Jack and Gillette made a bet

On who could seduce their dear James

They would meet at sunset

To see who had won the game

-

Gillette tried courting with flowers and such

To ensnare the cute Commodore

"Flowers die, candies spoil" James' words

Sent Gillette falling to the floor

-

Jack tried talking as he usually does

To the annoyance of our stressed James

So Jack decided to kiss him

And their relationship was never the same

-

Gillette tried subtle flirting

This went over the brunette's head

Till he gave him a kiss on the cheek

Making James turn beet red

-

Both men were fuming

Nothing was working!

They invited James to the docks

To see which man he would be necking.

-

James arrived at the docks exactly on time

A flustered Groves with him, a major oddity

Groves walked towards Gillette, his heart hammering

James just laughed at their stupidity

-

James smiled as he felt his newfound lover

Burrowing against his back

How he had fallen for him, he'd never know

"Ready for another go Jack?"

-

Yeah, so after posting my first poem, I tried thinking of other Pirate related things that rhymed with Gillette other than corset and I thought of bet and I'm not sure I can explain the rest.

And I managed to pair up Gillette with Groves and still do my beloved Sparrington. I'm quite proud of myself. Please review and I promise never to do this again!