind of fun." Jeff said as he scooted his seat farther from Zach's.
"Oh come on, live a little," Zach said, so close his breath was tickling Jeff's ear. Jeff made the mistake to look at Zach. Their lips were inches apart. Zach took this opportunity to close the space between their lips. Jeff felt his lips on his and immediately started kissing back. But as soon as he started, he stopped. He pulled back and pushed Zach away. "Mmm, that was nice," Zach smirked, "how about we go continue that in the bathroom? Or my place? Whichever."
"I believe he told you he had a boyfriend," Sebastian said, pushing Zach away from Jeff. Blaine went to Jeff's side and wrapped his arms around him.
"He did. But he kissed me back. So I figured it was worth a shot," Zach said, coming chest to chest with Sebastian. He was a few inches shorter than Sebastian but he wasn't backing down.
"You're new around here. Ask anyone in here, I'll kick your ass without giving it a second thought," Sebastian said, a slight smirk tugging at his lips.
"Oh yeah?" Zach smirked in reply, "Let's see what you've got."
The bartender laughed, making all four men look at him.
"Don't mess with him, new kid. I don't feel like calling another ambulance tonight," the bartender warned Zach. Sebastian smiled at the bartender as a thank you and Zach backed away from Sebastian.
"I'm out of here," Zach says as he storms out of the door.
"I-I cheated…" is all Jeff can manage to say.
"You need another drink," Sebastian says, pulling out his wallet. Jeff's hand stopped Sebastian.
"No." Jeff says, "I want to go home."
"Okay, we'll take you home. Come on, Seb," Blaine said, ushering Jeff out the door.
"Thanks," Jeff muttered, getting into the car. He knew he had to tell Nick. No matter what the consequences.
Tada! Thanks for the reviews guys! When you guys tell me that you didn't really ship Niff but after reading this you do, that makes me so happy! You don't even understand, I got so happy that I could do that! The last two days will probably be up shortly. I'd work on them tonight but I really wanna work on my next chapter of BTWILY. But I finally got my own laptop so I should be able to update more! Yay! Thanks for reading guys! :)