You're a What?
Rated: PG-13 for now, rating will change to higher

Pairings: D/B, S/B, some D/E, S/E, mentions of Katherine, Emily

A/N: Thanks for the reviews you guys! It what keeps me going, and after Thursday's finale, OMG!

Summary: What if Bonnie returned to Mystic Falls with another secret?

Chapter II

"I never thought you'd become a stalker, Stefan." Bonnie mustered up enough courage to speak to him, but moved back a couple of feet to keep a distance between them. But that didn't stop the smells invading her nostrils. His scent, it was even stronger now that they were alone and she looked down at her own shoes, avoiding eye contact.

"You looked sick in class. We were worried," Stefan put the emphasis on "we" and she knew that "we" meant him and Elena.

"I'm fine, Stefan, believe me. Let's just.. go back to class, okay?" Bonnie wanted the conversation to end there but felt a tug on her arm, and Stefan wasn't going to let go. But Bonnie knew something else was different about him... she couldn't put her finger on it. He seemed more carefree, more aggressive, she only hoped he wasn't going to become another Damon.

That name, Bonnie's look in her eyes could have killed.

"What?" Bonnie asked, looking down at his hold.

"Something's different about you." Stefan spoke up, inching closer.

"I'd say the same about you."

Stefan watched her with newly developed eyes and smelled a familiar scent around her. Katherine, he thought in his head and invaded Bonnie's space, his nose was buried in her hair and he sniffed her. "Different, different, different," he repeated and Bonnie was stunned. Her body instincts were telling her to push him away, that he and Damon were the enemy but realization hit her that she was also the enemy now. That her alliance with humans were somewhat thrown out the window because of what she had become.

"You should... you should leave me alone." Bonnie pleaded, pushing Stefan away from her, somewhat breathless. Backing away, she rubbed her neck in the same part, exactly where she had been bitten. It wasn't until Stefan caught a glimpse of the necklace around her neck. It looked so similiar to the rings that he and Damon had shared, as well as other vampires. They were rare but it was enough for Stefan to speak up.

"Chemistry lab after school. We need to talk." Those were the last words Bonnie heard as she almost broke out into a sprint to head back to History class.

After school, Bonnie was glad she made it through her first day back. After being welcomed back by Matt and even Tyler, she was about to head to her car when she heard a familiar voice behind her. It was Elena, and still, it creeped Bonnie out at how much she resembled Katherine... almost to a T.

"Bonnie! I left you so many messages and..." Elena was almost overwhelmed.

"I know and I couldn't really handle anything then, but I'm... okay. I'm dealing." Bonnie was getting better at putting up a front but the conversation took a turn before she knew it and was rescued by Caroline interrupting. She wandered back some when she was given a big bear hug by Caroline and she wrapped her available arm around the blonde. She could sense the tension between her and Elena growing by the second.

But Bonnie tuned out Caroline's chatter about Miss Mystic Falls... she was glad she didn't sign up for that. But she also remembered that Elena had signed up, and gave her a look when it was mentioned. Seemed that Elena had forgotten all about it, too, but Caroline's voice seemed to drown out all the voices around them, and felt butterflies show up in the pit of her stomach.

"Well, I gotta get going you guys. Bonnie, will you like to help me pick out a dress for the competition?" Caroline asked her.

"Sure, why not?" Bonnie immediately replied, giving her friend a smile. "But I have to get going, but I'll call you later?" The blonde gave her another hug and exclaimed how happy she was to have her back. Bonnie walked away from the two girls but she could feel Elena's eyes on her as she walked to her car.

Once Bonnie arrived to her vehicle, she sat her bag in the back seat and twirled the necklace around her fingers. Should she or shouldn't she were the options she had. If she didn't see Stefan, he would already come to some conclusion about her if he hadn't already and if she went, she couldn't promise how she would respond to him. The way his body had pressed into hers in the hallway, she hadn't felt anything like that before. All he did was sniff her, but it was the way everything was executed. But the one thing she learned from Katherine was "don't be a chicken and do it."

"Damn Katherine to hell," she muttered as she closed the car door behind her, locking it as she approached the school once again.

Stefan was in the chemistry lab, waiting in one seats in front. He had to make some excuse to Elena to stay behind but after reassuring her that he was fine, everything was fine, he had given her a kiss on her lips and gave her a smile and watched her depart from him. But now onto serious matters, Bonnie. Stefan knew that Bonnie was hurting, still hurting deeply and a part of him knew that it was mostly his, Damon and Elena's fault. If they had never opened the tomb... if they hadn't.... Stefan just let out a sigh as he waited.

He knew that Bonnie would show up. He just did. And as he glanced up at the clock, the door beneath it had opened and in walked Bonnie.

"What is it, Stefan?" Bonnie kept her distance, her arms crossed in front of her chest as she went to the window, glancing out it. The cheerleading squad were out and about practicing for the upcoming Founders Day celebration and a part of Bonnie missed being just a simple cheerleader. She didn't hear him response but she heard his footsteps inch closer. "You can stop right there." Bonnie didn't need to see where Stefan had stopped but he was close enough to where if she turned to walk, she would collide with him again. "So you know."

Stefan nodded his head. "There's a thing where other vampires can sense others like them, especially if they're brand new. And from how your scent was before to now, I'd say yeah, I know." He explained and Bonnie bit down on her bottom lip. "How?" he asked her, and the question was directed towards how she was able to walk around in the sun without having a ring.

"I learned a lot of things while I was gone. I went through my Grams things, found books and spells.. and when I was in California, I learned even more. I'm a witch, that's always first and I figured out a way to charm things to make it happen." Bonnie explained in simple terms. Sure, she had help when it came to witchcraft but she felt it wasn't the right time to reveal everything.

"Did... did you have a choice on becoming a vampire?" Stefan just had to know.

"I chose it, Stefan. I chose to become one." Bonnie finally turned on her heels to face Stefan, arms still around her chest, almost as if they were her safety blanket. "No one forced me or whatever, but I did this to myself. And I have to live with it. But... everything's so strange now. Is that how you felt when you were... changed?" Bonnie began walking around the table tops of the classroom, her fingers grazing over a few beakers.

Stefan was practically stunned but nodded his head when Bonnie looked over her shoulders at him. But he couldn't deny the feeling he was getting when he saw her get further and further away from him. There was an awkward silence between both of them and she had ran her fingers through her hair, exactly where his face was buried just a few hours ago. Bonnie could feel the hunger creep back inside of her and closed the blinds before her, her eyes turned the familiar black and turned her attention to Stefan. "Help me?"

Bonnie felt so helpless, so confused, so alone that Stefan came to her side immediately and took her into his arms. He only reserved those arms for Elena, and previously... Katherine but Bonnie, Bonnie was so special. Bonnie wasn't supposed to be a vampire. She was supposed to continue on her legacy as a witch, be Elena's best friend, hate Stefan and his brother, and other vampires. Not become the one thing she hated.

Stefan could feel Bonnie's arms come around him and heard her sniff his shirt and up to his neck. "What's happening to me? Why am I doing this?" Her voice was so quiet that the normal person could not hear her but he did. "Let me..." she trailed off, her lips were right up to his. "She was right. She was right... it is a lot stronger." Bonnie whispered to Stefan as she finally kissed him. But the surprise was that Stefan did not push her away.

His lips weren't cold like she thought that they would be... and yes, she had thought about his lips. Before everything that happened, the lies, the deaths, Bonnie had secretly thought Stefan was quite a looker.

And then everything changed.

And it was still changing, even as both parties kissed passionately. Of all the questions in Bonnie's mind, none of them were about Elena and what Elena would think.

Elena just wouldn't understand.

A/N: Gasp! They kissed! Eeep! Even I didn't know they would until I started typing it... so what's gonna happen next? I don't even know that but it'll be good, I promise!