A/N: I feel like I should change the title to 'Can't Believe This Story Is Getting This Much Hype'. I'd like to thank all of the reviewers, people who have subscribed to me as an author or to his story, and people who favorite the story and me as an author. I've written 8 stories and none of them have gotten this much hype. Thank you. It means a lot.
Disclaimer: Don't own Glee. Ryan Murphy won't return my calls.
Chapter 2
I'm jealous, Finn realized.
He stood abruptly and knocked over his chair.
Rachel looked at him with concern and inquired, "Is everything okay?"
Finn looked into her beautiful brown eyes and knew that he had to leave before he said something he'd regret.
"N-no. I promised…. Umm... Puck that we'd meet up and it's getting late so I'm gonna go. I'll pay at the front," Finn stammered.
Rachel stood also and a look of bewilderment crossed her face.
"We haven't ordered anything. Are you sure you're okay?" she questioned.
Finn laughed nervously and replied, "I'm totally fine. Just hung over. I'll call you later."
Rachel nodded, but she looked irritated.
Finn bent down and kissed her cheek before leaving.
Rachel brought her hand up to her face and wondered what had come over Finn.
(At Puck's house)
The ride to Puck's house was pleasantly quick.
Finn hammered on the door of Puck's apartment.
A few minutes later, a very unhappy and sleepy Puck opened the door.
"What the fu-"he began.
"I think I have a thing for Rachel," Finn said quickly.
Puck raised his eyebrows in shock and beckoned Finn in.
Finn stepped in and said, "I don't know what I'm gonna do, man. One minute we're talking and laughing, the next some guy is hitting on her and I get jealous. I can't believe I'm jealous!"
Puck laughed lightly and then cringed from the effort.
"Dude, relax. We all saw this coming," Puck replied nonchalantly.
"How can I relax when- wait what do you mean by that?" Finn inquired accusingly.
Puck rolled his eyes.
"Everyone knew, dude. The only reason you didn't is because she didn't date a lot of winners and you're practically already dating."
Finn thought briefly. Rachel had dated a lot of duds. No real competition. And they were really close.
Finn groaned.
"You're right! I hate it when that happens."
Puck chuckled.
"Get used to it. We all knew that you loved her."
"Who said anything about love?" Finn scoffed, although secretly he had been thinking the same thing.
"Well, who do you see yourself with when you're old and gray?" Puck inquired.
"Rachel," Finn replied before he thought about.
"If she said she loved you, how would you feel?"
"Amazing. Relieved. Happy," Finn replied.
Puck cackled and said, "Dude you are totally in love with her."
Finn thought about this briefly.
He had come to the same conclusion. He was in love with Rachel Barry.
"Crap. I'm too late. She's dating someone new," Finn whined.
"So?" Puck inquired.
"So what? She's taken," Finn replied as if it was obvious.
"Steal her back. Show her what she's missing."
Finn thought about his suggestion.
Puck obviously thought he needed more convincing because he said, "Dude. She loves you too. That's why she doesn't date guys she can see a future with. She was waiting for you. Then, you showed her a guy she could be serious with and she thought you weren't interested. Put on the moves, man."
Finn smiled lightly.
"You're right. I'm gonna win her back from Jesse St. Jackass," he exclaimed cheerfully.
Finn would let her know how he felt and he would win Rachel Barry.
"You've got to plant the seed of doubt first. Flirt with her. Make her unsure of Jesse. Make Jesse unsure too."
Finn nodded, a plan already forming in his head.
"Dude, how do you know all of this? You haven't had a serious girlfriend since the 8th grade," Finn inquired incredulously.
"This is how I get chicks. I just do it faster so that they'll sleep with me," Puck replied as if he'd just said that it was gonna rain.
Finn nodded, slightly disgusted that he was gonna win the girl he loved with Noah Puckerman's pick up moves.
"She'll love ya in no time," Puck said, "Now leave or get me some aspirin because I am so hung over right now."
Finn chuckled at his joke, and Puck laughed along.
Puck suddenly got serious and said, "Seriously, Finn. I drank a lot of beer and shots. This conversation is way too loud."
Finn nodded and went to go fetch Puck's aspirin. He normally would've flipped him off, but he was so excited at the prospect of winning over Rachel.
A/N: Sorry if I made Finn a little O.O.C. I wasn't sure how to make him react. If I made him in character, go me, but sorry if I didn't. Please review!