Authors Note:

Regular Text: Normal

Italicized Text: Thoughts of the Characters

Bold Italicized Text: Phone Text Messages and Hand Written Notes/Messages

Underlined Text: These will be Song lyrics. Note: I have modified a few lyrics for some of the songs.

Prologue

Break Your Heart

-Finn-

You know for it being 2:00 in the afternoon, on hot day in July, things really couldn't get any worse then they already have. Finn thought as a sat on the edge of his bed in the basement in the Hummel house. He was already upset with himself for how he had treated Rachel and then to lead her on like he did. He was so STUPID! Plus the radio was playing the "Break Your Heart" song, how ironic is that? He heard his phone buzz next to him. Finn flipped it open and saw the last thing that he needed at the moment.

Woah Woah

Woah Woah

New Text Message

Rachel Berry

View Now?

View Later?

Finn pressed View Now?

WTH Finn! Wht is goin on w/u?

^.^Gonna b a *

Finn groaned. He so didn't want to talk Rachel especially now. But oh well he couldn't avoid her forever.

Now listen to me baby
Before I love and leave you
They call me heart breaker
I don't wanna deceive you

Sorry, R, I didn't mean 2 lead u on. Again I'm sorry I didn't wnt 2 hurt u.

Keep it Loose!

Rachel replied back way to quickly for Finn's liking. But he read her next text.

Wht is tht supposed 2 mean? Ur pulling away from me, y?

^.^Gonna b a *

Finn sighed and replied again to Rachel's annoying text.

R, I'm sorry, I thought that I really wnted a relationship w/u, but I feel nothing 4 u. I don't kno y I asked u out again, only 2 hurt u. I'm so so sorry R.

Keep it Loose!

If you fall for me
I'm not easy to please
I might tear you apart
Told you from the start, baby from the start.

There was a few minutes quiet after that but then Finn got another text from Rachel.

OMG! UR BREAKING UP W/ME! Finn come on let's talk about this first b4 u make any hasty decisions. We could do some relationship counseling or something, plz don't b rash!

^.^Gonna b a *

Finn couldn't believe that she was just going to hang on to him. This is what he had been afraid of when he first said earlier to her that he didn't want to see her anymore.

R, look I don't wnt 2 c a counselor w/u. I guess wht I'm saying is tht I'm not interested in u romantically anymore. PLZ! Just let this go!

Keep it Loose!

Finn felt a tear slid down his cheek. He felt bad for what was going on but he didn't realize that his feelings had been for someone else. They had been for a while, but he didn't want to admit to those feelings and the longer he dated Rachel the more intense those feelings became. The phone vibrated again.

Look F, we can work this out. ILU! I'm sorry if did something to push u away but plz let's talk.

^.^Gonna b a *

I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your, break break your heart

Finn just couldn't take this anymore. It's not his fault that he happened to like someone else.

R, I'm sorry, but no. I thought that dating u was what I wnted. But its not R, I'm sorry. I'm moving on, u need 2 do the same.

Keep it Loose!

Finn was amazed that Rachel could text so fast, because her reply was almost immediate.

UR MOVING ON! F, u don't wnt 2 give us a chance? D: What about me? Finn, God I LOVE YOU! Y r u being such a jerk to me, Finn? U & I had something? What's ur big deal now?

^.^ Gonna b a *

Woah Woah

Woah Woah

Finn felt a few more tears slide down his cheeks. He knew that this was all really unfair for Rachel. This was just really hard to do, but not as hard as when he found out about Quinn's baby actually being Puck's. Now that was hard to deal with.

R, look I'm sorry, I didn't wnt this 2 end this way. I realized way 2 l8 that I like u as a friend, and not a gf. I'm sorry but there is someone else that I wnt 2 b w/ bcause I they have been there for me, even though I treated them a little harshly.

Keep it Loose!

As Finn sent the text, he soon became angry with himself for saying that, and the tears started to flow freely from his face. Now Rachel was going to think that he has been cheating on her. Well on the physical and actual evidence he hasn't, but mentally he was screwed and guilty as charged. The phone buzzed again.

OMGF! UR SEEING SOMEONE ELSE! WHO IS IT? I'M GOING TO GIVE THEM A PIECE OF MY MIND! FINN U R A JERK! I THOUGHT THAT U WERE BETTER THAN THIS!

^.^ Gonna b a *

There's no point trying to hide it
No point trying to evade it
I know I got a problem
By doing this behavior

Finn was slightly angry now. But he replied back to Rachel.

R, I'm not seeing anyone. Let me come over and we'll talk this out. It's not what you think is going on Rachel. Again I'm sorry.

Keep it Loose!

Rachel's response was again quicker than Finn thought possible.

Finn, I DON'T YOU TO EVER COME AROUND MY HOUSE AGAIN! I DON'T WANT TO SEE YOUR FACE! I JUST WISH YOU NEVER EXCISTED SO THAT I DIDN'T GET MY HEART BROKEN BY YOU TWICE!

^.^ Gonna b a *

Finn was mad now, Rachel was just being so overly dramatic about this.

Rachel plz.

Keep it Loose!

Again Rachel replied with the almost instant response.

No Finn, I trusted you, and ur being mean and cruel. I thought that you were so much better than Puck or the rest of the jerks in this town, but apparently I was wrong. You never really cared about me, you just wanted to get into my pants, since you couldn't be w/Quinn.

^.^ Gonna b a *

If you fall for me
I'm not easy to please
I might tear you apart
Told you from the start, baby from the start.

Finn was now shaking with anger as he replied back to Rachel.

Listen you self centered freak! Spending time with u was great, but it opened my eyes to something that I had been ignoring for a while and that is why I've moved on. It's not that I didn't care about you, I really did. Just something changed.

Keep it Loose!

Finn was up off his bed and pacing about the room. Rachel replied back.

Finn, I don't care what ur excuse is! Just kno this, that if I am unable to have you then no other girl will either, Finn. U are the biggest jerk of everybody around here.

^.^ Gonna b a *

I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your, break break your heart

Finn reached over and grabbed one of his gifts from Rachel, a coffee mug with a golden star, which he got shortly after Regional's, and chucked it across the room where it broke. He grabbed a CD with all of Rachel's favorite Broadway songs on it and threw it on the floor, and stomped on it repeatedly.

Rachel, I'm done with you! The reason I'm breaking up with you is because I realized that I like guys! Being around you dads made me realize that this summer.

Keep it Loose!

Finn stood next to his dresser trying to calm down. But Rachel replied back.

WHATEVER! Don't blame this on my dad's. You're not gay, because I kno 4 a fact that u had sex with Santana. It's not that u love Kurt. Because he's not even a girl, so shut up and stop making crap up it's so not u! Besides ur too stupid for that!

^.^ Gonna b a *

Woah Woah

Woah Woah

Finn's anger got the best of him. He threw his cell phone across the room where it collided with the wall and broke into two pieces and landed on Kurt's bed. Finn then took a picture frame with a photo of Rachel in it and threw it. The picture frame hit the door that came down to the room and then bounced back as it landed on the stairs and down the landing where the rest of the glass broke. Finn raced over and grabbed the picture out of the pile of broken glass and the frame and started to rip the picture up, while he accidentally cut himself on the glass.

(Eh) and I know karma's gonna get me back for being so cold (eh)

Like a big bad wolf I'm born to be bad and bad to the bone (eh)

If you fall for me I'm only gonna tear you apart (eh)

Told ya from the start (eh)

"Finn, are you okay?" Kurt's voice came down from the now open door. But Finn didn't hear him. He was crying from his anger and he was only concentrated on one thing: ripping Rachel Berry to pieces, well the picture any way. Finn went into the bathroom and threw the majority of the picture into the toilet and flushed Rachel picture down the toilet. Finn then back tracked out of the bathroom where he ran into Kurt.

"Finn, what's going on? OH MY GOD YOU'RE BLEEDING! Finn…"

Finn shoved Kurt aside and he ran out of the basement bedroom, he tripped on his way out and slammed onto the floor at the top of the stairs letting out another roar of anger and hurt he then stormed his way to the front door and left slamming the door, leaving Kurt wide eyed and shocked in the basement.

I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your break break your heart
I'm only gonna break break your, break break your heart

Woah Woah

Woah Woah

-Kurt-

Kurt surveyed the mess in his and Finn's room. He was appalled that Finn did this to his room. Remember this is Finn's room as well. Kurt sighed and then decided he might as well try and help Finn out a little bit. Kurt went upstairs and grabbed a broom and a vacuum, brought them down and started to clean. It was only then that he realized that Finn was apparently upset with Rachel. After vacuuming everything he went to the bathroom where Finn's bloody fingers were just on the door handles and the flusher to the toilet. Kurt thanked that there was no blood on his carpet. But he finally noticed that when Finn pushed him he had gotten blood on his white Gucci jacket.

"Kurt?" Burt Hummel called for him.

"I'm in here dad." Kurt said as he walked out of his bathroom to meet his father.

"What happened to you? Is that blood?" Burt Hummel asked as he then moved forward to look at Kurt closely.

"Nothing happened to me. Yes it's blood, but not mine." Kurt said, he didn't notice Finn's mom coming down the stairs since his back was turned. "It's Finn's blood."

"Is he alright?" Carol's voice filled the room and Kurt mentally kicked himself.

"I don't know." Kurt said honestly. "I was upstairs and the next thing that I know I hear something hitting the door and I came to see what's going on and Finn was really upset and angry. I came down to see if I could help but he shoved me to get out of the way and he ran out of the house. I think he and Rachel had some sort of fight, because it was the stuff that she had given him that was broke."

"I'm going to call him." Carol said as she went upstairs.

Burt watched Carol go before he turned back to Kurt. "Are you sure that you're okay?"

"Dad, I'm fine. Just a little shook up is all, but I'll be fine." Kurt said with a smile. "I'm just going to finish up down here and then I'll be up."

"Alright, Kurt, we're going to the store in a half hour." Burt said and he too went up after Carol. Kurt let out a sigh and then went and sat on his bed and then he leaned back and felt his hand touch something. Kurt brought it up and noticed that it was Finn's phone, and he flipped it open. It was off. Kurt pressed power and after a few seconds flipped it over and noticed that it didn't have its battery.

Kurt dug around and found the battery and put the phone back together, and turned the phone on. Kurt was amazed to see that the screen still worked. But he dropped the phone in surprise when it vibrated with another text from Rachel. Kurt debated for a minute before he finally decided to read it.

OMG! Finn ur not denying it? Ur actually telling me that ur breaking up with me for a guy! And of all people KURT!

^.^ Gonna b a *

Kurt stared at Finn's phone, he was in absolute shock. There is no freaking way that this is actually happening! Kurt stared at the screen. There is no fucking way! Kurt snapped the phone closed. He wasn't going to go through Finn's phone, even though the conversation was about him. If Finn was really breaking up with Rachel for him, then it was surely something that had Finn upset.