Author's note: DON'T OWN GLEE. So here is chapter 3. I finally have an idea where this story is going to go, but if anyone has a suggestion, please let me know! Sorry for any mistakes, I tried to correct it the best I could. If you like it then please review, it boosts my confidence level which is not so high on this story :( Anyway, happy reading! :D
Santanna P.O.V
I woke up the next morning cuddled into Rachel's back while she was lying across Puck's chest. I pulled her hair back and kissed her neck until she woke up.
"Morning baby" I said planting a kiss on her lips when she turned her head.
"Hi" she said rubbing the sleep out of her eyes. "What time is it?" she asked quietly.
"Almost 6:30" I said, smiling as I pushed the hair out of her face.
"Mmm..why did you wake me up so early on a Saturday?" she grumbled burying her face in Puck's chest. I couldn't help but laugh at how cute she was when she was tired.
"I'm sorry baby, but I need to get up and run I'm extremely out of shape and I need to be ready when for my first practice on Monday. I just wanted to let you know that I'm leaving" I said rubbing her side.
"No, don't leave" she mumbled, pulling my arm back around her waist. "Stay here and have fun with me".
"Trust me if I don't go, I'll be extremely sore and then I'll really be no fun" I said, yanking my arm back and hopping out of bed.
"Fine" she said pouting as I walked to the other side of the bed and kissed her. "But hurry back".
"I'll be back in an hour or so" I said throwing on some clothes and pushing open the door. "I love you" I said watching her cuddle her way under the blankets next to Puck.
"You too" she grumbled as he wrapped his arms around her.
As I was running, I used the time to reflect on what had happened last night. I had confessed my love for a girl who I'd only been dating for two days, I had slept with her and her boyfriend, and I could not get her off my mind. I tried to think for a moment about life without her and I almost cried. I stopped running and seriously thought about our relationship. She made me ridiculously happy and I hadn't felt like this in a long time. Ever since my parents split up, I've been tossed back and forth between them and I was feeling kinda unwanted. I still loved both of them and I was thrilled they had let me get my own place, that way I could choose which of them I wanted to see and when. But I still had this feeling of loneliness and Brittany's rejection only made it worse, Rachel somehow filled that gap. I could tell that every time I looked in her eyes she was telling me that I was beautiful. She didn't have to say anything, her actions spoke louder. She was a very touchy person and she would reach over and stroke my leg if we were sitting down. She didn't mean anything sexual by the gesture, it was just to let me know how she was feeling. I decided I had run far enough, so I turned around and went home with my thoughts consumed by a tiny brunette.
Noah P.O.V
I woke up that morning to find none other than Rachel Berry naked in my arms. I almost fell out of bed, until yesterday's events flashed through my mind. She was my girlfriend and she told me she loved me. I couldn't believe how happy those three little words had made me. I looked over at the clock and realized it was only seven. I groaned and realized I had serious morning wood and having Rachel's ass pressed against it was not helping, not that I was complaining or anything. I leaned forward and kissed her head before untangling myself from her body to take a cold shower.
"Where are you going?" she asked sitting up. I groaned when the sheet fell and revealed her naked breasts, that didn't help either.
"To take a shower, I didn't want to wake you" I said grabbing a towel out of the closet. Santanna's house was pretty self explanatory, everything was put in a specific place.
"Oh" she crawling towards the end of the bed. "Hi" she gigged while keeling on the edge and wrapping her arms around my neck.
"Hi" I said back, kissing her and rubbing my chest against hers, groaning at the feel of our naked bodies together.
"Let's go" she said jumping of the bed and dragging me to the shower.
"Um, babe not that I won't enjoy a morning shower with you, but where's Santanna?" I asked, I hadn't even realized she wasn't in bed when I woke up.
"She went for a run" she said as she bent over to turn on the water, giving my a fantastic view of her ass.
"God, you're beautiful" I said pulling her back against me when she stood up.
"You're not so bad yourself" she giggled, rubbing her hands up and down my chest.
"No so bad? Babe, I'm a fucking stud, have you seen my guns?" I asked flexing for her.
"Noah, you know I think you're arms are lovely" she said sweetly while pulling me into the warm water behind her. "I like them even better when you wrap them around me" she giggled as I licked her ear.
"Like this?" I asked, pulling her ass right against my hard-on.
"Uh..yea" she said grinding herself backwards.
"Fuck babe" I said pushing her away, "you can't do that shit" I groaned.
"Why not?" she pouted. Damn she was hot when she bit her lip like that. "I thought you liked it".
"Yea and that's exactly why you can't do it, you make me wanna explode" I said, pulling her back against me.
"Mm. That's the point. You ready for round 2?" she asked lifting her leg up on the side.
"Aren't you sore?" I asked.
"Nope" she said, reaching back and stroking me.
"Rachel" I moaned as she lined me up with her entrance.
"Please Noah" she whispered, turing her head and licking my neck.
"I love you" I whispered as I pushed into her, moaning at how tight she was.
"Uh..god..I love you..mm..too" she gasped as I pumped myself in and out of her, I was so close to coming it wasn't even funny.
"Mm..Rach I'm so close" I moaned into her neck, licking one of the hickeys I had left yesterday.
"So good..so so good. Faster" she told me, thrusting her hips back to meet mine.
"Jesus" I moaned, pressing into her faster and faster until I was pounding into her tight body.
"More" she gasped out.
I snaked one hand up to pinch her nipples while using the other to rub her clit in slow hard circles like Santanna had done.
"Noah!" she screamed as she clenched around me, leaning forward to hold the wall making me go deeper inside her.
"Fuck Rach" I yelled as I felt myself explode deep inside while she came around me. "I love you so much" I whispered as into her neck as I pulled out.
"I you you too" she said, turning around and wrapping her arms around my neck.
We were standing under the water, holding each other for what seemed like ages when Santanna pulled back the curtain and hoped in, wrapping her arms around Rachel's back.
"Hi baby" she whispered into her neck.
"Hi" I heard her mumble against my chest.
I unwrapped our arms, kissed her one last time, before pushing her towards Santanna and getting out of the shower.
"Hey Puck, I bought you a little present, it's on the bed" I heard Santanna say before her and Rachel started splashing each other and laughing.
I wrapped myself in a towel and went to the bed. She had changed the sheets and laid out a fresh pair of brand new clothes for both me ad Rachel to wear. I walked over and pulled the tags off the clothes when something hit the floor. I finished getting dressed and then bent down to see what had fallen. I reached under the bed to grab the object and almost had a heart attack when I realized what it was.
Santanna had bought an extra large box of condoms.
And then it hit me.
I had just been in the shower with Rachel and I wasn't wearing one and I had definitely came inside her.
Thousands of thoughts ran through my head and I started to get dizzy. I pulled myself together and went to find my phone. For some reason, that seemed to be the most logical thing to do. I had put my phone in Rachel's duffel bag when we were at the park, so I began digging through it when I found something that saved my life. Inside Rachel's duffel bag was a pack of birth control pills.
Thank God.
I stuffed the pills back in the bag, forgot about my previous worry and went to make breakfast for the girls.
Santanna P.O.V
After I had ravished Rachel in the shower I realized I was starving and she must be as well. I turned off the water and dried us off. I was sitting on the bed with her in-between my legs.
"Guess what I bought for breakfast?" I asked drying her hair with one of my favorite towels. I wanted it to smell like her, so I'd have it when she left.
"What?" she asked innocently.
"Strawberries" I said kissing her neck. "Blueberries..and raspberries" I said kissing the marks that Puck had made on her neck and making my own.
"Really?" she asked.
"Yea, I just couldn't get enough Berries" I said kissing her lips and pressing my tongue between her teeth.
"oh..mm..well..m-maybe you could..um..make a fruit salad" she gasped in-between kisses.
"Or maybe I really just want a certain type of Berry" I growled pushing her onto the bed and crawling between her legs.
"When you guys are done fooling around, breakfast is ready" Puck yelled, banging on the door.
"Boy he really knows how to kill the mood" I said pulling her up.
"Oh be nice, besides I'm hungry" she said, following behind me.
"Hey babe" he said, pulling her to his chest, while I sat down to eat.
"Hi" she giggled. "I had fun this morning Noah" she whispered in his ear. I wasn't supposed to hear that and it kinda pissed me off, didn't we have fun too?
"But not as much fun as I had with you" she whispered, plopping down next to me.
I almost choked, she never ceased to amaze me.
"You alright?" Puck asked.
"Yep" I answered cooly.
"So what are we going to do today?" she asked bouncing in her seat.
"Whatever you want baby girl" I answered.
"I was thinking we should go to the carnival that's in town" Puck said shrugging.
"What a great idea!" she yelled, plopping down in his lap and peppering his face with kisses.
"Hate to burst your bubble, but it's raining" I said.
"Shit" he answered.
"Noah, don't swear it's degrading" she said, hitting his chest while she proceeded to eat his breakfast.
"Sorry babe" he said, snatching the toast out of her hands.
"How about we go to the museum?" I asked.
silence.
"What?" I asked. "If you don't wanna go, you don't have to" I snapped. Why were they looking at me like that?
"No, no, no" she said shaking her head. "I think it's a wonderful idea" she said.
"Just didn't think you were a museum type of person" Puck said, burying his face in her neck.
"So because I'm a bitch I can't like art. I like the Natural History museum, thank you very much" I said curtly.
"Then that's were we'll go" Rachel said, jumping up and wrapping her arms around me.
On the way back from the museum, we watched as Rachel struggled to keep her eyes open.
"Just go to sleep baby" I said, tucking her hair behind her ears.
"I don't want to. Noah what was your favorite exhibit?" she asked, trying to change the subject.
"Cavemen" he said beating on his chest. "They're pretty badass".
"Typical man behavior" I said, rolling my eyes.
"What about you San?" she asked, leaning her head on his shoulder.
"Dinosaurs" I said, running my fingers through her hair.
"Hmm..I liked them both" she said, drifting off.
"You think we wore her out?" he asked nodding his head towards Rachel.
"Not for long, she just didn't have any coffee today" I pointed out. Rachel ran like an energizer bunny when she had even a little bit of caffeine.
Noah P.O.V
We decided that I would drop Santanna off at home and then take Rachel back to her own house so she could spend the rest of the weekend with her dads.
"Babe, wake up" I said shaking her lightly as we pulled into her driveway.
"Where are we?" she asked, snuggling further into my side.
"Your house, come on it's time to go" I said kissing her head.
"My dads aren't home, will you stay with me?" she asked, looking at me with her big brown eyes.
"Of course" I said, leaning down to kiss her lips.
"Where's Santanna?" she asked.
"I took her home, she was pretty tired and she had some house work to do. She said she'll call you later" I said, opening the door and carrying her to the house.
"I can walk you know" she yawned.
"Babe, you're so tired, you probably can't see straight. Just admit, the Puckerone was too much for you to handle" I said unlocking her door.
"I can handle anything" she said.
"Sure" I said laying down on the couch with her on top of me. "When will your dads get back?" I asked.
"Not until tomorrow morning" she sighed.
"You want something to eat?" I asked.
"Yea, I'll eat anything. We haven't eaten since breakfast" she said sitting up.
"I know, let's go see what we can come up with" I said.
"Can't we just order pizza?" she asked.
"If that's what you want" I said, grabbing my phone.
"Yep" she said, skipping off to the bathroom.
I had ordered the pizza, popped in a movie, and was laying on the couch when I heard Rachel come down the stairs.
"Did you oder the pizza?" she asked.
"Yep" I answered.
"How long?" she asked walking closer to me.
"Bout 45 minutes" I answered.
"That's plenty of time" she said standing in front of me.
"Holy shit" I said, sitting up.
Here she was standing in front of me in nothing but a black lace bra and underwear.
"I'll take that as a compliment" she said, straddling my legs and kissing my neck.
"Babe, slow down" I said pushing her away.
"Why?" she asked before biting down on my shoulder.
"Fuck Rach, just give me a minute" I said, trying to catch my breath.
"I thought you wanted me" she said, lowering her head.
"Trust me I do" I said. "I mean we were just together this morning, I didn't think you'd want anymore for today" I said trying to adjust myself. "Most girls don't like to get it on that much, ya know?".
"Why would you think that? Don't you like making love to me?" she asked with tears in her eyes.
"Wait a minute, are you okay? I fucking love you and I love being with you, it's just this is moving kinda fast. I mean one minute we're friends and now we're dating and having sex. I just need time to adjust, that's all" I said pulling her towards me.
"Oh, I thought maybe you didn't want me" she said wiping her eyes on my shirt.
"Are you crazy? Do you feel this?" I asked dragging her hand down to feel my erection. "Trust me I want you babe, like all the time" I said, kissing her roughly.
"Can we do it one more time and then take a break for a while?" she asked.
"I knew there was a reason I loved you" I said unbuckling her bra.
"I love you too" she said pulling down my shorts.
When we were completely naked I was pulling her down onto the couch, when she stopped me.
"Can I be on top?" she asked in a shy voice.
"Hell yea" I said. There she goes again with that 'I'm sexy without trying shit'.
"Will you help me, I've never tried this before?" she said biting her lip.
"Of course" I said, rolling the condom on. "Come here" I said as I pushed into her tight, wet heat.
"Mm..Noah" she moaned as I filled her up.
"Damn Rach, you're so fucking tight" I groaned as she ground her hips down on me.
"I like this Noah" she gasped as she stared doing this figure eight thing with her hips, that almost made me lode my shit.
"Me fucking too babe" I groaned as she continued to pick up speed.
"I can feel all of you inside me..mm..and it's feels so good" she said, laying her head on my shoulder.
"God Rach" I groaned as I lifted her hips up and began pounding into her.
"Uh..Noah..um..yes" she yelled as she climaxed around me.
"God I love you" I moaned in her ear, as I spilled myself into the condom.
"I love you too" she whispered as I pulled her into my arms and laid down on the couch.
We laid there until the pizza came. As we ate, we talked and laughed about school, glee, and other things.
"Noah, where do you see yourself in ten years?" she asked outta the blue.
"With you, Santanna, and our kids in New York. You'll be on broadway, I'll be working somewhere, and Santanna will be the stay at home mom. Why?" I asked.
"Just wondering" she smiled. I honestly didn't care where I ended up, as long as I had her it really didn't matter. "I can picture that too" she said, kissing me.
We spent a few more hours talking and playing board games, before I had to head home.
"I'll see you Monday morning" I said, kissing her on my way out the door.
"You're not coming over tomorrow?" she asked sadly.
"No and neither is Santanna. We need to learn to spend time apart, just like in a normal relationship. Sunday is the day you spend with your dads, and we are not changing that just because we're dating" I said kissing her goodbye. "I'll text you late on!" I yelled before getting in my truck and driving away.
Rachel P.O.V
That night as I was getting ready for bed, my phone vibrated. I decided to leave it be and finish my bedtime routine. As I scrubbed my face, I couldn't help by feel like the luckiest girl in the world. I had two parents who cared about me, a boyfriend who I had loved for a while, and a girlfriend who had worked her way into my life. I was so happy that I was actually looking forward to school for once.
When I was finally ready for bed I picked up my phone and scrolled though my messages. Several were from Kurt and Mercedes, but I was only looking for two in particular.
[Santanna] I love you baby girl, sleep tight 3
[Noah] Sleep tight babe, love ya.
I texted them both a simple I love you and a good night and fell asleep picturing myself wrapped in Noah's arms with Santanna pressed against my back.
Sunday flew by so quickly, I hardly had time to text Noah or Santanna. First my dads surprised me with breakfast at my favorite bakery, then we went to go see a production of My Fair Lady at the local theater, had a great lunch at the new restaurant, finished my homework, and played Scrabble with my dads until bedtime.
Monday morning, I woke up up to two more happy texts.
[Noah] Mornin beautiful
[Santanna] Wake up baby girl. It's time to get sexy 3
I jumped on the elliptical, took a nice long shower, applied my moisturizer, curled my hair, and went to select the perfect outfit to impress my boyfriend and girlfriend. I went into the back of my closet and picked out the shortest skirt I owned because I knew Noah liked them. Then I grabbed a low cut, tight fitting sweater that stopped at my elbows. I put on my purple lace push up bra for Santanna because I know she'd appreciate seeing a little cleavage. I threw on a jacket, ran downstairs, kissed my dads on the cheek, popped a couple bagels in the toaster for breakfast, and waited for Noah and Santanna to pick me up.
As soon as my dads left, the doorbell rang. I flung the door opened and was pulled into a bone crushing hug by Noah.
"Morning babe" he said kissing me on the lips.
"Good morning Noah" I said, rubbing my hands up and down his arms. His arms always made me feel protected and loved.
"Hey baby" Santanna said, pushing past Noah and wrapping her arms around me.
"Hi" I said, pressing my lips against hers and tasting her lip gloss. "I made you guys bagels" I said grabbing their hands and pulling them into the house.
"Strawberry for you" I said handing her a bagel and "And regular for you" I said handing him his bagel.
"What are you eating baby?" Santanna asked.
"Oh, I don't eat breakfast, I usually just have a protein shake" I said giggling. I liked that she cared enough about me to worry.
"Not today you're not. Your way too skinny, you need to eat breakfast babe" Noah said. I couldn't help but laugh at how serious and protective he was being.
"Noah if I eat breakfast, I won't be hungry at lunch and then I'll be starving during glee" I whined.
"Don't care, I'll pack you a snack" he said rummaging through the closets.
"Oh calm down Puck she's a big girl, she'll eat when she's hungry. Right baby?" Santanna asked wrapping her arms around me.
"Yes" I giggled. "Oh before I forget, do you guys like my outfit?" I said, taking of my jacket and spinning around.
"Fuck No!" Noah yelled.
"W-what?" I stammered. I was sure they would love it.
"Oh, ignore him he loves it and so do I" Santanna kissing me hard on the lips. "You look sexy as hell".
"But why don't you like it Noah?" I asked heartbroken.
"N-no trust me babe, I love it. You look fucking amazing, but you're not wearing that to school" he said crossing his arms over his chest.
"Why?" I asked.
"Cause I already have to watch Finn and his hopeless stares when he thinks Quinn isn't looking and then there's desperate as hell Sam who would probably try and hit on you, not to mention Brittany and her flirty ways. The last thing I need is someone else making a move on my girl" he said sharply.
"Aw your being overprotective. It's cute" I giggled.
"S'not cute, it's because I'm a stud and no one is messing with my girl" he snapped and yanked me towards him.
"Whatever" I said, rolling my eyes and kissing him.
"Ugh you two are sickening. Can we go now?" Santanna asked, finishing her bagel.
We piled into Noah's truck and began our drive to school. I could get used to this routine, I was tucked under Noah's arm and had my feet across Santanna's lap. When we were half way there, I began to panic. What would people say when I show up with Noah on my arm as well as Santanna. The gossip wheel was on a roll when Santanna and I announced our relationship, how were they gonna react to this?
"Babe. Rach, hello?" Noah said waving his arm in front of my face.
"Baby, what're you thinking about?" Santanna asked, when I came out of my thoughts.
"School. What are the rumors gonna be like?" I asked suddenly very worried. I was so excited to get to school with them, but now I wasn't so sure.
"Who cares?" Santanna said shrugging her shoulders.
"I do San. I've never had a social status until I started dating you, and now I'm dating you and Noah. What are people going to think?" I asked.
"Babe, you can't honestly tell me that you're worried about what people are gonna say. Kids are idiots and they'll say anything to bring you down, and when they do me and Santanna are gonna have some serious ass kicking to do" he said as he high-fived her across the seat.
"I don't care what people think Noah, it's what they say that affects me. They may be idiots, but their words still hurt" I said quietly, I had been through enough bullying to be able to brush off the cruel words in public, but that didn't mean it hurt any less.
"I'm sorry baby. I wasn't even thinking about that. You know how sorry I am for everything I've ever done, right?" she asked.
"Me too babe, I honestly had no idea how much the slushies and insults put you down" he said, rubbing my back.
"I know and I forgive you both for that. I love you guys so much and it kinda upsets me that people are going to make fun of me for it" I said.
"Babe, I highly doubt that anyone is going to bully you when they see me and Satan on your arms. I mean we're like the ultimate badasses" he said smugly.
"First of all, don't call me that and second, he's right baby. You've become pretty popular over the last 2 days. Everyone's been talking about you on Facebook and you're all over Jacob's blog, not to mention all the people that are following you on Twitter. People are jealous of you, so let's go rub it in their faces" she said kissing me one last time.
We hoped out of the car and made our way in. Noah tucked me protectively under his arm and Santanna locked her pinky with mine. To say we turned heads would be an understatement, people would actually stop dead in their tracks when they saw us. I made my way to my locker and began gathering the books I needed for class, stopping when Noah continued to snatch the books out of my hands.
"Hey Diva" Mercedes grinned when she approached me.
"Good morning Mercedes, good morning Tina" I said with a bright smile.
"There something you wanna tell us?" she asked, nodding at Noah and Santanna.
"You're choice of wardrobe is fantastic today. Are those new boots?" I asked, avoiding the topic.
"Nice try, but that's not what she meant" Tina said.
"I have no idea what you're referring to ladies" I said, keeping my voice calm.
"Oh, so I guess you didn't see Jacob's blog or get any of me and Kurt's messages?" she asked sarcastically.
"No, I got your messages. I was too busy to answer them, is there something you needed?" I asked.
"Look Aretha, she said she was busy so don't go putting your nose where it don't belong" Noah said.
"Hold up, did I ask you?" Mercedes snapped.
"No, but you're questioning my girl and I don't like it" he said.
"So it's true?" Tina asked.
"What's true?" Santanna asked.
"You guys are really dating each other" she said.
"Why do you care?" Santanna asked, examining her fingernails.
"Because Rachel is our friend and if you two mess with her then I'ma tear your white asses up" Mercedes said.
"Well we're not" Noah said leading us away.
"Wait, Noah. I want to be truthful with them, they're my friends" I said, pulling away.
"Fine, but only because I love you" he said kissing me, making the girls gasp.
"To answer you question we are not all dating" I said gesturing to the three of us. "I am dating Santanna and Puck at the same time, but they are not dating each other. I love them both and I would appreciate your support in our relationship" I said.
"All I ask is that you tell me what's going on" Mercedes said. "I'm cool with whatever you're doing".
"Me too" Tina agreed.
"Thank you" I said.
"So how does it work?" she asked.
"Like this" I said kissing Santanna passionately on the lips and then turning around to kiss Noah squarely on the mouth.
"Well damn" Mercedes said "Don't let us ruin your fun" she said walking away.
"And you were worried about it" Noah teased.
"I told you no one that matters would judge you baby" Santanna said.
"I love you guys" I said, pulling them closer as we continued our way down the hall.