Hey Jealousy
summary- Mike agrees to help Rachel make Puck jealous, but will he end up falling for her? And will he bee too late?
"Thanks Mike for the ride." Rachel said giving him a kiss on the cheek.
"You can come in." Santana said shrugging.
"Yeah you should." Rachel said smiling.
"Not the whole night but some." Santana said seriously.
"Alright, some." Mike said hesitating. Rachel unlocked the door to her house and turned on the lights, no one was home as usually.
"Parents gone?" Santana asked.
"Pretty much all the time." Rachel said slumping down on the couch.
"We could throw a party!" Santana squealed getting out her phone. Mike nodded at Rachel and Rachel sighed before saying sure. "Yay, it will be amazing!"
"I'll get the food I guess." Rachel said Mike following her.
"I'll get the guest and you need to change into something more party." Santana yelled back.
"Fine." Rachel yelled back laughing. "Can you handle food, you know where everything is right?" She asked him.
"Yes, go go." He said laughing.
"So quick to get rid of me." She said laughing and walking to her room. She flipped through her closet, in the way back you could see a hint of her old clothing, the owl sweater, the huge bow shirt, and a ton of skirts. She looked through her dresses before finally deciding on one.
"Yes. Perfect. See you then." Snapping her phone shut. "Party planning is exhausting." She said to Mike as he sat down.
"And the party hasn't even started yet." Mike laughed.
"I'm on a mission tonight." She said seating on the couch.
"Which is?" He asked.
"To find a boyfriend who will treat me the way you treat Rachel." Santana said smiling.
"Be friends first, that's what we did." He said telling half of the truth.
"Ready." Rachel said waking down the stairs. She was wearing a black strapless mini dress that cut off a little above the knee. She had black pumps and a pair of black dangly earrings. Her hair was in light curls and she had red lips.
"You look gorgeous Rach." Mike said trying to catch his breathe.
"Perfect." Santana said excitedly. "Now the guest should be arriving soon." She said right on cue as the door bell rang. Within ten minutes Rachel house was packed tight and people were coming in and out. The music was blaring and the lights were turned down.
"Where do you want the keg?" A tall guy asked.
"Over there." Santana answered. Rachel saw Finn and Puck walk in, she decided to go greet them.
"Finn!" She said giving him a small hug.
"Wow Rach cool party." He said hugging her back.
"Aren't you going to give me a hug?" Puck asked her smirking.
"Fine." She said giving him a small hug back when she did he pulled her in close and squeezed her butt. "Ah." She said pushing him back disgusted.
"She wants me." Puck told Finn.
"She's with Mike." Finn said rolling his eyes.
"Doesn't mean she doesn't want me." He said smirking.
"Well if it isn't the great Matt." Rachel said hugging him.
"Rach awesome party, and you look amazing as well." Matt said smiling.
"Thank you Matt." Rachel said smiling. "Have you seen Mike?"
"He wondered off with Kurt somewhere." Matt responded.
"Kay." Rachel said turning. Before she could look Santana gave her a huge hug.
"This party is perfect." Santana said obviously a little drunk.
"You planned it." Rachel said laughing.
"Oh yeah huh." Santana responded laughing.
Puck was getting bored so he wandered upstairs where he heard two guys voice talking and Rachel's name. He moved in closer to hear better.
"You have to tell her." Kurt argued.
"I want to but with this whole fake dating thing when would be a good time to say oh hey I love you." Mike voice blared. Puck smirked he had the perfect opportunity to get Rachel. He walked down the stairs and locked eyes with Rachel before smirking.
"Hey Rach." He purred in her ear.
"Puck." She said turning to face him.
"Let's hook up I know you want to." He said pulling her in close, Rachel smelled beer and his breathe.
"I'm with Mike." She said pushing him back, he just laughed and tightened his grip.
"You are so funny." Puck said laughing.
"Puck let go of me." She said trying to get out of his grip.
"I don't want to." He said smirking.
"Let her go." Mike said pushing him back, Puck smiled he got exactly what he wanted.
"Fine." He smirked. "You are her boyfriend."
"Creep." Rachel told Mike. Puck got up on the table stumbling it was obvious to everyone he was drunk.
"Attention." Puck yelled, someone turned the music down and everyone looked over at him. "The schools most adorable couple Rachel and Mike are not really a couple." Everyone looked over at the two. "It was a ploy probably because Mike is completely in love with Rachel and she doesn't know, oh what guess she does now." Puck said smirking. Mike felt his breathing shorten his got red and was completely nervous. He ran outside not knowing what else to do, he was mortified. Rachel didn't know what to do she went to run after Mike trying to understand what just happened but she was stopped by Santana.
"Is it true, was it all fake?" Santana asked hurt.
"San." Rachel tried.
"Is it?" Santana asked mad.
"Yes." Rachel said about to cry. Santana looked pissed and just walked away. Rachel ran outside trying to find Mike.
"Mike." She yelled. He turned at her it was obvious he was very close to breaking down.
"So." She said awkwardly. He looked at her before kissing her deeply. She didn't know what to do so she pulled back.
"We are good together Rach, you know it's true. This whole fake dating thing proved it." He said upset.
"I- uh." She couldn't form the words.
"I have to go." Mike said walking away.
"Mike." She said but it came out as a whisper. She fell to the floor so upset by how this night had gone so wrong.
"Bet I look really good to you know, to bad I don't want you." Puck said laughing, he had some tall blonde on his side. "Let's go." He said to the blonde and then he was gone. Rachel walked back into the house turned the lights on and turned the music off.
"Everyone out." Rachel yelled. "Now." They all quickly ran out. Rachel changed into one of Mike's old football shirts and crawled into bed and cried herself into sleep.
A.N: So i had Major writers block! But anyway school staring on wed ah, i'm sad but i'll try and keep the faster updates.