Kurt looked at Blaine, as they exited the Gershwin theater.
"So, why'd you take me here? I mean, it's not my birthday, not our anniversary, I'm pretty sure no one is dead, or you would've told me, I hope Wait, what?" Kurt said, as he saw everyone from Windsor standing in front of him.
"Reed!" Kurt yelled as Reed practically tackled him.
"Alice!" Evan and Ethan yelled in unison.
"Some things just never change, do they?" Charlie asked, smiling at the scene playing out in front of him.
"The White Rabbit called us and we flew the Dormouse, the Hatter, the Hare, the Queen, and the Little Bat out here as soon as we heard! I can't believe he was going t-" Blaine smacked a hand over Evan's mouth, and Shane stared at his brother with a look that said, "Do-It-NOW!".
"Well, since Evan almost let it slip, and New York legalized it this morning, I had something planned, and Oh! FINALLY! Finn!" Blaine said, sounding really nervous. What had New York legalized this morning? Kurt couldn't remember, but Blaine had kept him from the TV this morning, so it would make sense that he didn't know. Blaine led another crowd towards them, the extremely tall (HE HAD GROWN SINCE HIGH SCHOOL) Finn leading a short Rachel, with Mercedes, Tina, and Artie in tow.
"FINNY! BERRY! 'CEDES! TINA! ARTIE!" Kurt yelled, as he hugged them.
"Blaine! We can go in now!" the Twins yelled, smiling their faces off.
"Go where?" Kurt asked, but he was pulled into a side door at the Gershwin theater. Rachel gave him a thumbs' up, and Blaine dragged him onstage, where the props still were still in place for the last scene.
"Kurt Hummel, I've loved you since I first laid eyes on you, when you were Wesley's endearing spy. I loved you when the lights went out-" the lights in the theater went out at this point and Kurt shrieked and landed on Blaine, "I loved you through the Logan fiasco and, most of all, I've loved you since we came here, and when we began to drift apart, you pulled us back together. And I'd like to think that I'll be able to love you for years to come." the Tweedles turned the lights on this time. Blaine was on one knee and Kurt was crying. "So, Kurt Elizabeth Hummel, will you marry me?" Kurt stared at blaine in shock.
"This is not how I pictured the first time I'd stand on this stage with an audience below me." Kurt mumbled, and Blaine laughed.
"Kurt, my knee hurts, could you answer?" Blaine said. Kurt sighed.
"Do you even need an answer?" Kurt said, sarcasm lacing his voice. Blaine gave him the puppy dog eyes. "Because my answer's been yes all along." Kurt finished.
The place erupted into applause.