Chapter 2
Nate decided to ask Jenna out against Emily's wishes. Emily had a bad past with Jenna, but she couldn't talk about it with Nate unless she brought up a dark time where she and her friends stood by while Alison DiLaurentis blinded her unintentionally. The real prank was to explode the garage to get back at a past enemy Toby Cavanaugh who was now Emily's good friend, as well as the boyfriend of Spencer Hastings, who was a friend of Emily's.
Jenna and Nate had chemistry filled eye contact at the Brew, so Jenna accepted when Nate asked her out. The two went on their first date at the Apple Rose Grille, and it went well, much to Emily's dismay. She didn't want Nate to get hurt by dating Jenna.