Warning: If you do not like yaoi, then please don't read. Thanks!
Later that day, Eric and Alan entered their home and found Danielle, Christopher, and Fangurl sitting in the living room. "Danielle, dad, who's she?" Eric asked.
"This is Fangurl Phantomhive, she is the student counselor at your school," Danielle informed.
"I'm here to just observe your family, so please act as if I wasn't here," Fangurl requested as she sat at the dining room table.
"Okay, well I'm gonna go set my stuff down in my room, I'll be right back," Alan said.
"Do you mind if I ask him a few questions?" Fangurl asked the parents as she started for the stairs.
"What do you wanna know from him?" Eric demanded as he blocked the entrance to the stairs.
"Just to ask him a couple of questions about school," Fangurl said.
Eric glared at Fangurl but allowed her to go upstairs. He grabbed her arm and whispered "If you say anything to make him upset –"
"Don't worry, every question is standard procedure," Fangurl replied.
The girl walked down the hall and knocked on Alan's bedroom door. "What, what is it?" Alan asked in a nervous tone.
"Alan, it's Fangurl, may I come in?" she wondered. The brunette opened his bedroom door and let her in. "Alan I would like to ask you a couple of questions about yourself."
"Am I in trouble?" he asked.
"No, there were a couple of kids at school who say that you and Eric sneak away to the bleachers at the football field," Fangurl informed.
Alan's eyes widened. "Yes, but we always come back for class," Alan snapped with nervousness.
"Alright, now what is you and Eric's relationship like?" Fangurl continued.
"I love him," Alan immediately said. He then caught himself and continued "He's my stepbrother after all. May I please see him?"
"In a minute, now tell me, do you and Eric have a lot of friends or girlfriends?" Fangurl wondered.
"I don't know, I don't care, can I please just go and see Eric?" Alan requested as he felt his body tremble.
"Alan, does your brother abuse you?" Fangurl asked.
The brunette stood up and pushed books off his desk before angrily replying "No, why are you asking me these questions?! Eric and I have a wonderful relationship, why do you care?!" There was a knock at the door before Alan threw it open and latched himself onto his brother. "Make her go away," he cried to Eric.
The blonde held Alan close and looked up at Fangurl. "I told you not to make him upset," he said. "Get away from my brother!" Eric pushed Fangurl out of Alan's room and locked himself and Alan in the room. Eric held Alan as they lay on the bed together and wrapped their arms around one another. Alan cried as Eric shushed him gently, stroked his hair, and kissed his forehead.
Fangurl walked down the stairs and joined Danielle and Christopher. "Is everything alright? We heard yelling," Danielle asked.
Slowly, Fangurl sat down and said "Eric and Alan seem to have a unique relationship. They appear to be attached to one another, a little too much. Eric shows signs of extreme protectiveness over Alan, and Alan seems very fond of Eric; now judging from what you told me, and by the way they act around each other suggests signs of, well this is hard for me to say . . ."
"What, what is it?" Christopher wondered.
"You two are going to think I'm crazy, but your sons are displaying indications of an incestuous relationship," Fangurl stated.
Danielle and Christopher dropped their jaws. "Are you insane?! Eric and Alan would never do something so immoral! They know better than that, they know it's wrong and illegal," Danielle shouted.
"Mrs. Slingby, have Eric and Alan seemed to be acting strange lately to you?" Fangurl inquired.
"No, well the other night I walked into Alan's room in the middle of the night and –" Danielle stopped short.
"What, honey what is it?" Christopher questioned.
Turning to her husband, Danielle stated "Eric and Alan were in bed together, awfully close to one another. Alan claimed he had a nightmare and that Eric was helping him calm down. Oh my God, do you think they're sexually active together do you?"
"To be safe, I would like to talk to them both privately in my office. For the rest of the week, I would like for them individually to come and talk with me. I want Alan to come on Tuesday, and Eric on Wednesday, then I'd like them both to come together on Thursday," Fangurl requested.
"Okay, we will talk to them both, and have them report to you," Christopher promised.
After Fangurl left, Christopher and Danielle called Eric and Alan downstairs. "What is it?" Eric asked.
"Sit down," Christopher stated firmly. Eric and Alan sat down on the couch across from their parents. "Now Miss Phantomhive told us some disturbing news that had better not be true."
"She said the two of you are showing signs of an incestuous relationship, tell me this isn't true," Danielle pleaded.
"Of course not, why would she say that?" Eric asked.
"Because of the way you two act around one another, and because your mother saw the both of you lying together in bed the other night," Christopher said.
"Dad, nothing is happening between us," Eric lied.
"Yeah, why would she tell you something like that?" Alan added.
"You two are going to go talk to that counselor again tomorrow. And if she says that you two are indeed are in an incestuous relationship, you will be separated and sent away from each other. I cannot even believe that you two are being accused of doing something so disgusting. Eric, you will be kicked out of the house, and Alan, you will have no contact with him, if Miss Phantomhive is correct," Christopher growled.
"You two, go upstairs and stay up there for the rest of the night. And stay in your own bedrooms," Danielle instructed.
Eric and Alan stood up and walked upstairs to their bedrooms. Alan lie on his bed and began to cry, while Eric punched his door. This counselor was ruining everything the two of them had worked so hard to keep a secret. In the middle of the night, Eric snuck into Alan's room and held his brother close to him, while the brunette cried quietly. Alan whispered "Eric, I'm scared, Christopher threatened to separate us if they find out the truth."
Eric ran a hand up and down Alan's back before replying "It'll be okay, as long as we're together, no one will break us. I'll make sure she doesn't say anything else to make you upset. We will be together no matter what, I promise." The blonde placed a kiss on his brother's head before closing his eyes to go to sleep.