Disclaimer: I own nothing!
It was the day after regionals and both Quinn and Rachel refused to talk to Finn. It didn't bother him that Quinn refused to talk to him, but the fact that Rachel wasn't speaking to him was driving him crazy. Everyone was in Glee Club waiting for that week's lesson to begin.
"Mr Shue, I've prepared something that I would like to share with everyone." As she said this Rachel shot a dirty look at Finn.
"Yeah sure, Rachel the floor is yours"
I would toss some time at night with your voice in my head
Like a broken record all the words you say
And when I finally fall asleep
You find your way into my dreams
But I would never mind, you see
Cuz I get to live my fantasy
Finn stared at Rachel, he knew she was talking about the break up, and him being with Quinn. It killed him that he had missed so many months with Rachel.
And I know though we're made for mistakes
But you're holding every breath I take
Feeling this is more insane
So please don't let me go my baby
She wanted him back, it was obvious. Finn smiled slightly when she looked over at him.
I try my best to get away from you so badly
Knowing that I'd give my heart to you so gladly
But then it came reality,
Every word of when she came to me
But now I gave myself to you
I'm so scared of what you're gonna do
She was scared of what he was gonna do her if she gave him her heart again, she probably thought that he would break it like he had before. Finn thought to himself that he would never do that to her again.
And I know though we're made for mistakes
But you're holding every breath I take
Feeling this is more insane
So please don't let me go my baby
A small tear ran down Rachel's cheek, it killed Finn.
Keep your owns exactly where they are
I wanna be here
I wanna feel you
And I keep thoughts exactly where you are
I wanna be here
I wanna feel you
Like a broken record
Like a broken record
Like a broken record
Like a broken record
Like a broken record
Everyone clapped as Rachel finished, the only thing finn could do was stand up and muster out
"I love you Rachel" The whole room went silent. No one knew of Quinn and Finn's break up,
"YOU WHAT, you only split up with me last night and you're already fucking telling her in front of everyone that you love her!" screamed Quinn
Nobody said a word after Quinn yelled, she stormed out quickly after she said her piece, Rachel started blankly at Finn, not knowing what to say.
"I never knew you could be so inconsiderate." Was all Rachel said once she ran out after Quinn.
"Dude, you totally fucked that one up" Puck laughed
Finn shot him a look as he hurried out after Rachel, how could he be such an idiot!
"I think that concludes todays lesson " said Mr Shue
Rachel found Quinn slumped against a locker in the hallway crying. She knew if it was her that Quinn wouldn't care, but she wasn't Quinn.
"I'm sorry" was all Rachel could think of as she sat down next to Quinn
"Why does he love you and not me? How are you so special?"
Rachel didn't know what to say, she didn't have the answer, she just felt sorry for Quinn.
"I don't know, I never asked Finn to do this"
"Well you sang that stupid fucking song, about how you are sorry, damn you and your talent!" Quinn faked a smile after she said this.
"You're talented too, and I know for a fact Sam still loves you"
"Thanks but no thanks, I'm done with guys for a while" With that Quinn stood up and left, leaving Rachel looking directly at Finn