Disclaimer: I don't own anything, its all Jk's.

Chapter 2: Why Things Went Wrong.

Petunia stared in shame at the last letter she'd read. Lily had never known why Petunia had hated her so much. Though she did guess... And she'd been right.

Flash Back

Petunia slumped back into her chair, her elbow falling into her bowl of porridge. Every morning she would check the post, looking for her Hogwarts letter that would surely be coming, but still it hadn't.

Lily had got her letter around this time last year, so where was here's? She looked down anxiously, and the porridge was suddenly much more watery than it had been before. She couldn't live like this much longer.

3 weeks on, and the letter was surely much to late. Lily would be coming home soon. Petunia didn't want to see her.

And then, finally, a letter arrived, written on yellow parchment with emerald ink.

Dear Miss Petunia Evans,

We have heard that you are waiting for a Hogwarts letter,

And we have the most discomforting duty to inform you that you have not received a place at the school,

due to showing a lack of magical behaviour.

We hope this news does not course much rivalry between You and Miss Lily Evans, who I understand has a place at the school.

Yours sincerely,

Professor McGonagall,

Deputy Headmistress.

From the day Petunia read that letter she couldn't bear to see her sister's face. Lily had everything petunia had wanted, and Petunia had lost it all.

End Flash Back

Dear Lily,

Petunia didn't get a place at Hogwarts.

She is extremely upset, crying all the time.

We are sorry but we can't pick you up from Hogwarts, we have better things to do than waste out time on the girl that broke our daughters heart,

Mom.

Dear Mom and Dad,

Tell Petunia I am sorry.

I'm also sorry for doing anything to hurt your feelings. I didn't mean any harm going to Hogwarts, and now I wish I never had.

Don't worry, ill catch a taxi back home.

Love Lily.

Petunia,

I will write to the headmaster tonight and tell him there was a mistake with your letter.

Lily.

Dear Albus Dumbledore,

My sister Petunia didn't receive a place at Hogwarts for next year and I was wondering why not.

She needs to come and im sure the letter was just a mistake so please send her her real letter.

Lily Evans.

Dear Miss L. Evans,

I am sorry to inform you that your sister did not get a place here.

She failed to show any magical activity and therefore cannot come.

Please forgive me, I sincerely hope that it does not get between you to.

Albus Dumbledore.

Lily,

Don't go asking that Dumbledore man anything, cause I don't want to hear it.

You are stupid and foolish, and I have better things to do in my life than waste time on you. Have a nice life.

Petunia.

Dear petunia,

Please don't say that. You have no idea how much it hurts.

I wont ask Dumbledore if you don't want.

Just please talk to me.

You're my best friend and I need you.

Love Lily.

Petunia! Please don't do this to me.

I promise I wont go back to Hogwarts next year if that's what you want.

I wont do anything.

Ill come back to school and everything will be just like normal.

Tell mom and dad.

I love you so much.

Lily.

Dear Lily,

Stop plaguing petunia with those awful letters.

We know what your like and we've had enough.

There is no way were getting you a place at stonewall,

We don't want you here, your nothing but an up yourself freak and we want you out of our lives.

Try not to talk to anyone during the summer, we don't want to be embarrassed.

Mom.

Dear Albus Dumbledore,

Please can you get me a place at Hogwarts.

I want to go so much, and I miss Lily terribly.

I need to go.

Life here isn't right for me, and I want to be a witch to,

Mom and Dad don't understand. They think Lily is just showing off.

But please, please, please can I go?

I'm not naughty and I will catch up in no time.

Its just I miss Lily so much, and she got everything I ever wanted.

I hope you understand.

Petunia.