Hello everyone! Welcome back to A Pizzaing Case Chapter 2! Jessie and I are really happy that you are enjoying the story so far!

Just a reminder, last time we met, Herbert and Klutzy bought the last vegetarian pizza on Club Penguin. After eating all but one slice of pizza, they momentarily left the room. When they came back, the last slice was gone! They decided to sue each other in court. They checked with Lake Blue to make sure there was a court, leaving both Lake Blue and Jessie very puzzled. What happens? You'll have to find out! Enjoy! :D


Lake Blue and Jessie sat in their respective courtroom seats. Penguins shuffled in and likewise took a seat. Everyone was curious and fairly surprised to see the boxes with Herbert and Klutzy's names on them.

"What on Club Penguin is going on here?" Lake Blue asked Jessie, who shrugged.
"Although it's kind of ironic that Herbert and Klutzy are in court, since they have done so much to destroy the island." Jessie chuckled.
"All rise!" A shrill voice commanded, and they turned their heads to find John, one of their classmates from school, walking into the courtroom. Behind him trailed Greenbat, another one of their classmates.
"Greenbat?!" They whispered to each other in surprise as they stood up.
"Yes," asked Greenbat.
"Why are you the judge," asked Jessie.
"Why not? And you should see the crab's lawyer," he snickered as he went to the judge's table.
The penguins suddenly heard some loud footsteps and they turned around to see Herbert marching into the courtroom. Trailing behind him was Klutzy and his lawyer... Sesian, who was another one of their classmates.
The three of them took their seats while Herbert glared at Klutzy.
"Look at all the people supporting me," Herbert shouted across the courtroom.
They all looked around and Herbert immediately noticed that most of the penguins that were watching the trial was on Klutzy's side of the room. The only thing that was on Herbert's side was a tumbleweed that was passing by and a white puffle that hopped right into Herbert's face and kissed him.
"Ew! Go to the other side," shrieked Herbert getting the puffle off of him.
"The Court's now in session," shouted John as everyone took their seats.
"First thing first," Greenbat. "Herbert, where's your lawyer?"
"My lawyer is right here," said Herbert hopping over to the lawyer seat.
Greenbat showed no expression while John face palmed behind him. "Alright then, let's continue." He finally stated. Herbert ran back to his seat, which was a foot away. However, he still managed to trip and hit his nose on the edge of the box, causing a few members of the jury to chuckle.
"Okay, will Klutzy please come to the witness stand." John ordered, and Klutzy rose from his chair and calmly scuttled to the oversized chair.
"Attorney, you may proceed with the questioning."
Sesian cleared his throat and stood up. "Klutzy, explain what happened."
"Click click Ka click clickety click klick klickety click." Klutzy clicked, the sounds echoing in the large room. There was a slight pause as the penguins realized that they didn't have a crab translator.
"Wait," said a slightly familiar voice.
A blue penguin wearing a lab coat with classes stood up from the jury.
"You better have something good, Gary before interrupting the case," declared Greenbat. "By the way, can i have your autograph? I'm a really big fan."
"It would be worth your while judge," stated Gary. "I have a crab translator. That way we can easily can understand Klutzy"
Gary walked over to Klutzy and attached the crab translator on him and walked back to the jury.
"Alright," Sesian began once again. "Klutzy, please tell us what happened."
"Well," began Klutzy before being interrupted by Herbert.
"OBJECTION," he shouted.
"Herbert," said Greenbat. "Only the lawyer can object."
"Oh yeah," responded Herbert while hopping over to the lawyer seat. "OBJECTION!"
"What is it, Herbert?" He rolled his eyes as he spoke.
Herbert looked up at him before quickly saying, "Nothing, just wanted to say that he needs to tell us what happened." He smiled sheepishly, "And that he's ugly." He added quietly after.
"Pardon?" Greenbat sternly questioned, which made Herbert firmly shake his head and slink back into his chair.
"Anyway, as I was saying, Herbert and I bought our box of pizza-" Klutzy began.
"OBJECTION!" Herbert interrupted yet again before moving to his other seat. "Let ME tell the story! First, Klutzy and I were ambling through the forest. We were yelling at each other about which kind of pizza we wanted to buy. And-"
"Silence!" Greenbat yelled, hitting the table with the gavel a few times. "Klutzy is testifying right now. Continue Klutzy."
"As I was saying, we went back to our lair and then we decided we were going to relax a little before we started on Herbert's new plan-" Klutzy began again.
"And then finally, when we reached the pizza parlour. I failed at opening the door because I thought it was a pull door when it really was a push door. Or was it the other way around? I think it was the other way around. It was a pull door and I thought it was a push door." Herbert paused for a second, thinking about the topic.
"Herbert," Greenbat said sternly. "Klutzy is speaking. Would you like someone to interrupt you?"
"No," admitted Herbert. "Even though people do interrupt me."
"Klutzy please continue," said Sesian.
"Once we got back to the lair, we dug into the pizza until there was only one slice left. We decided to take a break and I went to the bathroom. And when I came back," Klutzy said.
"OBJECTION," shouted Herbert.
"What now," asked the judge.
"He's not telling the truth," shouted Herbert.
"Well, we will hear your story in a minute," said Greenbat. "Continue Klutzy."
"When I came back, I found an empty pizza box with Herbert towering over it."
"Is that all that happened," asked Sesian.
"Yes that is."
"Now, would you tell me is there a reason that Herbert would take the last slice," questioned Sesian.
"Well, the pizza parlor chef did say that it was the last vegetarian pizza left and Herbert is a vegetarian," stated Klutzy.
"That is it," said Sesian walking back to the table.
"Herbert, would you like to cross-examine," asked Greenbat.
"Of course," said Herbert getting up.
Herbert slowly walked over to the witness stand before putting his paws down right in front of Klutzy saying, "WHAT IS TWO PLUS TWO?"
John face palmed behind Greenbat, who sighed in frustration.
"Objection! Irrelevant and-" Sesian began to call out, but was soon interrupted by Greenbat, who just waved it off, since Herbert's behavior was already appalling.
"Two plus two is four..." Klutzy said dully.
"INCORRECT!" Herbert yelled. "Two plus two is...Umm...uhh..." He pondered this question for a full minute before shrugging and saying, "How do you add two numbers again?" This time both John and Greenbat face-palmed.
"Irrelevant! Next question!" Greenbert ordered through gritted teeth.
"Geez, okay okay, no need to be so mean about it." Herbert quickly complained. He then turned to Klutzy and asked, "So why did you take the last slice of pizza?"
"I didn't," Klutzy immediately responded.
"How do you know if you're not lying," said Herbert staring him down.
"Objection! He's intimidating my client!"
"Herbert, your cross examination is over," stated Greenbat.
"What?! Why?"
"Because your questions are completely irrelevant."
"Fine."
"Will Herbert P. Bear Esquire come forward to the witness stand," asked John.
"Let's see how this would end up," Jessie whispered over to Lake Blue while Herbert approached the witness stand.


How do you think this will turn out? We're just curious to see what you think about the plot so far. Who do you think will win? ;)

That's all for today. We sincerely hope you enjoyed, and we wish you a nice day!