Chapter 3: Truth or Dare

Once everybody had sat down, Puck placed an empty beer bottle in the centre of the circle and was about to say what game they were playing before Becky interrupted "Are we on a reality tv show right now?"

"We are on tv?" Brittany asked confused and looking around the room apparently for hidden cameras.

"No Brit" Santana said "and what?"

"Come on, teenage kids, an empty beer bottle, i am assuming this is either spin the bottle or truth or dare... it's totally cliché" Becky said smiling cheekily.

"fair point" Santana said with a slight smile of approval.

"Well, its truth or dare, and it's fun" Puck said ending the conversation.

/

Puck spun the bottle first and it landed on Blaine, who chose truth. "Ok, Did you really enjoy kissing Rachel last time we played spin the bottle?" Puck had a huge grin on his face and everybody turned to face Blaine, eagerly awaiting his answer. "At the time, i guess i did" Blaine answered, his face turning red. Kurt looked annoyed but was happy once Blaine apologised to him and explained that it was only because he was drunk and that it would never happen again.

When Blaine span the bottle, it landed on Mercedes who chose dare. Blaine had just come up with an idea when Vicky interrupted "wait a minute, don't we need a forfeit or something?". Everyone seemed to think for a minute, coming up with a good idea for a forfeit. "I got it" Puck announced "if you don't do the dare, you spend the rest of the game in your underwear" he said looking smug and wiggling his eyebrows suggestively at the girls. "We had better do our dares then" Vicky said teasingly. "Mercedes, I dare you, to eat a spoonful of cinnamon" Blaine said, chuckling when her reaction was that it would be easy. A few members of the group had seen videos of people doing the cinnamon challenge before and they knew it would be funny, Mercedes had no clue. The whole group watched as she confidently put the spoon in her mouth. It was hilarious to watch as she coughed a cloud of cinnamon in the air and kept asking for water.

Mercedes asked Rachel what the real reason she dumped Finn was. "I didn't love him any more" Rachel answered honestly, and Finn didn't seem to mind. They were friends again now, and things seemed to be better that way,

Rachel asked Kurt if he had ever kissed a girl and everyone got annoyed at the waste of a truth because they all knew that he had kissed Brittany before. Becky and Vicky seemed a little surprised and laughed once they were filled in on the situation.

Kurt dared Sam to see how many golf balls he could fit in his mouth, and everyone was surprised that he could only fit three, which actually isn't a bad number.

Sam asked Tina if her and Mike were actually related as a joke because he couldn't think of anything. Luckily she didn't take it the wrong way and laughed saying no of course they aren't. By this point Puck was starting to get frustrated at the lack of people choosing dare. "No one ever chooses dare, don't be pussy's" he moaned.

Feeling obligated Finn chose dare when Tina spun the bottle and it landed on him. She decided to make the dare a bit of a game, and dared Finn to try to down a beer faster that Puck, Sam and Mike. He lost to Puck, but they all decided that because he tried, he didn't have to sit around in his boxers. Nobody really wanted to see that anyway.

Santana chose truth, just to piss the boys off. Normally she would chose dare, but annoying Puck at his own party was much more fun. "You always talk about sleeping with all these people, how many people have you actually slept with, boys and girls" Finn challenged. Everyone was silenced. They all assumed that Santana had slept with alot of people, both boys and girls, but nobody had actually ever asked her. This was a question that Santana didn't really want to answer, but she did anyway. "Three" she said, picking at her nails. "Three, thats it?" Puck asked sounding shocked. "You, Finnosence and Britt" Santana explained. Everybody was shocked, but nobody said anything.

At that point Sam announced that he needed the toilet and everybody decided that they should have a break so that people could go to the toilet and refill drinks before playing the game some more. Vicky was followed by Puck as she, Tina and Mike went to refill their drinks.

"Having fun" he said, taking her cup from her so that he could fill her drink up instead, mixing something he said he called the "Puckasaurus" and making her laugh.

Quinn decided to go outside to get a bit of fresh air and was followed by Brittany who insisted that she shouldn't be outside in the dark on her own and that she needed company. She had been drinking alot and was starting to feel light headed. Deciding that she needed to sober up a bit she took a bottle of water with her.

Sam ran up the stairs and to the toilet followed by both Becky and Santana who also needed to use the loo. The others all stayed seating, chatting and thinking about possible dares.

/

"I could treat you right you know" Puck whispered in Vicky's ear.

"I'm sure you could, but from what i've heard, thats not really what you are about is it?" Vicky laughed.

"It could be" Puck said, smirking.

"You are supposed to be the badass one" Vicky whispered in her ear, making sure to linger there a little longer than was necessary to wind him up.

Once again he was left watching as she walked away from him. This was going to take some effort if he was going to make her his.

/

"How long does he take in there?" Becky asked as she leant against the wall waiting for Sam to finish in the bathroom.

Santana huffed and moved past Becky to start hammering on the bathroom door. "Sam, hurry up! Ladies gotta pee!" she shouted. Becky laughed when she heard his muffled reply of "You're not fooling anyone Santana, you're no lady".

"You think that's funny?" Santana asked as she moved away from the door to stand in front of Becky. Her tone of voice said that she was pissed off, but the smirk on her face said that she was playing games with Becky.

"It was" Becky said, pushing herself off from the wall.

"Just tell me" Santana whispered in Becky's ear, her body coming closer to Becky than necessary. She smirked when she felt the other girls breathing hitch when their body's made contact.

"Tell you what?" Becky asked realising that she was now leaning against the wall again and feeling intimidated.

"That you're gay" Santana laughed when Becky shook her head to say no "You gotta be at least Bi" Santana continued but Becky still denied it. "Listen, I am a judgmental bitch and a lesbian, you know what that means?" she asked and Becky just looked up at her confused "It means i have awesome gaydar, and you sweetie, you are making it go crazy" Santana husked, her eyes locked with the other girl.

Becky was about to protest but the door opened making Santana jump back and Becky quickly made her way into the bathroom.

/

Once everyone was back in the basement, the games continued. Becky couldn't help but feel like Santana was up to something as every time she looked at her, the girl had a smirk on her face. Puck chose dare when the bottle landed on him, and Santana dared him to kiss Finn "with tongue". "So, we are playing it that way are we Satan" Puck said as he licked his lips. Finn looked scared and visibly backed away but was quickly grabbed by Puck who carried out his dare and then sat back feeling confident.

Puck dared Brittany to do a sexy dance in the middle of the circle which she happily obliged. It wasn't really a hard dare, but no one could be harsh towards Brittany. Either way her dancing had full attention from all of the boys except for Kurt and Blaine. Santana was obviously watching and enjoying. Surprisingly Tina seemed happy to watch, Vicky didn't avoid watching, but she didn't seem bothered about it either whilst Mercedes and Rachel just averted their eyes. Santana smirked when she noticed that Becky was watching, and looked like she was enjoying it, and she almost laughed out loud when she noticed that Quinn seemed to be enjoying the dancing.

Brittany spun the bottle and it landed on Vicky who she dared to kiss Puck. Puck obviously got excited but Vicky maintained a poker face and gave him a quick peck on the lips. When Puck argued that it wasn't fulfilling the dare, she reminded everyone that Brittany never specified how she should kiss him.

The bottle then landed on Brittany once more, who was actually excited and this time she picked truth. That was hard because Vicky didn't know much about her. Rachel whispered a suggestion in her ear and then Vicky asked if Brittany really did think her cat could talk, the answer of course, was of course Lord Tubbington can talk.

The bottle then landed on Santana again and everyone was keen to find out what Brittany would dare her to do. "Kiss one of the other girls" Brittany said proudly and the boys looked excited, as did Santana. "Who?" she asked and Brittany explained that it could be anyone but her. The smirk was more visible that ever on Santana's face and Becky knew that she was in trouble when the girl locked eyes with her. Santana leant across the circle, making sure that Becky had a clear view down her top and licked her lips. Everybody was quiet as they watched Santana close the gap. The kiss was quick, more than a peck, but no tongues. Just enough to make Santana even more sure that her gaydar was working.

Santana spun the bottle and it landed on Quinn. Before Quinn even had the option of choosing between truth and dare, Santana gave her dare. "Tina involved more than one person, so this isn't against the rules right?" Santana half asked and half stated. Nobody objected. "Quinn and Becky have to show each other their boobs" she said, leaning back on her elbows and looking very pleased with herself. "What?" Becky asked, feeling more annoyed that it wasn't even her dare more than anything else. Puck found this the perfect time to remind them of the forfeit if they didn't do it. Santana watched closely as the girls took turns in looking down the other ones tops, revelling in the look she saw in both of their eyes. This was turning out to be an interesting night.

/

The game ended and soon after everyone decided they needed to get home, it was a school night after all. No one was sober enough to drive, so the boys each walked some of the girls home, making sure that they were all safe.