Disclaimer: Same as before

Rachel was now standing in her hospital room watching as CM Punk the man she like so very much and Noah Puckerman the father of her dead baby girl stare at each other. Noah had no idea that his idol would be here in the hospital room of the girl he had had a baby with but he should have known he would be here especially with how Rachel and Punk had acted with each other in the choir room that day when Quinn had been singing. Rachel stood watching with sad brown eye when she felt something or someone grab her hand. She looked down and saw Naomi looking sadly up at her as she too watched the interaction between the two men.

"Can they hear us?" Rachel asked

"No they can't sorry mommy." Naomi told her mother

"It's alright baby girl." Rachel whispered

"I wish they could hear us!" Naomi exclaimed

"Maybe they can." Rachel murmured as she walked over to Punk's side and bent so she was by his ear.

She placed a hand on his cheek hoping this would work. She closed her eyes and thought of what to say.

"It won't work mommy." Naomi sighed

"Punk would you talk to Noah already stop this stupid staring match!" Rachel snapped in his ear

Punk jumped and looked around after hearing Rachel's voice in his ear but when he looked at the girl on the bed she was still asleep. Rachel smiled at Punk but he couldn't see her. She then skipped over to Puck and did the same thing she had done to Punk but didn't talk yet since she didn't know what to say. Her eyes widened and she turned towards Naomi and motioned her over to Puck's side picking the small girl up and telling her to do what she had done to Punk and to say something to her father.

"I miss you Daddy." Naomi whispered into Noah's ear

Puck jumped and looked around trying to find the voice that had spoken in his ear and had called him daddy. There was only one little girl he knew that would call him daddy and she was dead. He closed his eyes thinking about Naomi Caroline Berry-Puckerman with her brown hair so similar to Rachel's, her big greenish hazel eyes so much like his, her tan skin she got from both of them, the Jewish nose she had gotten from both of them, and her smile was so much like Puck's. She had passed away at one month old from SIDS and he knew Rachel blamed herself for not checking on the small girl but he hadn't either and they had both been in the same house since he had taken her in after her dads had kicked her out. Rachel had moved out three months after Naomi's funeral and her nursery was going to be used for Beth until Quinn decided to get rid of her. When he told Rachel what he was going to with Naomi's nursery she had given him this heart breaking look and had stormed away from him. He later told him that Beth was going to be put up for adoption and she had just stared at him with that same look and had said she was sorry and he didn't ask why she was sorry because she had started crying and he held her.

"I gotta go take care of her until I get back Puckerman." Punk had snapped before leaving the room

"I will. I promise." Puck had said as the door closed

Rachel and Naomi stood watching Noah hold onto Rachel's hand while she was in her coma. Naomi looked at her mother and then at her father.

"So does Daddy really have another daughter?" Naomi asked

"Yeah her name is Beth and she was adopted by my Mommy." Rachel said

"If I had lived would Beth have been born?" Naomi asked

"I don't know sweetie but probably not." Rachel had said

"Mommy when you have another baby and it's a girl will you name her after me?" Naomi asked

"Of course I will baby girl." Rachel said

"You need to go back now Mommy I will miss you." Naomi said

"I'll miss you too baby girl." Rachel whispered as she was forced back into her body.

Puck jumped when all of a sudden Rachel's eyes shoot open and she looked around wildly. He quickly called a nurse and soon Rachel's tube was taken out and she was now sitting up in bed looking at Puck a small smile on her face.

"Hey." She whispered

"Hey Rach." Noah said

"I saw her." Rachel whispered

"Who?" He questioned

"Naomi she is a beautiful little girl a perfect mixture of the both of us." Rachel rasped her voice hoarse from the tube having been taken out.

"Really?" Noah questioned tears in his eyes

"Yes she even spoke to you and I know you heard her because you jumped." Rachel told him

"I can't believe it was actually her voice I heard I thought I was imagining it but it was really her." Noah gasped as the tears started falling

"She is a beautiful little girl." Rachel told him

"What does she look like?" He asked

"She has my hair, your eyes, my laugh, your nose, my tan, and your smile." She told him a fond smile on her face as she talked about her daughter

"She sounds beautiful." He said

"She is and she loves you so much." Rachel told him taking his hand and holding it

"I love her too." Puck said

"She asked about Beth." Rachel told him

"What did you tell her?" He asked

"She asked if it was true and I said yes then she asked if Beth would have been born but I said I didn't know and that she probably wouldn't have been born." She told him

"You were right Beth wouldn't have been born if Naomi had lived." He said

"I was doing research on Beth and I realized that she was born nine months after the day Naomi had died." Rachel said

"I was depressed and Quinn was feeling fat so we slept together so we took advantage of each other." He said just as the door was thrown open and AJ Lee came running in

"RACHEL!" AJ yelled as she ran over to her cousin who smiled at her