A/N: Last chapter had the lowest amount of reviews this story has ever gotten for a chapter so I am thinking you guys did not like it. Maybe because Kurt was left frustrated or you really did want to see Kurt in lingerie? Here is the second part. I hope you all enjoy it more. Spoilers for Brokeback Mountain.
What Do You Suppose Would Happen?
Chapter Twelve
Kurt woke up and found he was still achingly hard. He had been very frustrated when Finn fell asleep on him. But the other boy looked so sweet; Kurt didn't have the heart to wake him.
It was early… He checked his phone. It was almost six in the morning. He moved so he was spooning his boyfriend. He loved waking up next to Finn. This was actually the first time they had slept the whole night together. He could definitely get used to it.
Kurt kissed Finn's back, causing the other boy to stir in his sleep. Although he hadn't wanted to wake Finn last night, he had no qualms about doing it now. But he was not in any rush to do it. They had time.
He lazily ran his tongue over Finn's skin, loving the taste of him. And that reminded him of the night before, and he blushed in response. He had given his boyfriend a blow job, and he enjoyed it more than he thought he would. It was uncomfortable at first… feeling like he was going to gag but after a bit, he found he really liked it. And Finn definitely did!
That also reminded him of something else that had happened last night. When he had touched Finn there, it had put him over the edge. It made him wonder if Finn was gay.
Actually, he already knew the answer to that, but he wondered if Finn knew. Really, knew. Kurt was determined to find out.
"Wake up, Finn," he said softly as he kissed the back of Finn's neck. The other boy moved in response but still did not wake up. Kurt knew he could take more drastic measures, but he wasn't ready to do that, yet.
He kissed his way up to right behind Finn's ear.
"Sweetie, you need to wake up and pleasure your oh so deserving boyfriend."
"Hmm?" Finn mumbled, not quite awake yet.
So Kurt did what he needed to do. He bit down on Finn's ear lobe.
"What?" Finn gasped, suddenly awake.
"Hey, Finn," Kurt said. "Glad you're awake."
"What time is it, Kurt?" he said groggily, looking over at him.
"Early… almost six."
"What the hell? I'm exhausted." And he turned around as if he was going to go back to sleep.
"Finn, wake up," Kurt said firmly. "I know you're tired, but you fell asleep on me last night."
"Oh, yeah."
"So now you are going to make it up to me. Finn? Are you listening to me?"
"Yeah, but can't we do it later. I just want to sleep a little longer."
"Finn, our parents will be up later."
"Okay, Kurt…"
It was quiet then, and Kurt knew he'd lost him once again to sleep.
Time to bring out the big guns. Kurt pushed up against his boyfriend as he reached around to stroke him. He was already half hard, and Kurt wondered if he had been dreaming about him.
Finn stretched his legs, pushing back against him.
"Mmmm," he mumbled as he turned around to face Kurt.
"Hey," Kurt said. "Good morning."
"Good morning," Finn replied as he kissed him.
"You fell asleep on me last night, Finn," he repeated.
"I know. I'm sorry," he said as he brushed Kurt's bangs out of his face.
"It's okay," he replied. "You're going to make it up to me."
"Anything you want, babe."
Kurt found he liked the sound of the endearment.
"Good… I hope you mean that."
Finn really opened his eyes then. Obviously thinking about what Kurt might ask him to do, helped to really wake him up.
Kurt just smiled as he kissed him again. He turned their bodies so he was once again straddling Finn. He rubbed their erections together as he leaned down to kiss Finn's chest. His hand wandered to Finn's legs, stroking the inside of his thighs.
"Kurt," he moaned.
"Do you like that, Finn?"
As an answer, the other boy thrust up against him.
"Not yet, sweetie," he said. "I want to ask you something first."
"More talking, Kurt. Can't we just have sex?"
"It's important, Finn."
"What did you want to ask me?"
"Are you… I mean, do you consider yourself…gay?"
"What?" He stopped moving and looked at Kurt. "I'm here with you, Kurt. And after all we have done … you're asking me that?"
"I mean, I know you like me… like having sex with me…"
"I don't understand, Kurt."
Kurt blushed. He didn't think it would be this difficult to talk about. "I guess I'm asking if you like me as a guy? Or do you think of me as an honorary girl?"
"Don't you remember the whole Brokeback Mountain thing? I think of you as a guy, Kurt. Not a girl. I like this," he said as he grabbed Kurt's still hard cock.
"I know you do…"
"Then what's this about, Kurt?"
"I guess I want to hear you say it. Tell me you're gay or at least bi."
"Really, Kurt? I can't believe you don't know already. You know how I feel about you, right?"
"Yeah, I do Finn. I just want you to know."
"That doesn't make any sense, Kurt."
"Fine… then just kiss me."
And Finn kissed him… and it was hot and urgent, and Kurt knew he was trying to say what he wasn't able to put into words. But it wasn't enough for him.
"Remember what you said earlier, Finn?"
"Yeah… wait, what did I say?"
"That you would do whatever I wanted."
"Oh, yeah… that. Sure… what do you want, Kurt?"
"I want to make love to you, Finn," he said softly in his ear.
"That doesn't sound too bad. I think I would like that…"
Kurt smiled at him. He was just too adorable. He playfully kissed his chin and then bit down… not hard. No reason to scare him. Finn was smiling at him. Hopefully he would still be smiling after what Kurt said next.
"I want to be on top, Finn."
"I… what… what do you mean?" he asked nervously.
Kurt was sure he had an idea, but he explained it anyway.
"I want to be inside you," Kurt said watching his boyfriend carefully.
"I… Kurt, I don't think I'm ready for that, yet. I mean this is all new to me."
"You're ready, Finn. But don't worry… I'll take it slow."
"Kurt…"
But Kurt didn't let him get any further. He kissed him passionately as he continued his exploration of his boyfriend's legs. Slowly he moved closer to his goal. Finn moaned in appreciation, and Kurt could feel him relax. His hand stroked his member on one side as he pushed his bottom against him on the other. Finn again starting thrusting, and Kurt almost changed his mind. It wouldn't take much for Finn to be inside him … and he wanted him so much…
"Settle down, cowboy," Kurt whispered. He ran his finger over the head of Finn's cock, and then moved his hand down to Finn's bottom. The other boy had his knees bent, and Kurt had easy access. He lightly stroked his hole, using the precum to make it easier. Kurt smiled as he heard Finn moan. But when he pushed his finger in slightly, Finn panicked.
"Kurt… I don't know…"
"Shh, Finn," he said. "It's only my finger." He teased the small opening once again until Finn was whimpering.
He leaned forward. "Should I go on, Finn?"
"I don't know…"
"Just because you like it, Finn, it doesn't make you any less of a guy," he whispered.
"I know…"
"Do you?" Kurt asked. "And being on the receiving end, doesn't make you the girl…"
"Kurt I'm just confused,"
"Do you trust me, Finn? I want to show you how amazing it can be."
Finn didn't say anything, he just nodded. Kurt felt a swell of excitement and love for his boyfriend. He trusted him not to hurt him, and it gave Kurt the confidence he needed to continue.
Kurt retrieved the lube and a condom from the bedside. Finn had his eyes closed as Kurt lubed up his middle finger and again touched his boyfriend. Finn was talking deep breaths, and Kurt kissed him sweetly, trying to calm him down.
He rubbed slow circles around the edge until Finn relaxed and was once again pushing against his finger. He pressed in further causing Finn to gasp.
"Are you okay?" he asked.
"Don't," Finn said, panting, "don't stop, please, Kurt."
Kurt used another finger to open him up as much as possible.
"Please," he said again.
"What do you want, Finn?" Kurt asked, as he moved his fingers further in.
"You…"
"Inside you?"
"Yes…"
"Why, Finn? Tell me why."
"Because…"
"Because why?" He started to pull out, but Finn grabbed his hand holding it against him.
"Kurt,"
"Finn, look at me…" Finn opened his eyes and tried to focus…his eyes were glazed over with lust. "Tell me what you want,"
"I want … you inside me, Kurt,"
"Why?" he whispered.
"Because you're my boyfriend and … I'm gay."
Kurt kissed him fiercely before reaching for the condom and slipping it on.
"Are you ready, sweetie," he said. He knew Finn was still nervous about it even though he nodded.
Kurt moved, positioning himself between Finn's legs. He eased in, taking it slow and letting Finn get used to the feeling before moving in further. He knew how much it hurt at first, and he wanted to make it good for him.
"Harder, Kurt," Finn said with a groan. "I won't break."
That was all the encouragement Kurt needed. He pounded against the other boy, trying to hit that one spot that would really make it worthwhile for Finn. He knew he wouldn't last much longer. Finn was tighter than he could even imagine, and it felt amazing.
"Kurt!" Finn cried out, and he couldn't hold back any longer. He watched as his boyfriend came all over his own stomach and chest, and he thought he would never see anything more erotic than that.
He kissed Finn once again and whispered, "You okay?"
"I'm great," Finn said with a shy smile, and Kurt let out the breath he didn't realized he'd been holding. "What about you?"
"I'm great, too, Finn."
They curled up in each other's arms just enjoying the moment.
"Kurt?"
Finn sounded sad, and Kurt looked up into his face. He was looking at the ceiling.
"Yes?"
"That movie was sad…"
Kurt didn't have to ask which movie he meant.
"I know."
"I mean… he died in the end… he was killed… because he was gay, right?"
"Yes," Kurt replied. He wondered if Finn was regretting what he said… what they'd done. He would get teased or worse when everyone else found out about them. Would he still want to be with Kurt then?
"All those times they came back to each other, though. They loved each other, don't you think?"
"Yes," Kurt agreed. He didn't know what else to say.
"No matter what pain they went through, it was worth it if they could be together, even for a little while."
Again, Kurt agreed, watching Finn's face.
Then Finn looked down at him and smiled.
"It is worth it, Kurt," Finn said as he kissed him. "You're worth it."
"Finn," Kurt whispered, as he pulled him into another kiss, ignoring the tears now falling down his face.
A/N: Okay got a little sappy at the end but I'm just a romantic sap… sue me. Below is the prompt I got for this chapter and last. I had already planned part of this so I was able to work it in. Some things I didn't seem to fit so I left them off, as you can see. Thanks also to lynxzpanther for her comments on Brokeback Mountain which I incorporated into the story. This is not over so stay tuned.
This is the prompt from GleeFan5:
Kurt takes Finn into Finn's "closet"...Errr... I mean bedroom, where sexy times happen...(Of which there is some Brokeback Mt. style role playing involved)... ;D
BONUS POINTS if BOTH Finn are Kurt are wearing the hats from "The Rhodes Not Taken" episode during/before/after foreplay/sex.
BONUS POINTS if Kurt wears COWBOY BOOTS in addition.
BONUS POINTS if you incorporate the "Settle down, Cowboy" line...;D
1. Finn, during sex, asks what spurred the idea to roleplay BBM style when Kurt denies Finn the answer of, until Finn remembers why (see "I live in a closet that has cowboy wallpaper", line)...
2. FINN ADMITTING THAT HE IS BISEXUAL, (EMBARRASSINGLY), because he remembers the answer/is able to put the pieces together to the question posed in #1) ...Please have this come about because Kurt is denying Finn something sexual (without Finn admitting his sexuality), and Finn, admitting it because he wants it/him BAD ENOUGH...~3...Yep! that's an Evil!Dom!Kurt for you. ;D
3. Top!Kurt turning to bottoming!Kurt straddling Finn on top...(If that makes sense)...(Size!kink)... ;D~3 3 3