Dislcaimer: I still own nothing.

Make Me Forget

Chapter 2 – Round 2

Rachel hadn't seen Puck all weekend, though he had sent her a couple of texts asking if she was okay, and she had told him she was. She was afraid to see him, wondering if things would be awkward between them, whether he would be the same way he was that night or whether he would revert back to his jerk ways. And to top it all off she had been mortified to discover that she had left her underwear at his house. Rachel hurried into school and rushed to her locker. She wanted to avoid seeing him for as long as possible, that was why she come to school this early, Noah Puckerman was a five minute to the bell arriver. She quickly opened her locker and grabbed the books for her first class. All she had to do was get to class without seeing Puck and everything would be fine.

"You free tonight?" Puck breathed in her ear.

Rachel jumped in fright and spun to face him guiltily, clutching her books to her chest. Why did he have to sound like sex? His voice dripped nothing but and it made her want to do things to him that the former non-elicit and extremely moral Rachel Berry would have considered distasteful and animalistic. Now they sounded like exceptionally good ideas that would have to be explored further at a future date.

It also made it very hard for her to not get flustered in his presence. All she could think of now that she was looking at him was how he looked naked. His tanned body, muscled arms, well defined chest and abs that lead her thoughts downwards, which inevitably led to memories of sex.

"Yes," she answered quickly looking around to make sure no one was paying attention to them. No one was.

Now that Puck was a part of Glee and he had turned his back on the football team a few weeks back he had gone way down in status. He could have done something to get his reputation back up, but Puck didn't care to. He was back on the football team, but he didn't really run with that crowd anymore the way Finn did. Finn was a people pleaser, whereas Puck, he just looked out for himself and did whatever made him happy. Rachel thought she and Puck were alike in that way, they didn't care what people thought about them.

"I'm going to do you so hard tonight you won't be able to walk tomorrow," Puck growled into her ear and Rachel felt her face blush bright red. Puck's hand grazed her breast and it sent a fire through her body. She wanted him to touch her right then and there, to do everything he just promised right there in the halls. Puck stepped closer to her and Rachel started breathing heavily, "Leave your window open tonight."

Rachel's legs felt like jelly as their eyes met in a smoldering gaze.

"Rachel," a voice interrupted their staring contest and they both jumped apart guiltily.

"Finn," Rachel spun from Puck, her voice high pitched and she heard Puck chuckle from behind her. Finn frowned, glancing from her to Puck curiously.

"Puck bothering you?" Finn asked shooting Puck a warning glare and Puck just shrugged and strolled to his next class, and Rachel twisted her head to watch him go, her eyes drifting to his ass which looked great in those jeans and that it looked even better without them.

Rachel wanted to say yes, because Puck really was bothering her. He was making her so hot and bothered she didn't know left from right. Rachel turned to Finn and smiled brightly.

"No, we are just organizing a singing lesson," she assured him then she sidestepped him, "I should go to class, see you later."

Finn was left scratching his head as Rachel walked away, her head in the clouds.

School passed Rachel by in a daze. She saw Puck once or twice in the halls; he was a senior and she was a sophomore so they didn't have classes together, but when she did see him he just gave her that intense look and she would blush and look away. That night Rachel could barely sit still through dinner with her dads. Both noticed that she seemed antsy but when they asked her about it she just told them she was worried about a new duet in Glee. Not a total lie, but what could she say? She couldn't exactly tell them she was nervous because Noah Puckerman would be crawling through her window, that was currently open in her bedroom upstairs, soon to do her 'so hard that she wouldn't be able to walk in the morning' as he had told her. Just thinking of the way he said that to her this morning had her clenching her thighs together. She felt like she had become a sex addict, Noah was her addiction.

Once dinner was over Rachel feigned tiredness and told them she was just going to play some music and go to sleep. Her dad's shrugged and kissed her goodnight and Rachel made her way up the stairs to her room. She breezed into her room and turned to close and lock the door carefully. She nearly jumped out of her skin when warm arms encircled her waist, and a firm body pressed to her back successfully trapping her against the door. Noah buried his face in her neck, and then his tongue slid out to tease her ear. Rachel had to bite her lip to stop her moans. Noah pushed his hips against her backside and Rachel involuntarily pushed back into him.

"Took you long enough Rachel," Noah whispered darkly and Rachel shivered with desire, "I think I really need to punish you for making me wait."

"One sec," Rachel pulled away from him to press play on her iPod. The sounds of a musical began playing quite loudly filling the room. West Side Story. Rachel turned to face him and Noah frowned in confusion.

"What's with the music?" he asked walking over to her and Rachel smirked encircling her arms around his neck.

"So my dad's can't hear us."

Noah kissed her lips roughly, and then spun her around so that her back was to his chest. He ran his hands down her back and then pushed her over so that her hands were resting on her bed. Her impossibly short skirt rode up to reveal red lace underwear he knew she had to have worn for him. Noah didn't even bother with removing any of her clothes, he was already hard and testing the crotch of her underwear, she was wet already. Noah tugged her panties to one side and slid into her from behind startling her. Rachel let out a muffled moan as she buried her face in a pillow. Noah took a moment to caress her smooth ass loving the feel of being inside her and Rachel wiggled impatiently, wanting him to start. Noah rested his hands on her lower back and slowly started moving in and out, wanting to tease her first before he kept his promise. Rachel moaned softly enjoying it at first but then she twisted her head to look up at him, her cheeks flushed.

"I thought you were supposed to be doing me hard tonight," she taunted him and Noah grinned.

"You asked for it," he warned her grabbing her hips and then he thrust into her hard. Rachel bit her pillow and screamed with delight as he did it again and again. In the background Maria was singing 'Tonight'.

Noah was having the best experience of his life. Below him Rachel was screaming into her pillow as he pounded into her from behind. She was even backing onto him when he thrust forward and he bit his lip to stop from groaning out loud. God, she felt so good. He thrust into her hard one more time before pulling out abruptly. Rachel turned to him and pouted, obviously displeased at his absence. Noah grinned then spun her onto her back and entered her again. Rachel grabbed her pillow and shoved it on top of her face with one hand while the other moved to grab his back pressing them together. Noah grabbed her hips and then started moving inside her with carnal ferocity. He quickly threw aside her pillow and attacked her lips with his own. Damn. She tasted so sweet he was sure he was going to get cavities. Rachel ran a hand through his Mohawk, and desperately kissed him harder. Every thrust had her moaning breathlessly.

"I'm so close," she whispered into his mouth and Noah kept his pace trying to think of something else so that he wouldn't blow the show early. Rachel kissed him and then tensed against his body clutching him to her as she orgasmed, whimpering at the acute pleasure. Once Noah was sure she was finished he released inside of her, grunting into her neck. They lay together for some time, and then Noah pulled out of her and flipped onto his back exhausted.

"I'm just going to the bathroom," Rachel excused herself pausing to kiss him before she went.

Noah lay there and then a horrible thought crossed his mind. Rachel hadn't said anything about birth control; he had just assumed she was taking care of it. Noah had made the mistake with Quinn, and now she was having his baby. Noah didn't need another complication like that; it would make the whole situation worse. Noah sat up and saw her handbag on the nightstand. He quickly peeked inside and saw a pill case for daily tablets and inside were small circular tablets. Noah relaxed. They had to be birth control pills. Rachel wouldn't just come to him like she did without planning ahead, she was Rachel Berry, she was meticulous and organized to a fault. Noah returned to lying peacefully on the bed and Rachel came back in, blushing a little. Even though he had been with her twice already, Rachel still felt shy around him. Rachel crawled onto the bed and then straddled him eagerly.

"Again," she demanded bending down to kiss his chest.

"God Berry," Noah cursed but he wasn't about to turn her down, besides he had a promise to keep.

The next day Rachel strolled into school and went straight to her locker to find Puck waiting there. Rachel wasted no time in pushing him out of the way letting her hands linger on his chest. Puck's hands grazed her nipples.

"You can walk, I must be rusty," Puck mulled giving her the once over critically and Rachel gave him a shy smile.

"I'm just a great actress, it actually hurts to move," she admitted sheepishly and Puck grinned in satisfaction. He looked around to make sure no one was in the area before he spoke again.

"Tonight?"

"My place or yours?"

"I was thinking somewhere a little different."

"Like?"

"My car, backseat."

Rachel paused to consider. The back seat of a car seemed a tad slutty but this was what she wanted. She didn't want to be a goody two shoes anymore, she wanted to experience everything. Puck was grinning down at her and Rachel shrugged.

"Okay."

"Midnight, I'll be down the road from your house."

Puck turned and swaggered down the hall and Rachel watched him go. She didn't know what it was about Noah Puckerman but he was quickly becoming her favorite past time.

Rachel walked into the choir room hoping to stop thinking about Puck and sex and sex with Puck and the way he just knew what to do to her and how his hands felt on her, when she walked in on this conversation between Mercedes, Kurt and Tina.

"I will die if I finish high school and I am still a virgin," Mercedes declared and Rachel nearly made an about face and walked right out of the room as memories of her first time got her heart pounding. Her first time had only been five days ago, and she was about to get thirds tonight. She was quickly on her way to becoming a sex addict, Puck was that good.

"Cheer up darling, you still have two years," Kurt told her his eyes flicking to Rachel who now could not escape because they had seen her. Joy. Rachel pretended not to be interested in the conversation as she maneuvered over to the piano taking a seat. Unfortunately, the conversation continued.

"I j..j..just know my first t...t...time will be magical," Tina said dreamily and Rachel smirked.

"Please, it hurts like you wouldn't believe," Rachel muttered under her breath not expecting to be heard and three pairs of curious eyes turned to her. Kurt stood up and power walked over to her excitedly and the other two quickly followed.

"Rachel Berry, someone popped your cherry?" Kurt gasped scandalized and Rachel felt her face burning bright red.

Me and my big mouth, she cursed herself mentally wishing that the ground would swallow her up whole so that she wouldn't have to answer their questions. Rachel always cracked under their questioning. It was like she felt compelled to answer anything and everything they asked.

"No one popped anything and please stop rhyming my name like that, it's vulgar," Rachel asked politely ignoring the question completely, hoping in vain that they would grow tired of trying to wheedle the information out of her. She should have known she wouldn't be that lucky. The door opened and Rachel hoped it was someone who could save her, like Mr Shue, unfortunately for Rachel, it was Artie.

"What's going on?" Artie asked carefully, noting the way the others had boxed Rachel in so that she couldn't escape from the piano and Kurt couldn't resist blurting out haughtily,

"Someone popped Berry's cherry."

Artie's mouth dropped open and distractedly wheeled into a desk. Rachel made a face at them. Was it really so shocking that she had had sex with someone?

"Kurt! Even if someone did, which they didn't, but even if they did its private," Rachel cried out slapping Kurt's arm and he made a mock face of offense and hid behind Mercedes when Rachel got to her feet fuming, "And stop rhyming my name with cherry."

"It just works so well," Kurt replied smugly then he grinned mischievously, "So tell us who it was or you will never have a moment's peace."

God smiled down on Rachel at that moment because Mr. Shue and the rest of Glee walked into the choir room saving her from answering although the object of her desire strolled in and looked over at her, raising an eyebrow. Her heart pounded while Mr. Shue called for attention.

"We aren't done sweetheart," Kurt whispered to her and Rachel cringed. Damn.

Mr. Shue started talking about Sectional's and wanted them to work on three songs he was considering. They would each perform a song and then there would be a vote on which song to use.

"Ok, I've decided to split you up into groups, Quinn, Finn, Rachel and Puck in one group," Mr Shue started handing out the music, "Kurt, Mercedes, Artie and Tina in the other team and Santana, Brittany, Mike and Matt in the other. You will all perform the songs and then vote which one you would like to use at Sectionals."

Rachel knew for sure the world wanted her to die an embarrassing death. Firstly, they grouped her with Finn and Quinn, and it still hurt to see them together excited over their baby. Secondly, they added her secret lover to the team. Rachel took control and clapped her hands calling their attention. The song was easy enough, they would all just have to learn their parts separately, choreography would be something they had to work on so they decided to do that first. The four of them were working out the choreography and Rachel was acutely aware that they were being watched. Finn and Quinn partnered together, which left Puck and Rachel dancing together.

From where Puck and Rachel stood awkwardly trying to dance, without reverting to ripping each other's clothes off, they could hear Artie, Mercedes, Kurt and Tina discuss Rachel's newly discovered sex life though Puck didn't know that was what they were discussing. Rachel was trying to ignore the way that Puck's hand rested far too long on her backside. She shot him a warning look. If he kept doing things like that the others would work out he was the one who, as they so eloquently put it, popped her cherry.

"Do you think Finn?" Artie voiced and Rachel rolled her eyes. She couldn't imagine that Finn would ever be able to do the things to her that Puck did. Rachel paused; if she loved Finn shouldn't she be able to imagine sex with Finn? When she tried to think about having sex with Finn her mind came up blank. Odd.

"Please, I'm surprised he figured out how to knock Quinn up, there's no way he's player enough to dangle Quinn and Rachel," Mercedes snapped with authority. Puck raised an eyebrow at her curiously, not picking up what the gleeks were discussing, though he was getting a fair idea.

"I agree, the boy may be an incarnation of Adonis but he isn't exactly Casanova," Kurt interjected dismissively and Tina scratched her head.

"Well then who co...co....could it be?" Tina posed the question to them and curiosity got too much for Puck who pulled away from Rachel.

"What are you guys talking about?" Puck asked loudly and the Gleeks all turned to him almost guiltily. Finn and Quinn stopped rehearsing to watch the car crash unfold. Rachel was going to die of embarrassment if she didn't stop them talking.

"Nothing! Nothing right guys?" Rachel's voice went high pitched with panic again as she stared wide eyed at her four friends coming to stand next to Puck and stealing a quick glance at him. The four of them glanced from Puck to Rachel, then back to Puck then to Rachel and their mouths dropped open.

"Sweet baby Jesus," Mercedes actually had to sit down from the shock of it.

"Oh my god," Tina didn't stutter for once as she moved to sit beside Mercedes. Artie moved his mouth but no sound came out.

"A mental image just flashed through my head, I need to get it out. Please get it out," Kurt whined before running from the room and Finn and Quinn came to stand with Puck and Rachel.

"What are they talking about?" Quinn asked curiously, her gaze focusing on Puck intently. Rachel resisted the urge to push her away from Puck. Rachel had to remind herself she had no claim on him, she was the one who broke up with him, and she was the one who requested this sex only relationship.

"Noah's dancing, it's horrible right?" Rachel interrupted then grabbed his hand, "Let's practice more."

She quickly dragged him away and attempted to throw herself into the choreography for the remainder of the practice ignoring any curious stares that were sent her way.

Glee finished a couple of minutes later and Puck and Rachel stayed behind in the choir room, but she knew Artie, Tina, Mercedes and Kurt would be waiting by her car to interrogate her.

"So much for keeping this between us," Puck joked easily and Rachel shook her head.

"They are very perceptive," she admitted then looked up at him. He didn't seem concerned in the slightest that they knew. She had expected anger, annoyance, some sort of reaction at least but he seemed very at peace.

"Tell them to keep their mouths shut and everything will be fine," Puck assured her and Rachel frowned at him.

"You don't mind that they know?" she ventured to ask hesitantly and Puck shrugged.

"Rachel, you're hot, I don't care who knows," he said bluntly, then grinned down at her lewdly, "But I know that you do care who knows, so tell them to keep their traps shut and I can stay your dirty little secret."

Puck brushed his lips against hers then turned and strode from the room and Rachel picked up her bags and hurried out. Sure enough the Gleeks were standing by her car arms folded across their chests. Rachel purposefully approached them, preparing to defend herself.

"Please say it isn't so," Mercedes said when Rachel reached her car and Rachel rolled her eyes.

"What's wrong with Noah?" she demanded. Were they blind? Noah Puckerman was divine. Perfection in every way. The mere mental picture of his body could send shivers down her spine.

"He's a man whore darling," Kurt reminded her shaking his head and Rachel gave a fond smile as she recalled his hands on her body.

"He is very experienced."

She deemed saying he was a sex god something they would react poorly too, no matter how more accurate it was.

"Oh the images," Kurt pressed his hands to his eyes dramatically. Mercedes just looked at her in disbelief. Tina and Artie were sharing glances between them having a mental conversation.

"Look this is between Noah and I and we would appreciate it if you kept this to yourselves," Rachel informed them seriously and Tina frowned at Artie as though willing him to speak up what all four of them were thinking.

"He's using you Rachel," Artie spoke up and Rachel pulled her shoulders back proudly. They thought she was silly little Rachel Berry literally getting taken for a ride by the big bad wolf. Well they were wrong.

"No I'm using him," Rachel retorted and they fell silent. Rachel half expected tumbleweed to blow by and a cricket to chirp.

"What?" Mercedes managed to choke out and Rachel shrugged.

"I'm using him. He knows, he's fine with it. This isn't a relationship it's just sex, so we would appreciate it if you didn't tell anyone," Rachel told them sensibly and they all looked at each other before shrugging as they rightfully realized that what Rachel and Puck chose to do in their spare time wasn't their business. No matter how strange and unbelievable it was.

"Well don't do anything stupid like fall in love with the boy or something," Mercedes left her with a half serious parting remark and Rachel gave a gurgle of laughter.

"I don't think there is any chance of that happening."

AN: By popular demand chapter 2 LOL. This is Beta'd by the awesome booksmartblonde333 who is as obsessed with Puckleberry as I am.

I can't stop listening to 'I Wanna Sex You Up' from the Glee soundtrack. Mark Salling sounds sooooo sexy. Like so incredibly amazingly sexy. Did I mention he sounds sexy? LOL

Thank you to everyone who put this on Story Alerts and Favourites etc. You guys make me blush like a school girl. Review! Tell me your favourite bits! I guess my fav is where Artie wheels into a desk LOL for some reason I laugh when I read that, every damn time.