Duke shook his head, Crystal was looking at him trying to find out what was going on. Then the female pup walked to him, and kissed his cheek. Crystal mouth dropped, and looked at Duke. Jill pulled the pup that kissed Duke away from her brother and Crystal.

"What was that for?" she asked.

"Leave him alone Lola, he has a girlfriend." said Jill. Ghost and Lola looked at her then at Duke.

"Go bro, and let me guess this small pup right here is your girl." Ghost said pointing to Crystal.

"Hi I'm Crystal, nice to meet you."

"Your a nice little pup, good you my brother. O this is my wife Lala." Ghost said tapping on his wife's paw.

"You look like the prefect match for Duke." said Lala.

"Thank you." said Crystal blushing alittle.

"But I'm prefect for Duke, I was his first girlfriend and we were going to be together forever." said Lola. Scar and Lala looked at their sister. Duke rolled his eyes, but he had to step infront of Crystal if she's not that much of a fighting type of pup he wants to protect her.

"Man I heard you stay at the Lookout with the Paw Patrol." said Ghost.

"Yep, I live with my friends, and the Ninja pups."

"Ghost our parents and Snowdrop is at the Lookout now. They would love to see you." said Jill. So they all left, Lola was trying to get next to Duke. She bumped Crystal out the way, and walk right next to him. Crystal was next to Skye and Chase, and they both heard Crystal growl. Duke noticed Crystal wasn't next to him when he turned his head it was Lola. She was about to kiss him but he dodged it and ran back to Crystal. Lola wasn't that happy about losing her man to a small rat with fur.

"He will be mine." she said to herself. Once they got back to the Lookout. Ryder and Cleo was back by that time.

"Ryder I want you to meet my older brother and his wife." said Duke.

"Hello Lola, Duke that's a girl you should be with not a ninja." said Snow. Crystal was starting to get upset, so instead of hearing the comments about her dating Duke. She just walked away into the Lookout. Duke saw her walk away, and gave his mom a look. "Don't give me that look young man."

"Mom leave the girl alone." said Ghost.

"Josh where have I gone wrong with Duke. I thought him and Lola will be together forever." said Snow. Lola was able to walk away to find Crystal. Once she did, she walked to her with a big smile.

"Hi Crystal. I was looking for you."

"Ok well you found me. What do you want?"

"Why do you have to be so mean to me?"

"Well I don't know maybe because you kissed my boyfriend."

"O my, but its not my fault that he still have feelings for me. We may not look alike but we have the same type of style. Maybe thats why he likes you, since you remind him of me. You will never win Duke's heart, and he brake up with you and come back to me."

"That's not true, Duke loves me." yelled Crystal trying not to cry.

"Of course it is, think about it your a young pup, a ninja pup, your to young for love. He feels sorry for you so thats why he is dating you to begin with. The lost of your father, with Ryder going missing twice." Lola saw a tear coming down her face. Then she saw Duke walking to them. "Hello Duke."

"Crystal there you are. I was worried." he said. Lola walked to him and kissed his cheek. Duke had one eye closed. Crystal saw that and was trying to stay strong. "Lola can you stop that please."

"Why Duke sweety, and don't worry we were just having a girl chat." Lola was rubbing her head against him. Duke was trying to get free but she was holding on to him so tight that he couldn't get free.

"I'm going to head back to the Lookout, I will leave you two alone." Crystal said as she started to walk away. Duke was about to say something but Lola jumped and kissed him on the lips. Duke's eyes were closed. Crystal was right there, she saw Duke's face getting red. So she ran off crying. Duke pushed Lola off of him, got up and saw Crystal running off. So he ran after her, and Lola was right behind him. Back at the Lookout, all the pups were watching Azul and Trixie play pup pup boogie. Then the heard yelling. Duke and Lola walked in.

"Hey guys have any of you seen Crystal." asked Duke. They all looked at each other and nodded no. "This is not good, I need to find her."

"Duke whats going on?" asked Azul.

"Ask Lola, she was with her before I found the both of them."

"Well I was just talking to her thats it. No harm done." said Lola as she looked at Snow with a smile.

"Okay we need to find my sister now, Kari you stay here in case she comes back. Azul and Zuma you guys check by water. Skye your by air. The rest of us look everywhere in Adventure Bay. Lets go." said Platinum. Once they left, Blaster, Jill, Ghost, and Lala went to help also.

"Whatever you did Lola thank you. This might work in order to break them up." said Snow. Snowdrop smiled and so did Josh.

"The next thing we have to do is get him out of the Paw Patrol." said Josh. It was late almost midnight Crystal was no where to be found. Duke was pacing, and worried sick about her. "Son calm down she will be back." said Josh. But Duke was to worried to pay attention. No one in the Paw Patrol or the Ninja Pups saw Duke like this. Platinum smelled something, he got up. Wendy saw him.

"Platinum what's wrong?" she asked. But he didn't answer until they all saw an adult Terrier with Crystal on her back. Duke's mom wasn't happy that Crystal was back.

"Hello is this the Lookout?" the Terrier asked.

"Yes, it is. How can I help you?" said Ryder. The terrier took Crystal off her back. Duke saw that it was Crystal, so he ran to her but the terrier started to growl at him. So Platinum walked up to her.

"Calm down mom, this is Crystal's boyfriend Duke." he said.

"So your Duke, she take saying your name in her sleep. Platinum take care of your sister, she been crying. Its none of my business to know why. So I will be on my way." said Terrier.

"Mom please stay for Crystal please." Platinum said. The mother looked at her son and then at her daughter.

"Okay Platinum I will stay." she said.

"So whats your name?" asked Brittany.

"O sorry where are my manners, I'm Amber. Nice to meet all of you." Then Crystal started to wake up.

"Where am I? Mom is that you?"

"Your back at the Lookout honey, and yes its me my little Crystal light." Crystal jumped up and hugged her mom, and Platinum hugged her also. "Its so good to see both of my babies right now." Amber said crying. Duke tapped on Crystal's shoulder. She looked at him, and backed away from him. Once he started to walk close to her, she ran off, and Duke followed her. Outside Crystal was still running until she hurt her paw. Duke got his medical bag, and walked to her. Crystal didn't even look at him.

"Crystal whats wrong what did I even do to you to get the cold shoulder?" he asked.

"Do you have feelings for Lola?" she asked.

"Wait what?"

"Do..you..have..feel..ings.. ..la?" she said slowly. Duke remained quiet. "Do you yes or no or are you just dating me cuz you feel sorry for me?"

"No I don't feelings for Lola, I broke up with her way before I came to Adventure Bay, why would you ask that you know that my heart only belongs to you and only you."

"Well when she kissed you, you most of enjoyed it since your eyes were closed. Is she a better kisser then me, or do you just want to be with her more."

"Where is this all coming from? I broke up with Lola, and I'm dating you. Wait a minute, what did Lola even tell you?" he saw Crystal walking away from him. So he ran infront of her. Crystal tried to get around, but her paw was hurting. "Crystal what did she tell you?" Crystal didn't look at him. Duke looked at her, and put his paw on hers. "Crystal, please tell me, I'm not going to lose you because of this dumb fight. I love you too much to lose you." Crystal still didn't look at him. So Duke put his paw under her chin, and lift her head to meet eye-to-eye. He looked into her eyes, it had pain, fear, sadness, and it was like she was about to cry again. So Duke pulled her in for a hug, Crystal was trying to brake free, but gave in. They broke apart, Duke looked at her again, and kissed her right on the lips. He felt movement, it was her body shaking, and his paw was getting wet from her tears. They pulled apart again, Duke used his paw to wipe her tears. "Crystal, listen to me. Lola will not get between us. I will not let her. You are the only pup that I love. If she get near you, don't talk to her." Crystal looked at him and nodded tears still coming down her face. Duke and Crystal kissed again. Behind the trees was Lola and Snow, they ran off.