WHAT?!?! : YOUR DATING MY SISTER?

Gabriella Montezand Joe Lucas were close in high school , then when Gabriella goes to college Joe starts to date her older sister Mary who decided to stay home. When Gabby comes home what does the game of love have in store? What if we add in the fact Joe was her History teacher? And that her husband wants her back? What will happen.

HSM/JONAS/ Another Cinderella Story

Genre : Romance , Family.

Couples: Joella , Troyella . Nary . Jary . Kevpay.

Love triangle : Gabriella likes Joe , who is Dating Mary who is Gabby's sister.

Part 1 of the What?!?! Trilogy

PArt1 : What!?!?: Your Dating my sister?

PArt 2:What?!?! My sister is engaged?

Part 3: What!?!?: I'm getting married?Again!

Part one.

I was looking through my old stuff when I found my old diary. It has been 4 years since I last wrote in it and I feel guilty. Not only about that , but other things like sleeping with Joe , but then again who wouldn't regret sleeping with their sisters boyfriend? 'I really need to loosen up' I thought and then opened up the diary , got a pen , and began to write.

Dear Diary,

Love to me is strange . Why do we have it? What good can come out of it? How do we know when we are truly in love? All those questions are somehow left opened when it comes to to my love life especially the last one. My life is a roller coaster at the moment and somehow I feel as though I'm never going to get off and that I'll be stuck on there. Like I felt as though I was stuck in Albuquerque years ago and when I was away and fell in 'lust' I forgot about everyone here. That's where everything went wrong.

Luckily I tried to avoid Joe again and it actually worked because I only went to the house during the day when he had work and guess what? Troy called! Yay my husband is calling me regarding our daughter. Which I'm still torn about. I don't know what to do . I want Shannon , but what if being with Troy is best for her future? What if I cant do it? What if I ruin her life? If she ended up all messed up it would be my fault her life is messed up.

What about Mary how is she effected by this? She would also get the short end of the stick. Wait lets face it we all would get the short end because guess what? No matter what I choose everyone will be effected and I'm not sure if it would be in a good way. Also Mary was cheated on and somehow I dont know why I did it. Did I still have feelings for Joe? Wait I never had feelings for Joe . He was just a teacher in training and he happened to be nice. He also hung out with me a lot. I used to feel happy when he was around but now it just feels stronger and jealous I guess of Mary.

Not that I dont love my sister but she is caught in the middle of my mistakes too. Lets just face another fact Mary was never the type of girl to date one guy. Joe will probably single again within the next month and then if we wanted to maybe we could date. Its not like Mary changed while I was gone. She probably changes guys every few months like she used to. She will see some one else and then she will move on to him and she will be happy again and the guy will be heartbroken and single.

Not to sound selfish but ... What about me? How am I going to choose ? Everyone will be sad in the end , well maybe Troy wont if I give him Shannon but thats different. Do I want to be a mother? Do I want to date Joe and betray my sister? How will Shannon be effected if I date Joe? Wait why am I even talking like this? Why would Joe like me? I'm nothing special just another girl who got married had a kid and is now getting divorced.

Either way I should probably get ready my mom wants Shannon and I to come over for dinner.

Sorry I haven't talked in a while

~Gabby~

When I got to my mothers house I saw that Joe was there as well as Troy? Wait! Troy 'damn!' I thought going into the backyard. This was not going to be easy. I put on a fake smile and get Shannon out of the car. Sharpay also steps out smiling talking about a guy she met at the bar last night. I rolled my eyes , leave it to Sharpay to pick-up a guy at the bar. But thatsreally Sharoay for you.

"You know if you really liked him why didnt you get his nimber?" I ask giggling trying to forget that I thought I saw Troy.

"I don't know , I bet I'll run into him lat- Wait is that Troy?" She asked pointing to Troy who was in the back yard.

"Shit." I whisper I wasn't seeing things he really is here! Shannon was just there in my arms oblivious to everything that was happening.

"Gabriella , your here! With Sharpay." My mother said to me .

"Hi mom how are you today?" I gingerly asked.

"I'm good , I'm very good!" She glowed smiling.

"Well that's good . I just have one question." I smiled

"Well what is it sweety?" She laughed inviting us in.

"Why is my husband here?" I laugh fakly giving her a look.

"Well why wouldn't I want my son-in-law here?" she smiled more giving me a look back.

"Because we are getting a divorce" I say trying to keep up my happy facade.

"Well I would at least like to meet the man my daughter married." She smiled and we walked in the house.

"Gabby! Shannon!" Aaron exclaimed hugging my legs. "I like your husband Gabby he's nice." Aaron smiled.

"Yeah he is nice." I smile at Troy.

"Gabby its good to see you." Joe said nodding at me.

"Joe. Hey Mary." I smile at my sister weakly.

"Hi Gabriella." Troy said giving me a light hug.

"Hi Troy , what are you doing here?" I smile.

"I wanted to see my daughter , meet my wife's family , and maybe try to work on our relationship?" He shrugged his shoulders.

"Shar what should I do?" I exclaim pacing around her room. Troy was taking Shan out for a while to give me some time to think.

"I say go back to Troy , and get some counseling." she shrugged her shoulders while shopping online for a pink dress. She ran into the guy again and now they have a date and I don't even know him. I just looked at her strangely "Marriage counseling." she corrects herself.

"This is as crazy as a walkrus fishing for a kangeroo in a ocean." I rub my temples. "And guess what else I slept with Joe two weeks ago and have barely talked to him since." I put my head in a pillow and scream.

"Wow well that's complicated." Sharpay said .

"You dont think im a slut for sleeping with my sisters boyfriend?" I lift up my head.

"No your not a slut , your just... confused." She calmed me.

"Yeah confused . My heart is just so FUCKING confused." I exclaim again.

"ITs not that bad." Sharpay said

"Yeah. I guess." I smile at her. "Thanks for the advise."

"Your welcome , just remember I'm always here for you." She smiled at me and then I walked out of the room.

"So Troy ... how has the last week without me been." I ask as i pick up Shan.

"It was a sad time , I missed you and decided to give you space." He smiled at me.

"Well I think we both needed space." I smiled back.

"I don't need any more space I need my dream girl by my side." He smiled then kissed me.

To my surprise I was kissing back . I needed to stop myself before I went to far like I did with Joe.

"Troy I'm not ready for that yet." I look into his eyes.

"I understand." He whispered.

"Im just going to take Shannon back to my place." I say and then leave.

Dear Diary,

Today was hectic , I think I have feelings for both guys and the worst part. Mary is beginning to hate me i think . For leaving, she still doesn't know about what happened. That is whats wrong. I am a filthy dirty slut and still my baby loves one good thing. I just don't feel right about anything lately. Maybe I'm just crazy at the moment . I deserve less. I barely deserve anything except my regrets and guilt and maybe Shannon well. I would emphasize the Maybe.

Also I think Troy doesnt understand that I left for a reason besides space. It will definetly be interesting to see what is to come of the future. I mean I have two guys , a guy crazy best friend , a daughter , and a sister who despises me. This will be a nice thing to talk about in the future. Shannon is sleeping at the moment. She has been tired lately and I'm happy about that because I get to do more stuff.

Did i mention Sharpay and I may have found our apartment. It is perfect for us and Shannon if she stays with us. Did I mention that Sharpay is now dating the guy and guess what else! He is Joe's older brother! His name is Kevin Lucas. Wow and man is Shar smitten. Words cant describe how happy she is. Wow I sound like a teenager again. Which is hard to believe becasue it seems so long ago and now instead of being worried about SAT's im worried about my lovelife and daughter.

It is weird to write in this again. I missed the diary so much it helped me through so much drama. Trust me drama is not as much fun as people think it is and guess what else. I have a new addiciton. It is ..... dun dun dun ..... taco pizzza . I dont know how but I was making a pizza and there were left over taco ingredients so i put them in and now I dont know how I survived with out it. i am aslo addicted to Kashi granola bars. They are soooo good. My favorite is the chocolate coconut. MMMM now I want one. Trust me it is good. Also I like froot loops now.

Oh well I'll just settle with feeding Shannon , she definetly likes her feeding time. Its like she knows whe I feed her but then again thats what she knows and I'm not going to stop her. She also rolls over now. She is so cute when she sleeps . She looks like a little angel. Plus now she sort of babbles but nothing coherent. Either way I guess I should go its time for Shannon to be fed.

~Gabby~

hey there so who do you think she is going to choose, also review! I LOVE YOU MALTA! WOOHOO!!!