Chapter 5 Bobby called Sam to tell him where Alex was then he told him about their fight and how she stormed out. " I'm coming down there now " , " ok I'm going out to find her so by Sam " , " bye Bobby and thanks " They hung up, both getting into cars and driving. Bobby could see the faint trail of tires of Alex's car, so he followed them right to the edge of the cliff. Bobby looked over the edge and saw bubbles coming to the surface ... Alex ! " Shit ! " Bobby screamed. Then he called Sam, told him, called 911 and stared down in anger at the water. Soon after that Sam arrived and then the firefighters, police and ambulances. They got her out of the car and dragged her to the surface as Sam and Bobby were being questioned. They looked down at the mangled body. It was broken and covered in blood, she was still breathingbut barely. The medics put her on a gurnie and carried her off. Sam looked down at her and whispered, " Alex what did you do ? " as they put her in the ambulance and drove away.

3 weeks later .
Sam was sitting on a chair next to Alex's bed, holding her hand. He knew that now Dean was gone he would want him to take care of her .. he failed. Dean has been gone for four months now and Alex, Dean's girlfriend was now in a coma for three weeks. Sam shed a tear as he looked at her beaten body. Alex's left arm and right leg were broken. She had a cut on her face that went from the edge of her hairline, down the left side of her nose, went over the corner of her mouth and ended at the bottom of her chin. Alex also had a bruise under her chin, that extends to each jawline, and she also had three broken ribs and a bruise under her right eye. Now Sam placed his hand gently on her head and rubbed her forehead with his thumb. Then he began to say, " Why did you do it Alex ? Were you trying to save Dean or kill yourself or what ?! I've already lost Dean I can't lose you too ! I mean I know your his girl but I still love you like a sister .. please don't die Alex ... please " Sam began to cry harder, the tears flowing. He put his arms flat on the bed and buried his face in them, crying so no one would see.