Spencer spent the whole night awake, thinking about Toby, whether he had done something to himself or her. At dawn, she finally decided that Alex was right: she needed to know, albeit she considered following Toby being wrong. After making up her mind, she put her head on her pillow and instantly fell asleep, only to be awoken by her alarm clock ten minutes later.
A look of frustration formed on her face as she waved her hand above and around the clock, trying to silence it. It finally shut up when she pushed it off her bedside table. She slowly got up, brushed her teeth, got dressed, arranged her hair in a cute ponytail then went downstairs to make herself two cups of coffee. She needed them if she wanted to stay awake during her courses.
At school, she met up with her friends.
"Judging by the cup of coffee that is still in your hand and that tired look on your face, I'm guessing you stayed awake the whole night. Am I right or am I right?" asked Emily.
"I think we need to follow Toby", said Spencer reluctantly.
The girls couldn't believe it: they thought Spencer would never change her mind. But she'd obviously given it a lot of thoughts.
"After school? We can meet up at my house", suggested Aria.
"Good, that will give me time to change from heels into sneakers", said Hanna.
They all laughed then went in as the bell rang. At about 5pm, they were all at Aria's, and Hanna had her sneakers on. They watched Toby get into his car, then they followed him, leaving a distance not to look suspicious. They kept on going for a while, then after twists and turns, they finally arrived at the Lost Woods Resort. They silently followed him to the furthest cabin. There was something they didn't notice before… he was wearing black jeans, a black hoodie and black leather gloves. They agreed to go inside and confront him. They barged into the cabin then stood still at the sight of Toby on the phone, surrounded by what seemed to be from the point of view of the girls millions of photos of them, Alison, their parents, their friends, by voodoo dolls and black clothing. Toby turned around when he heard them and dropped his phone. He then grabbed the closest Liar to him by her wrist, Hanna, and twisted it behind her back, making her let out a small scream. He approached a knife to her throat and started to slowly retreat, using his victim as a cover. They disappeared shortly after, leaving the girls dead worried about Hanna.