A/N: Sorry this chapter took so long. I wanted to get it just right. Hopefully I did that. Also loved the idea of Kurt in some sort of lingerie. I could see him loving the silk and lace but it did not fit into my story. Maybe some other time. Thanks for all the love.

What Do You Suppose Would Happen?

Chapter Eleven

"Well? What do you think?"

And before Finn could even answer, Kurt held up his hand.

"Wait…"

Kurt reached into that big bag and pulled out a cowboy hat. He put it on, completing his look.

"Wow, Kurt!" Finn said. "How did you get the outfit from when we sang Last Name at Sectionals?"

"I asked Mr. Schue if I could borrow them… I didn't tell him what I really wanted it for, of course."

Finn just smiled at him. He always thought Kurt looked good in that outfit… and he even had on the cowboy boots. He remembered Kurt dancing to the music, and his own reaction to that. It was really the start of it all.

"Oh, this is for you," Kurt said as he pulled out another black cowboy hat.

Was that a magic bag he had? How did he fit all that stuff in it?

Finn put on the hat and smirked at his boyfriend.

"Very nice, Finn," he said with an appreciative glance. "Very sexy."

"Thanks, Kurt," Finn said. "And you look really hot!"

"Thanks, sweetie."

"No… I mean you look really hot. Don't you want to take off some of those clothes?"

Kurt laughed as he started undressing for Finn. After he took the shirt off, he started to remove his hat.

"Could you leave the hat on?"

"Sure, but I am not wearing the boots…"

"No problem," Finn said moving closer. He undid Kurt's belt buckle, smiling to himself. He definitely couldn't see Kurt wearing this stuff normally.

"So what were you thinking… Kurt?" he asked. "At first I thought we were gonna playing cowboys and Indians… but now I'm thinking cowboys and cowboys?"

"Whatever you want, Finn," he said, his voice breathless as Finn unzipped his jeans. "We could pretend we're cowboys… do the whole Brokeback Mountain thing… or if you have another idea…"

"Actually, Kurt, to be honest, we don't have to do any of that stuff. I want you so much…it's really been a long week… I don't need anything but you."

"Are you saying you missed me?" Kurt asked, "Missed kissing me? Touching me?" Kurt was teasing him, and he didn't think he could take it for very long.

"Just kiss me already, cowboy," Finn said grabbing Kurt's belt loops and pulling him close.

Kurt's lips were on him in an instant. They kissed eagerly… And it was not an easy thing to do wearing cowboy hats. Finn's hands wandered down the other boy's back, pulling him closer.

"I did miss you, Kurt. I missed this," he said as he moved his hand to cup Kurt's erection. Kurt gasped, pushing against Finn's hand.

"I missed you doing that, Finn," he said. "And all these clothes are just in my way.'

Finn definitely agreed with him. It didn't take long for them to be in nothing but their underwear and of course, the cowboy hats. Although there was a moment when they were taking off Kurt's boots… Kurt had to sit on the bed with Finn straddling his leg. Kurt used his other foot to push on Finn's butt as he pulled off first one boot and then the other. That had been interesting, especially when he could feel Kurt's bare foot pressing against his bottom as he bent over the other boot...

Once they were undressed, he pulled Kurt onto the bed with him. He kissed Kurt hungrily, knocking the cowboy hat off and onto the bed. He couldn't wait. All the frustration of the last week… wanting Kurt but never really getting to have him. He needed him so much.

"Kurt," he moaned, once again palming the other boy's arousal.

"Wait, Finn," he said. "If you don't stop that, it's going to be over much too quickly."

"Are you just teasing me, Kurt?" And as he said the words, he realized they were true. Kurt definitely had something else planned.

"Would I do that, Finn?"

"Yes," he replied.

Kurt chuckled as he straddled Finn.

He put the hat on once again as he leaned in closer.

"Are you sure you don't want to be cowboys, Finn? I can just see it… we're two cowboys out on a cold night. We barely know each other, but we have to share a sleeping bag just to stay warm…"

Finn hadn't wanted to really do this. He just wanted to do Kurt… but he found himself caught up in Kurt's fantasy anyway.

"And as your body presses against mine… you have a reaction, and we both notice it. You're embarrassed, and you try to pull away but I won't let you. I kiss you and at first you're too afraid to respond but then suddenly we're all over each other… touching each other with calloused hands… rubbing and kissing… and we know we might regret it later, but at that moment we don't care."

"Kurt," he groaned. "You're driving me crazy!" He took Kurt's hand and placed it once again on his aching cock. "Please, Kurt."

"Is this what you want, Finn?" he asked, as he squeezed lightly.

"Yes," he gasped.

Kurt kissed the side of his face, whispering in his ear … and Finn realized the other boy was going to drag it out as long as he could.

"Do you know why I dressed up as a cowboy, Finn?"

"Because of the whole cowboy movie thing?"

"Partly," he said as his hand moved to squeeze his balls. "But there were other reasons."

"Could we talk about it later, Kurt?" Finn gasped… he could barely speak at this point.

"I want you to guess, Finn. And if you get it right I will give you what you want."

Finn was having a hard time even thinking straight. He wasn't good at this kind of thing under normal circumstances… but now, with Kurt on top of him, stroking him…

He tried to focus on what Kurt wanted…

"Was it the ride a cowboy song?"

"Very good guess. That song definitely made me horny. The thought of riding you… but no, Finn. Guess again." Why did Kurt sound so in control? Wasn't he affected at all? And why did that turn him on even more?

"Please, Kurt…"

"That's not a guess."

"Ummm… okay. The way you always told me to… 'Settle down, cowboy'?"

"I'm impressed, Finn," he said. "But no, that's not it. It's much simpler than that."

"Kurt! Really, I feel like I'm taking a test… you know I'm not good at stuff like that!" He looked up trying to clear his mind. It must not be too hard. Kurt wants him to get it right, after all. And then as he stared ahead… he got it. He just had to look at his walls…

"My cowboy wallpaper."

"Exactly right, Finn!" Kurt said. "And now for your reward."

Finn sighed in relief, until he realized Kurt was kissing his way down his body.

"Kurt… I just don't think you should do that… I won't be able to last…"

"I want to taste you, Finn," he replied. "And you aren't going to stop me."

And as Kurt got closer to his goal, Finn found he no longer wanted to stop him. The thought of Kurt's mouth on him… No one had ever done that to him before… He tried to focus on not erupting even before Kurt got to him.

And suddenly he could feel Kurt's hot mouth on him. The other boy was tentative at first but soon grew bolder, and Finn found he was as hard as a rock.

Kurt was no longer talking. The sounds coming from him were more like slurping, sucking, and at times moaning deep in his throat. Finn found he could really feel those sounds. He tried to hold on for as long as he could. But at one point, Kurt's finger moved to trace lightly against his hole, and he lost it. Kurt took in as much as he could before taking Finn out of his mouth, gasping for breath.

"Was that okay?" he asked after a moment. He looked so hopeful that Finn felt a wave of adoration for the other boy.

"Amazing, Kurt," he said, pulling him up against him. "And I loved your cowboy fantasy."

Kurt snuggled against him, kissing him lightly.

"Thanks, Finn."

And as they held each other, Finn realized that Kurt was still hard… the evidence resting against his leg. He needed to do something about that. Something for his boyfriend that would show how much he appreciated him.

Unfortunately, that was the last thought he had before he fell asleep.

A/N: This chapter was a response to a prompt from GleeFan5…. I had to break it up into two chapters though so I will tell you the prompt after the next chapter. More sexy times to come. After all we can't just leave Kurt frustrated, right?

~#~#~

I have updated my profile page with a new project I am working on. Please check it out. :)