He's Not Human

Phoebe

"Paigey who the hell did this to you?" I asked my frightened younger sister.

"I-I kn-know who d-did it. But I don't think you'll be-be-believe me," she stuttered.

"Just trust us, and if all else fails, we can cast a truth spell or have Phoebe get a premonition," Piper told Paige soothingly. Paige muttered something but it wasn't heard.

"Sweetie, say it louder please," I asked her. I wonder who it is. Why is she hiding it? We looked at her quizzically as she picked up a pad of paper and a pencil. She wrote something and showed it to Prue. She buried her head in Piper's chest. Prue passed it to me with a triumphant look. I looked at the paper and I was shocked. On the paper it said Cole. I gasped and glared at her. Cole wasn't evil. He was human! How dare she accuse him of that. I started to recite a truth spell under my breath. I had just made it up.

"Let all inhabitants of this house speak what's true,

If they lie, turn them a shade of blue."

"Paige was it really Cole who did it?" I asked her seriously.

"Yes," she said with no hesitation.

"You're lying!" I yelled at her and ran out of the room. I ran straight to my room and cried.

Paige

I am shocked! How can she not believe me! I heard her cast a truth spell. That's why she was a light shade of blue. After that little episode, I sent Piper and Prue out of the room. I cast a protection spell on my room. Cole won't be back here. I a going to convince Phoebe that I'm telling the truth if I die doing it! I don't mean that literally. She will see I'm telling the truth, even if I have to cast a spell or force a premonition. Screw personal gain. This is more important.

Cole

I know she tried to tell on me. I tried to get back into her room, but she cast a protection spell on it. So, I settled for the next best thing. I went into Phoebe's room and said a spell. The way it works is that it would make her evil. She would also bend her will to my command. I told her to kill Paige. Tomorrow my plan will work.

Piper

Yesterday was really weird. So was this morning. Phoebe's been acting really weird. Paige is so quiet. That is very unlike her. Next time I see Cole, I am sooooo vanquishing his sorry ass. Maybe if I summon him, and just concentrate on freezing the demons in the household, I can see if he's a demon. I really believe Paige about this. Ever since when we gave him that potion, he's been acting very weird. Like not showing up and stuff like that. I hope it's just a shapeshifter though. If not, we'll have to vanquish Cole. Simple as that. Well, my sisters should be down soon. That is, if they want breakfast. At 10:30, Prue came down stairs already dressed for work at the 415 magazine. Ten minutes later down comes Paige. Another fifteen and Phoebe came down. She had dark circles under her eyes and she lacked that sparkle in her eyes. I wonder what's wrong….

Prue

Phoebe looks really weird. I wonder what's wrong. I called in sick today so that we could figure this out. I also called Piper, Phoebe, and Paige in. I told them we had to tend to a sick Aunt in Washington, and we'd be out the rest of the week.
"Guys, I took the liberty of calling you all in sick until Monday. We are gonna work this whole thing out. Weather you want to or not. Understood!" I told them all seriously. They all nodded. That went…. Well. Or as well as expected.

Cole

Around 6:00pm, I shimmered into the living room invisibly. I worked my magic and told Phoebe what to do. I sat back to watch.

NORMAL POV

About half an hour later, Phoebe stood up. Cole's spell telling her to channel Paige's telekinetic orbing and orb crystals around Piper and Prue, leaving Paige out in the open.

"CRYSTALS CIRCLE!" Phoebe suddenly yelled. The crystals orbed down and surrounded Piper and Prue. They yelled and screamed for Phoebe to let them out. But after five minutes of this they knew that this wasn't their Phoebe. Phoebe channeled Prue's telekinesis and threw Paige into a wall.

"You pathetic little half breed. You wimp," she told the young woman while walking up to her. Her voice sounded different. She lifted her up and then she threw her back to the wall. A crack was heard and blood oozed out from Paige's wound. This continued on for a while. Cole came out and threw a fireball at Paige. He took the spell off Phoebe who blinked in surprise. She looked around and her eyes landed on Paige, all battered, bloody, and beaten. They then landed on Cole. He was laughing and throwing energyballs at the unconscious Paige.

"You should have listened to her, Phoebe. She was right. I am evil. The Source Of All Evil to be correct," said Cole to Phoebe, who looked shell-shocked. Cole flamed out. Phoebe took away the crystals and the three sisters ran to where Paige laid. She barley had a pulse and had shallow breaths. They called for Leo he came and healed Paige. He then left to check with the Elders. An unconscious Paige was taken upstairs and laid on a magically enlarged bed. The order went like this: Prue, Paige, Piper, and then Phoebe. This way when Paige woke up, until they explained the spell, Paige wouldn't be near Phoebe. But Phoebe would still be comforted.

The next morning, when Paige awoke, she tried to get off the bed, remembering the stuff that had happened the night before. As she tried, an arm wound itself tighter around her waist. When she found the owner of the hand, it belonged to Prue. The two got up and Prue moved Piper and Phoebe closer together. Paige orbed them to Prue's. All of a sudden, Paige burst into tears. Prue held her while she sobbed. Rocking her back and forth whispering soothing words into her ear. After what seemed like hours later, the duo heard sobbing coming from the next room. It was most likely Phoebe crying. Crying over the fact that her boyfriend is evil and that she nearly killed her only baby sister. The entire family would have to have a serious talk that afternoon.

A/N: Here is the much awaited for chapter 4. Please check out my other stories and R&R.