Author's note: DON'T OWN GLEE! So here is chapter two, it's got a little bit of fluff and a lot of smut. There will be more plot later on, but for now this is downright dirty :) so if you like it, please review! Happy reading :D
"I have a proposition for you" she said seriously.
I have no idea why, I was even listening to her. She had stolen the girl I loved and she knew it. Why was she even with Rachel anyway? Santanna was a slut and she could never be in a serious relationship with anyone. All I had to do was wait for her to fuck up and then I could have Rach.
"I ain't interested" I snapped and began walking away.
"It's for Rachel" she said stopping me in my tracks.
"Continue" I said leaning against the lockers.
"I want you to date her" she said.
"Yea, did you just realize that I'm better or what? Why now?" I asked. She made it pretty damn clear that her and Rachel were going strong by the way they walked around together.
"Yea right" she scuffed. "You're no better than me, not by a long shot. I want Rachel to date you because I know she loves you and somehow you make her happy." she said.
"So what, you just back off and I get to have her?" I asked unsurely.
"Absolutely not. I will still be dating her as well" she said confidently.
"What the fuck are you talking about, you can't make her choose. She made it clear this morning that she wanted you, so congratulations. Now leave me the fuck alone" I snapped.
"Would you just listen to me for five minutes!" she screamed. "I want nothing more than to make Rachel happy. I thought I did that, but I was wrong. You make her happy too, she wants both of us and what my girl wants she gets. I want us both to date Rachel" she said looking me dead in the eyes.
"You're serious?" I asked, was this some kind of joke?
"The only chance you'll ever get with her will be when we break up. I don't see that happening anytime soon, do you?" I shook my head. "Alright then, think about it. We could both have what we want" she said smiling.
"Isn't it kind of like cheating?" I asked. I mean we were going to share a person. I would have to watch Rachel kiss her and then I'd get to take her out? Then again watching Rachel kissing Santanna would be fucking hot.
"No, I have no interest in you Puckerman, you've got nothing for me anymore. I'm doing this for Rachel" she said seriously.
"You really like her don't you?" I asked.
"More than I've ever liked anyone before and we've only been together two days isn't that crazy?" she asked smiling.
"Not at all, I can relate" I said. It only took me a week of driving her to school to fall for her. "She has that effect on people" I said smiling back.
"So are you in?" she asked.
"How is it going to work exactly? I mean how do you share a person?" I asked.
"We schedule times to be together. In school we can all three walk down the halls and we can all go out together, but we can plan our times alone for more private things and special dates" she said.
"You really thought this through didn't you?" I asked.
"Yes, I want to make her as comfortable as possible with this" she said surely.
"Okay, I'm in" I said. "On one condition" I smirked.
"And what is that?" she asked, rolling her eyes.
"I get to watch you guys make out" I said.
"Whatever" she said holding her hand out. "Deal?".
"Deal?" I said as I walked away smiling. I had just gotten the girl of my dreams and as a bonus I got to watch her make-out with her girlfriend. I was one lucky bastard.
After glee was when we were going to approach her about it. I was seriously hoping she would be okay with it, I'd be pissed if she decided she didn't want me.
"Hey baby, come here for a minute" I heard Santanna call to her as everyone left the room.
"Yes" she said plopping herself down in the chair in front of us.
"Puck and I want to talk to you" she said in that serious tone.
"Okay, go ahead" she said slowly.
"Rachel, you know I care about you a lot" I said.
"Yes and I care about you, but I'm with Santanna, Noah" she said sadly.
"I know, but what if you were with me too?" I asked.
"Noah I can't date two people, it's completely unfair" she said.
"But we want you too" Santanna said. "We've talked it over and we decided we want you to have both of us" she said.
"We want to make you happy babe, and it's obvious you have feelings for both of us and we have those same feelings for you" I said, placing my hand on her shoulder.
"What does this mean?" she asked quietly.
"It means you'll have both a girlfriend and a boyfriend" Santanna said, sitting down next to her.
"Will you two also be dating?" she asked.
"No" I said. "We're only dating you and you only" I said, sitting on the other side.
"But won't you get jealous if I'm kissing her?" she asked, pointing to Santanna.
"A little, but I know she makes you happy and I trust you. Plus you two kissing would totally turn me on" I said wrapping my arm around the back of her neck.
"What about you?" she asked Santanna.
"Same for me. I'm not exactly thrilled that you'll be sucking face with Puckerman, but I trust you and I want you to be happy. And I can't lie, the thought of you and Puckerman getting it on, kinda thrills me" she said wrapping her arm around Rachel's waist.
"So, I have a boyfriend" she said kissing me on the lips. "And a girlfriend?" she asked, pressing her lips against Santanna's.
"Fuck that's hot" I groaned.
"If that's what you want baby" Santanna said smiling.
"Yes, that's exactly what I want" she said pulling us both into her side for a hug.
I looked over at Santanna and mouthed the words 'thank you' behind Rachel's back and she nodded in return. That was how I got Rachel Berry to be my girlfriend.
We decided to go to the park and talk things out. We were sitting on a bench when Rachel started asking questions.
"How are we gonna tell people?" she asked.
"We're not" I said.
"We're gonna let them figure it out on their own" Santanna said.
"Besides it's none of their business, all they need to know is that your taken" I smirked as I kissed her. Damn, I loved kissing her.
"Well then what about our parents?" she asked.
"What about them?" Santanna asked.
"What will my dads say when I tell them I have a boyfriend and a girlfriend?" she asked worriedly. "They'll think I'm a slut" she said sadly.
"Babe, does this make you feel like a slut?" I asked feeling bad. I knew this relationship would have some negative results, but I never thought she would feel bad about herself for it.
"No, not at all" she said.
"Then it doesn't matter" Santanna said. "We'll tell them when the time is right. My mom won't care, she's pretty liberal and this wouldn't even faze her. Besides she knows I'm gay, so I've got nothing to hide" she said.
"Babe, you know my mom worships the ground you walk on. She'll be so fucking happy when she finds out we're back together, she won't give a shit if you had 3 other girlfriends" I said nodding.
"That's great" she said kissing Santanna, then me. "But what about school, who will drive me?" she asked.
"I will" I said. "I just got a new truck and it has plenty of room for all of us. I'll just pick you up first and then we'll go get San" I said.
"Noah, what about gas money?" she asked.
"Babe you guys live like two blocks away, it ain't that much gas" I said laughing and kissing her forehead. She was so cute when she was worried.
"But what about dates?" she asked, biting her lip.
"We'll go out together. When one of us wants a date alone, we'll just take turns." I said.
"Okay" she said, "I just have one more question".
"What baby?" Santanna asked.
"What about sex?" she asked quietly.
"What about it babe, I'll wait until you're ready" I said. "I'm not in this for sex, I'm with you because I love you" I said, realizing this was the first time I had told her this.
"I love you too, Noah, but that's not the problem" she said.
"Then's what's wrong?" Santanna asked, rubbing her back. "We can take turns having private times as well" she said.
"But what if I don't want to" Rachel said with her head down.
"Baby, what are you talking about" Santanna asked, pulling her head up so she could look into her eyes.
"What if I want to be with both of you at the same time?" she asked shyly looking at me.
"Then you'll get both of us" I said smiling.
"Like a threesome?" Santanna asked, I could tell she hadn't expected Rach to say anything like this.
"Yes" she answered. "I love you both and I want to make love to you both at that same time. Is that okay?" she asked.
"S'fine with me babe" I said kissing her on the lips. I got to fuck Rach while she kissed Santanna? Fucking awesome.
"Baby, that's okay with me. Besides, I don't really have the right equipment to really pleasure you anyway" Santanna said. "We can make it work".
"But will you touch each other?" she asked.
Santanna and I had our fun in the past, but now I couldn't even imagine touching another girl that wasn't Rachel.
"No" I said. "I only want to touch you" I replied firmly.
"Me too baby, the only interest I have in Puck is the fact that he makes you happy. I love you and I want to make you happy. And no offense Puckerman, but it's like I said before, you've got nothing I want" she said.
"None taken" I said as I plunged my tongue into Rach's mouth. God she tasted like freaking honey or some sweet shit.
"mm..Noah" she moaned as she pulled away and then shoved her tongue in Santanna's mouth. Just seeing how happy she was with her, made me hard, it helped that they were both sexy as hell.
"Fuck babe" I moaned as I snuck my hand up her shirt to touch her breasts.
"mm..not..in..public..Noah" she moaned between her kisses.
"Fine" I grumbled and started kissing her neck.
"See, I told you it would work out" Santanna said smugly as we laid back on the bench breathless.
"Fuck yea, this is gonna be amazing" I said kissing her one more time.
"One more thing" she said to both of us.
"What baby?" Santanna asked.
"You're it!" she said hitting me on the arm and taking off to hide behind the swings.
"Hell no" I yelled chasing after the girls.
I laughed as I realized Rachel was dragging Santanna behind. Santanna may have been the athlete, but Rachel was way faster and was practically pulling her arm out of the socket.
"Run San" Rachel yelled as I grabbed her around the waist and spun her around. I set her down on the ground and started peppering her face with kisses until Santanna ran up behind her and yanked her away. I watched as Rachel tackled her to the ground and straddled her hips kissing her passionately. I ran over and snatched Rachel off and held her arms behind her back so Santanna could get her revenge.
"Okay I quit" she yelled as Santanna continued to tickle her sides.
"Nope, it's not over yet" Santanna yelled and started kissing her deeply.
I let go and watched as she fisted her heads through Santanna's hair and moaned into the kiss. I could feel my hard-on coming back so I walked behind her and kissed her neck while grinding myself into her ass to let her know how much I appreciated it.
"Can we try it now?" she asked pulling her mouth away from Santanna's.
"Try what babe?" I said sucking hard on her neck, feeling pleased when I left a mark.
"The threesome" she whispered between our bodies.
"Fuck" I moaned, that was probably the sexiest thing she ever said.
"If that's what you want baby" Santanna said leaving her own marks on Rachel's collarbone.
"Yes that's what I want" she gasped as I worked my way up the back of her shirt, drawing circles on her back.
"Then let's go" I said pulling her towards my truck.
When we got to Santanna's apartment, we immediately headed to the bedroom. We we're all turned on and excited to see how this would work out. We had decided that Santanna would help Rachel get ready for the penetration since this was her first time.
I stripped off all my clothes and laid on the bed, with my back against the headboard. I watched as Santanna kissed Rachel's entire body and then delicately took off all of her clothes. I was so fucking hard, I would've probably ripped the clothes off her body and that would've definitely killed the moment for our first time. I wanted to make it special and in order to do that I seriously needed to get off a few times or I wouldn't last very long. I grabbed my dick and began pumping my hand up and down as I watched Santanna suck on Rachel's nipples.
"Fuck that's hot" I moaned.
"Mm..San" she moaned as Santanna removed her own clothes and Rachel attached herself to Santanna's breasts.
I watched as they both reached down to each other's wet pussies and plunged their fingers inside each other. God I was so close to coming, I had never been this turned on in my life. I continued to watch as Rachel furiously pumped her fingers in and our of Santanna, while she slowly glided hers out of Rachel, curling and rubbing on the inside.
"Um..I'm gonna come San" Rachel moaned.
"Me too baby, I'm so close" she whispered.
I watched as they both removed their fingers from each other's bodies and sucked them clean. Then the hottest fucking thing ever happened. Santanna picked Rachel's leg up and wrapped around her waist and they began humping each other.
"Shit" I groaned when I felt myself quickly losing control. I speed up my hand and moved it up to rub the tip.
"God..Rach..you feel so good" she moaned as she rubbed her clit against Rachel's.
"San..um..UH!" suddenly Rachel's screamed pierced the air and I realized she was coming. I leaned my head back and came with her, squirting come all over the bed.
"Fuck" I yelled.
"God baby that was amazing" Santanna moaned after she too had come down from her orgasm.
"This was such a good idea" I said as Santanna pushed Rachel into my lap.
"I know" she smirked as she pulled her legs apart. "Relax baby, it's all about you" she said pushing her back to my front.
I sat up with Rachel in between my legs and grabbed the backs of her knees with each hand, pulling them into her our chests. I watched as Santanna lowered her head between Rachel's legs and started to explore Rachel's wet centre.
"Uh!" Rachel moaned as her back arched away from my chest.
"Relax babe" I said kissing the back of her neck.
"God..San" she moaned again.
"You like it when I taste you baby?" Santanna asked flicking her tongue over Rachel's clit.
"mm..y-yea" she groaned.
"You taste so sweet" Santanna said as she sucked her clit into her mouth.
"Fuck!" Rachel screamed as she tried to pull away from my grasp on her knees as Santanna started fingering her. I could feel myself getting hard again and my erection was digging straight into Rachel's back.
"San, stretch her" I said. I wanted to hurt her as little as possible.
I watched as Santanna slid in a third finger and curled them inside, stretching her out.
"God, you're tight baby" Santanna said as she continued her ministrations. "Does this hurt baby?" she asked gently.
"N-no" Rachel moaned arching her back again. "It feels so..umh..good".
"Come for me baby" Santanna whispered as she pinched her clit. I bite down hard on her neck and soothed the bite with my tongue.
"Sannntannaahh!" Rachel screamed as she came letting her juices pour all over the bed.
"Yes baby" Santanna said, crawling back up and kissing her on the lips.
"Thank you" she said quietly, stroking her face.
"S'not over yet babe" I said lifting her off of me.
I watched Rachel as she trailed her eyes over my body.
"You like what you see?" I asked pulling us both into a kneeling position so we could both kiss her.
I sucked her bottom lip into my mouth and nibbled on it while Santanna kissed the back of her neck and rubbed her hands around her stomach and up her breasts. I watched as she tweaked her nipples and reached her hand down to rub Rachel's swollen clit. I continued kissing her, until I felt her tiny hand fist around my cock.
"Fuck Rach" I moaned, plunging my tongue deeper into her mouth.
I continued kissing her until she pulled away and kissed her way down my neck to my chest. I threw my head back when she licked my nipple and flicked the ring with her tongue.
"God you're beautiful" I moaned as she continued to pump her hand up my dick.
"Mm..hmm" she moaned as she continued kissing down my body.
Without warning she opened her mouth and sucked my entire length into her mouth until she was touching the base.
"Jesus Christ" I yelled, feeling the tip hit the back of her throat.
"Mmm..bet you didn't know she could do that" Santanna smirked pinching her own nipples while still playing with Rachel's clit.
"Fuck babe..mm..god..Rach..you gotta stop..too fucking amazing" I couldn't remember the last time I had felt this good.
I watched as she continued to bob her head up and down while she brought one hand up to massage my balls. God I was so close to coming it wasn't even funny. Every time Santanna would pinch her clit she would moan and make a little humming noise that vibrated through my dick. I ran my fingers through her hair and pulled her head up so she could look at me.
"I love you" I said, looking dead into her eyes.
"mm" she moaned as Santanna started rubbing her harder.
After a couple minutes she started shaking as Santanna slipped her fingers inside and brought Rachel to orgasm. She starting swallowing around me and I was coming in seconds. I tried to pull out, but Rachel continued and swallowed all my come.
When she finally let me go, I laid down next to her on the bed, and kissed her as hard as I could.
"Was that okay?" she asked quietly.
"Okay?" I asked. "That was fucking incredible. Where the hell did you learn how to do that?" I asked stoking her hair, while Santanna laid kisses all over her body.
"I don't have a gag reflex" she giggled and snuggled into my chest.
No gag reflex? Fuck, just thinking about the possibilities with her made me hard again. I kissed her as she ran her hands down my body and grabbed my dick.
"No, babe no more of that" I said pulling her hand away. "If you still want to do this, you gotta let me rest" I said.
"Okay" she said as she reached towards Santanna.
My eyes almost popped outta my head when she pulled a bright blue vibrator out of Santanna's drawer. I watched as she shoved the entire thing down her throat before plunging it into Santanna.
"Uh" Santanna moaned.
"You like that San?" she asked, while Santanna threw her head back and moaned. "Do you like it when I fuck you?" she whispered in her ear.
Well fuck, this was something I had never expected. Who knew Rachel Berry could be a dirty girl?
"Harder baby please" Santanna moaned, kissing Rachel with all her might.
"You want it harder?" she asked shoving the vibrator in so hard, both of their breasts shook with every thurst. "Or do you want it faster?" she asked, speeding up her hand.
"Uh..Rachel..both baby" Santanna groaned.
"I love you San" she whispered in her ear as Santanna came, screaming and thrashing around.
"I love you too baby" she replied as she kissed her hard.
"I love you!" Rachel said as she jumped on my lap.
"And I love you" I said kissing her softly.
We continued kissing until I laid her down underneath me. I nipped at her lips and slid my hands up and down her body.
"Noah please" she begged looking up at me with her chocolate brown eyes.
"Are you sure baby?" I asked, stroking her soft hair.
"Yes please, make love to me" she whispered.
I looked behind me at Santanna who held out a condom. I took it and looked for any hesitance in her eyes, when I saw nothing but pure love, I opened it up and slid it on when she stopped me.
"Can I do it?" she asked quietly.
"Of course" I said, kissing her forehead and moaning when I felt her slide it up my length.
"You ready?" I asked pushing her legs apart and climbing between them.
"Yes" she said closing her eyes.
I watched as Santanna crawled up behind her and placed her head on her thigh.
"Just relax baby, it'll only hurt for a minute" she said, grabbing one of her hands.
At that moment I was extremely grateful for Santanna, she could take some of the pain away. I took a deep breath and pushed myself inside her, stopping when I got to her barrier. I looked down at her, she had her bottom lip between her teeth and tears were spilling out of her eyes. I brought my head down and pressed a chaste kiss to her lips, brushed the tears away, and pushed all the way inside breaking her barrier and making us one.
"You okay?" I asked, pushing the hair out of her face and kissing her nose.
"Yes, just be gentle" she said slowly.
"Okay baby" I said as Santanna lowered Rachel's head back down to the pillow and laid back at the end of the bed to watch. I didn't mind her being there, it was almost comforting. If she kept Rachel happy, then she kept me happy too, so her being there felt right.
I slid myself out and slowly pushed back in, swearing at the tightness of her.
"Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck" I moaned and I gently rocked in and out of her.
She was so wet, so I slid in easily, but she was so tight that I could barely move.
"Relax babe" I said pulling all the way out and pushing all the way back in. I did this several times before I felt her walls relax around me.
"Mmm..Noah" she moaned as she started to bring her hips up to match my thrusts.
"God you feel incredible around me Rach" I groaned, driving my hips forward a little but harder.
"Faster" she whispered as she licked the shell of my ear.
"Uh..Rach..god" I groaned.
"Damn this is hot" groaned Santanna.
I turned my head and noticed that she was pumping the dildo inside herself while watching Rachel and I make love. I should have been creeped out by this, but I wasn't because she wasn't watching me, she was watching Rachel being pleasured and that was understandable. I had been doing the same thing when she was with Santanna.
"Fuck Rach I'm gonna come" I moaned.
"I'm so close" she gasped as I hit a rough spot inside her.
I leaned forward and angled myself so I could hit that spot over and over again until she tightened up and came around me.
"Oh..Noah!" she yelled as she exploded around me.
"God Rach I love you so much" I said lowering my head to her neck while I spilled myself inside the condom.
I rolled over and threw the condom in the trash and pulled Rachel into my chest. I watched as Santanna climaxed after us and cuddled up behind Rachel throwing her arms around her waist. I bent down and pulled the blankets up over us, kissed Rach on the head, and closed my eyes.
"I love you Noah" she said as she kissed me.
"I love you San" she repeated as she turned around to kiss her as well.
"I love you too Rach" she said falling asleep.
"Love ya too babe" I murmured before I kissed her forehead and fell asleep.