Holly was up in her bedroom trying to find something to wear over to May's and nothing seemed the look right on her, "Wait…. why do I even care?" She said to herself, "I don't care what he thinks." She said throwing a shirt on the bed and looked at herself in the mirror, "Why am I even going to this anyways?"

"Mom who are you talking to?" Will asked as he walked into the room.

"No one sweetie. Are you about ready to go?"

"Yeah I can't wait to see Uncle Sam."

"Alright well then let's go." She said and turned off the light. This was going to be a long night.

When they got to Mays, Holly saw Dean's car in the driveway already. Despite what happened between them, that car held a lot of great memories for them two, "Mom are you ok?' Will asked her.

"Yeah I am fine. Let's go inside." She said and got out of the car. When she walked past the car, she saw a small scratch on the bumper and laughed to herself. Dean always did love that damn car more than her.

Flashback

Holly ran into the house and called every repair shop she could but no one was open, "Damn it!" She cursed to herself. Dean was going to be home any time with Will and he was going to be pissed. The one time she got to drive the car she had to back into the mail box. What was she thinking?

"Holly we're back!" Dean called out to her and she ran into the living room.

She saw Dean standing there with 6 yrs old Will," Hey honey. How was your day out?"

"Fine" he said and saw the nervous look on her face "Is everything ok?"

"Yeah why...why wouldn't it be?"

"I don't know. You just have that look."

"What look?" She said and smiled down at Will, "Why don't you go wash your hands for dinner." She said to him and he walked off.

Dean knew that look all to well. It was the look she had every time she had to tell him something, "Ok Holly spill it." He said and crossed his arms.

"Ok but please just remember I love you."

"Just tell me what you did?"

"I was about to start dinner when I realized I didn't have any milk so..."

"Whoa...please tell me you didn't screw up my car."

"I didn't screw up you car but I did have a really small accident."

"You what?" He said and ran out into the garage.

"Dean just calm down. It's not that bad."

Dean walked around to the back of the car a frowned, "Not that bad huh. Damn it Holly"

"It's just a scratch. You have done worse."

"It's not just a scratch. Thanks a lot."

Holly crossed her arms and looked at him, "I am fine by the way Dean. Thanks for caring."

"Oh don't give me that." he said and ran his hand over the small scratch.

"Ahhh!" She yelled and turned to walk a back in the house. She swore he would marry that car if he could.

End flashback

Holly and Will walked up to the door and before they could ring the bell, May opened the door, "About time you got here. What took you so long"

"Sorry but I had stuff to do."

"Like getting dressed for over an hour." Will said and Holly nudged him.

"Well you look great. Come on in."

When Holly walked in, she saw Dean and Sam sitting on the couch, "Uncle Sam" Will said and ran over to Sam.

"Hey buddy how's it going?"

"Awesome as always." Will said.

As Will and Sam caught up, Holly and Dean locked eye and he got up. Dean walked over to her, "I think Will is happy to see Sam."

"What can I say, he loves his uncle."

"Yeah he does. So where is Jack?" Dean asked but didn't really care.

"He had to work tonight."

"So is he coming later?"

"No he was just going on home." She said.

"At least you can see him later." Dean said and Holly looked at him.

"I know what you're getting at Dean and the answer is no. Jack doesn't live with me."

"I didn't ask."

"But you wanted to I can tell. I know they face." She said and turned to see Sam and Will walking over to them.

"Dinner is ready." May called from the kitchen and they all walked over to the table, "Just like old times isn't it?" She said and no one said a word. This was going to be the longest dinner ever.

After dinner, Holly helped May clear off the table while Will went with his dad and uncle into the living room, "So that went well I think." May said to Holly.

"No one said anything." She said and dropped the plates in the sink, "So why don't you tell me what this little dinner was really about."

"I don't know what you are talking about."

"I think you do and let me just tell that it's not going to work so stop it."

"What's not going to work?" May asked innocently.

"You know what I am talking about. You think that you get me and Dean in the same room enough time that we will magically realize we love each other and get back together."

Holly stood there and looked at her aunt who was smiling, "So you do love him?"

"What? No …I didn't say that. I love Jack so please drop the matchmaking. They only thing that will happen between me and Dean is more fighting." Holly said and walked out of the room.

May just rolled her eyes and grabbed the coffee and walked into the living room with everyone else.

Later that night, Will fell asleep while watching Fight Club with Sam and Dean, "Ok well I think we should be going." Holly said and stood up.

"Its speaks" Dean said sarcastically.

"Very funny Dean. I don't really have a lot to say so why pretend I do."

"Wow someone is in a bad mood tonight."

"I am not in a bad mood. I am just tired and ready to go home." Holly said.

"Why don't you let Will just stay here for the night?" May said, "He is already asleep so why wake him."

"That's fine. I will come by in the morning."

"Why rush off so soon?"

Holly stood there and crossed her arms as everyone looked at her. It was obvious she was uncomfortable around Dean, "I just need to go." She said and looked at Dean.

"Well don't leave because of me." He said.

"I'm not I just have a long day tomorrow."

"Yeah I bet." He said and got up, "Thanks for dinner May but I really need to go."

"Don't leave because of me." Holly said mocking his earlier comment.

"Believe me I'm not. I have no problem being in the same room as you."

"Oh you think that's why I have to go, all because of you? I don't think so."

"Sure looks that way to me." Dean said and they were face to face.

May and Sam looked at each other and she motioned to him to take Will upstairs. May knew they needed this confrontation. After two years of avoiding each other they needed to talk or so she thought.

"Listen Dean I don't want to fight with you right now." Holly said and turned to her aunt, "Dinner was great as always." She said and turned toward walk out the door, "Oh and Dean, you may want to fix that bumper. It looks awful." She said and smiled at him before walking out the door.

Dean looked back at May before walking after her, "Hey" he called out and she stopped.

"What now Dean?"

"What the hell was that about?"

"Nothing I just saw it as I was coming inside and remembered what a big deal you made over it and for some reason, you never fixed it."

"Oh please you just said that in there to piss me off and you know it."

"Maybe I did." She said and turned around and walked toward her car.

"That's right just walk away like always."

Holly turned back around and walked straight up to him, "What do you want Dean? There is no reason for me and you to talk anymore unless it's about Will. You are the one who started this because you felt the need to be a smart ass in there."

"Because you sat there for two hour like you had a stick up your ass!"

"Maybe because I didn't want us to fight like we are now! We can't ever have a simple evening in the same room together and you know it."

"That's bullshit."

"We always fight Dean and I am tired of it."

"You think I liked fighting with you?"

"Actually….yeah I do think that. Like when I accidentally scratched your car. You had a fit like I just totaled the damn thing!"

"I did not." He said and crossed his arms.

"Yes you did. Sometimes I think it would have been married if you just married that stupid thing."

"Well she wasn't the one who was pregnant!"

Dean couldn't believe he had just said that to her. He didn't mean it but it was too late. Holly felt her heart break and bit her lip to keep from crying, "Holly I…"

She just held up her hand, "Screw you Dean. Don't ever talk to me again," she said in a quiet voice and walked back to her car. There is was. After all these years the truth finally came out. He married her because she was pregnant and that was it. She was now even more sure she was making the right decision in marrying Jack.

Dean watched her drive off and cursed himself for saying that to her. He didn't mean it. He knew he would have married Holly whether she was pregnant or not. He loved her. He had to fix this. He couldn't let her think that's was the only reason.

Dean jumped into his car and did something he should have done two years ago. He went after her.

A/N thank you guys for review. Wow two chapter in one day. I was on a roll. I am working on the next chapter so review and I will hurry and get it done. Thanks again!