Hey Jealousy
Summary- Mike agrees to help Rachel make Puck jealous, but will he end up falling for her? And will he be too late?
Chapter 3-
Rachel walked out of glee when a voice called her, when she turned around she saw Puck standing in front of her. She felt her heart beat faster and reminded herself to breathe, she told herself to stick to the plan she was supposed to be with Mike and she had no reason to be nervous she thought.
"Hey so you and Mike?" Puck said raising an eyebrow.
"Yes, I mean he is so sweet and he wasn't afraid to tell me that he liked me I mean men today hid their feelings so well." She rumbled on. "I mean it would be a much better world if people just say how they feel."
"Well in that case I think you look incredible hot today." He said moving closer.
"Thanks but I really should go find Mike, bye." She said trying really hard to force herself to walk away; it would work in the long run she told herself.
"Rach." She turned see Mike.
"It's working!" She said wrapping her arms around his neck.
"Wait what?" He asked.
"Puck he is getting jealous." She said smiling.
"Great." He said flat.
"So I need you to ask him to go on a double date with us, it will be too much for him to handle." Rachel said smirking.
"I don't know Rachel." Mike said annoyed.
"Mike please, I really like him." She said looking into his eyes. Mike's heart sunk as soon as the words left her mouth.
"Fine; whatever." He said not looking at her.
"Want to come over tonight, maybe watch a movie you can really pick it this time." She said softly.
"No I uh can't." He said starting to walk away.
"Call me tonight?" She asked him.
"I'll try." He said getting in his car. She looked at him drive up confused, he never missed movie night and they always called each other. She played with the bottom on her hair and twirled it something she did when she was upset. She got in her car and drove home and put on sweats and started watching t.v. She heard a knock on her door and assumed it was Mike so she went to go answer it.
"Hey." She was looking at Puck standing on her doorstep.
"Hi." She responded lightly.
"Where's Mike?" He asked.
"Um he had a dinner with his parents or something." She said lying.
"Aw so your all by yourself." He said flirting.
"Looks that way." She responded sharply.
"Whoa Berry calm down I just wanted to see if you wanted to hang." He said smiling. She reminded why she started liking him in the first place. He had come to glee early and they started talking and it became a daily occurrence. They formed a friendship but then Santana entered the picture and hated that the two started talking and strike up an evil plan. She told Puck to slushie Rachel in front of everyone or she would dump him and tell everyone he sucked in bed. He did as he was told and that was the day Mike find her crying in the auditorium.
"I don't know Noah." She said biting her lip.
"Let's just talk." He said putting his charm on.
"Fine but not for too long." She said letting him into the house.
"What happened you used to love talking to me." He said sitting on the couch.
"Well Santana did and then you stopped talking to me I believe there was a slushie involved." She said emotion flooding in remembering everyone laughing including him.
"Listen I am sorry for that." He said grabbing her hand. "I miss our friendship."
"Noah I think you should go." She said abruptly.
"Okay, I guess I will see you at school." He said walking towards the door.
Rachel curled into a ball and began crying remembering that day and how hurt she was and how much he hurt her. She heard her phone go off but was too upset to go answer it. She kept crying thinking about how now Mike was mad at her and Noah and everything just came together at once. Someone came in to the house and sat down, he put her head on his chest and held her close rubbing her back whispering it was going to be okay.
"Mike." Rachel said snuggling into his chest.
"I'm here its okay." He said rubbing her back.
"Noah came by." She said.
"What did he do?" He voice filled with harshness.
"Well that day you find me crying, he was the one who slushied me." She said looking up at him.
"Are you serious Rach, and you still like him?" He asked angrily.
"He was great before that." She said honestly.
"Oh yeah; real great if he'd slushie you." Mike said upset.
"I still want to continue with the plan; maybe I can get that Noah back." She responded.
"But Rach." He sighed.
"Please." She said looking at him. He remembered the talk he had with Kurt; he drove there after being frustrated with Rachel. Kurt told him he had a better chance of winning Rachel's heart if he continued to fake date her and show her he was boyfriend material.
"Fine." He finally said.