Hey Jealousy
summary- Mike agrees to help Rachel make Puck jealous, but will he end up falling for her? And will he bee too late?
Rachel ran downstairs and saw Mike holding a dozens white daises, and she smiled at the fact he remembered they were her favorite. Mike took a deep breathe when he saw Rachel, she looked beautiful. He suddenly felt underdressed by just wearing a simple white button up with black pants.
"You look beautiful Rach." He said handing her the flowers.
"Thanks you look really handsome." She said smiling.
"Yeah." He said sarcastically.
"You do." She said looking him straight in the eyes, he felt his heart start speeding up.
"Thanks Rach, uh ready?" He asked finally.
"Yep." She said looping their arms. The ride there they spent talking and catching up, he loved hearing laugh and seeing her smile. He realized how much he missed the Rachel who didn't talk about Puck all the time.
"So where we going tonight?" Rachel asked.
"It's a surprise." He said laughing.
"You should tell me." She said laughing.
"No I don't think so." He continued the joke. She pretended to be upset and pouted and he looked at her and stuck his tongue out. They pulled into a drive way and Rachel instantly knew where they were.
"You didn't." She yelled, when he parked.
"I did." He said knowing it'd make her smile.
"You remembered." She said giving him a big smile.
"How could I forget." He said getting out, he ran over and opened her door for her and she got out and gave him a hug.
"Mike thank you for bringing us here." She said looking at the broadway themed restaurant remembering her dads used to take her here all the time, Mike eventually carried the tradition on. He smiled and held her in another hug and they stayed in each others arms till the heard a voice.
"Hey." Puck said interrupting.
"Hi." Rachel said slipping out from Mike's arms.
"Rupaul." Santana snapped.
"Hi Santana you look very pretty." Rachel said acting like the nicer of the two. Santana was wearing a red short dress and a pair of matching heels.
"Rach you look hot I mean pretty." Puck said laughing, Santana shoved him.
"Thank you." She said grabbing Mike's hand.
"What is this place?" Puck asked rudely. Rachel felt a twinge of pain when he said it that way.
"Just a old place I take Rachel all the time." Mike said pulling her close, Santana rolled her eyes.
"Yeah, Mike is just the sweetest." She said continuing the act.
"Can we go inside?" Santana asked rudely.
"Yeah let's go." Mike said leading Rachel by hand. The walked and got a booth with pictures of broadway plays. Rachel sat next to Mike and moved in closer. Santana rolled her eyes and Puck played with his fork and knife.
"So, how is your relationship going?" Rachel asked.
"It's going great, no stopping anytime soon." Santana said acting rudely.
"I feel the exact same way." Mike said slinging his arm over Rachel.
"Hi can I take your orders?" The waitress asked.
"She'll have a caesar salad with a side of fries, and I'll have the same oh and dressing on the side please." Mike said ordering for him and Rachel, he remembered her becoming a vegan.
"Uh I'll have a burger." Puck ordered. Santana waited for him to order for her and when he didn't she tensed up.
"I'll have a caesar salad too." She said quietly handing the waiter her menu. "Um bathroom." She said getting up.
"I'll go with." Rachel said sensing something was wrong. The got into the bathroom and Santana put her hands on her face and took breathe's trying not to cry.
"What's wrong Santana?" Rachel asked sweetly.
"Puck ignores me, he keeps saying how he wishes he had you, and it's just hard okay." She said upset.
"San, I'm sorry I didn't realize." Rachel replied.
"Why would you, you have an amazing boyfriend who orders for you and is head over heels for you." Santana said almost crying, Rachel walked over and put they upset girl into a small hug.
"Why are being so nice?" Santana asked.
"Because I've been you." Rachel said smiling. "Wanna try being friends?" Rachel asked.
"It couldn't hurt. I don't think I can do this anymore." Santana said.
"Do what?" Rachel asked.
"I can't be with Puck anymore.
"Are you sure?" Rachel asked.
"Yes. God you are so lucky Mike really loves you." Santana said before they walked back outside. Rachel felt her heart fall for having to trick Santana into believe her and Mike were a couple. They sat back down and the rest of the meal was sat in complete silence.
"Puck I can't do this anymore." Santana said after the bill was paid.
"What?" He asked her.
"I can't deal with being second anymore." Santana said getting up.
"Mike can we give her a ride home?" Rachel asked him quickly.
"You and Santana are friends now?" He asked.
"Yes." She replied.
"Okay let's go." Mike said nodding. Rachel walked over to her Santana telling Puck he was a jerk and he it coming. He fired back with she was the school's slut and that's when Rachel stepped in and pulled Santana away.
"Rach." Puck said smirking, she rolled her eyes and followed Santana.
"Let's get out of here." Santana said.
"Girls night?" Rachel said smiling.
"Sounds great." Santana said smiling. Mike drove to Santana's house so she could get stuff for the sleepover. Rachel turned over at him and gave him a huge hug.
"Thank you for being the perfect boyfriend." Rachel said laughing at how good he was at pretending. "I mean you are such a great actor."
"Yeah acting." He quickly covered.
"I'm glad we are so close." She said laughing.
"I'm here for you Rach, always." He said smiling.
"Eh love." Santana said annoyed.
"Come on San, girls night starts now." Rachel said smiling.
A.N: So yeah, no more Puck and Santana and Rachel is beginning to see a side of Puck she doesn't really like. Mike's feelings are growing stronger and when a certain someone overhears Mike talking to Kurt about the plan it's time for sabotage. This is so late cause of cheer camp/ a long family road trip, sorry about the lateness not much I could do. If you could tell me what you thought that be great! (: