Disclaimer: I own no rights to Glee or any characters portrayed in any of my writings!

"1, 2, 3, step, for-ward, back, turn"

Finn gazed in awe as Mr. Schue demonstrated the dance number for their first song. He couldn't resist watching how his director swayed from side to side with such symmetry. There was perfect posture and balance. Not even a quiver, even though he seemed exhausted. Finn watched as the sweat slowly slid down Will's forehead, down the side of his face and off his cute butt chin.

Puck and Kurt did their routines but to Finn it wasn't the same as how great Mr. Schue's performance was.

"Your turn Finn... Come on... Puck and Kurt have got it down"

Finn snaps out of his trance and tries to do the number but still a little shaky, he slips and falls.

"Ok guys, that's all for today, see you tomorrow" Mr. Schue was pausing nearly after every word trying to regain his breath.

Finn remains on the ground, upset that he can't get the moves done correctly, while Puck and Kurt go the change. Mr. Scheuster sits next to Finn.

"I know you want it Finn. I can see it on your face. I can feel it off of you. What's holding you back?"

"Nothing Mr. Schue... I'm just really tired I guess, got a lot on my mind, ya know?"

Will's heart was pulsating. He kept firm in trying to lie to himself that he was for some strange reason attracted to his student. He watched as Finn's dopey expression changed to a semi smile as if he was thanking him for being interested in his life. He studied the young jock turned performer, watching how the sweat was dripping from his now moist dark brown hair. He sat there wondering what it would really be like to have the tall teenager's lips upon his own.

Finn laid back on the choir room's floor.

"Mr. Schue, have you ever had the feeling where you think someone was into you but the possibility seemed so unrealistic?"

"Um..." He paused to make sure he thought through what his response would be "Believe it or not... I'm in a sort of position like that right now actually. There's this really cute gu-girl". He shivers and his pores raise as he feels his heart skip a beat with his near slip up. "and well, let's say she's.. Um.. How to put this delicately? Let's say she's 'out of my league'." He didn't know how else to put it as he knew to himself he was actually talking about Finn. He lays on his side next to Finn, inching down slowly as he is shaking nervously. His nervousness is not seen by Finn, but Will was practically cold sweating as he lay there next to the broad jock.

"Why did you ask Finn? Girl trouble? Anything I can help with? Advice?"

"Nah.. I think I'll have to figure this one out on my own. Thanks though Mr. Schue"

Finn smiles as he sits up and then hops up and leaves to go change.

Finn felt his heart sink as he soaked in what Mr. Scheuster said about being interested in a woman. "I wonder if it's a staff member? Could it be Ms. Pillsbury, they're really close but she isn't someone out of his league.." Finn was puzzled for a moment. "Nah, it can't be her. I wonder if he's deflecting, trying to throw me off his path? Is he on to me? What should I do? Ugh! This sucks! I haven't felt this way about anyone since I had that crush on Puck however long ago that was." Finn never told Puck how he felt. He knew Puck wasn't interested -or so he thought- and that they only started the friends with benefits sessions cause sometimes they were horny and they had broken up with their girlfriends. "I should just settle down for a bit.. Maybe not take this on so much"

"That was a close one. I don't think I would have been able to squeeze my way out of that." Will was still a bit shaken from nearly outing himself to Finn. "Would that have been such a bad thing though...? I mean, the guys are really cool with Kurt.. But then again.. I'm not quite even sure what's going on with me. I don't think I've ever felt so strong about anyone besides Terry. Am I over thinking this?"

Will was becoming desperate in trying to figure out what was going on with him. He did the only thing he could think of to help with the situation, he gave the three members of his club the topic of the week, "Sexuality".

Kurt was of course super excited with this topic and couldn't wait to go to Between the Sheets to get some material.

"Ok guys, since it's only three of you, I'm gonna have to partner up with one of you on this. So, I tossed all our names in here - he holds up his hat - and we're gonna vote. Here are 3 straws. Whoever pulls the shortest, gets to pick from the hat and decide our fates." Kurt got the shortest straw.

Kurt nervously pulls the first slip from the hat. His fingers were tangled up by a strand of Will's hair that was in the hat. He began to fidget to open the paper and his face lit up when he saw those four letters. It was so coincidental that all their names were only 4 letters. Will, Puck and Finn all awaited for him to say which name he got... It was Finn.

Will became a bit disappointed as he hoped he would get to spend more time with Finn.

Kurt was deeply in love with Finn. He knew from the first time he stepped into McKinley and saw Finn trying out for the football team, that he would one day hold his hand and they would walk into the sunset - or so he dreamed at least. "We should go to Behind the Sheets to get some material for our performance Finn. Then we could head home and work on the dance moves."

"Uuuhhh, ok sure. But don't you feel a little weird doing this, ya know? Seeing as our parents are dating?"

"No. Why would it be weird? It's just a performance Finn."

"I hope so" Finn was still uncertain about Kurt's intentions. He did feel sometimes like Kurt was trying to hit on him.

Puck met Will at his apartment that same afternoon.

"Ok Puck, we got some work to do. I know you have the whole bad boy thing going for you, so maybe me could expand on that. Kurt is definitely gonna try and control their performance, probably do something romantic, so maybe we can do the opposite. Something aggressive but there's still passion."

"Mr. Schue, with all do respect, you just sounded like McKinley's Homo Leader."

"Come on Puck. We're passed that. We are two grown adults. We both know what we want. A performance is not gonna change that."

Puck had a delay in his thought process. "Oh, uh, yeah, of course..."

Will heard the uncertainty in Puck's vocals.

"Is everything ok Puck? You sound a bit worried"

"Nah, everything's fine. Just a bit nervous."

"Nervous about what? You're Puck, or Puckarexus or whatever you call yourself"

"Puckasaurus! It's not that hard Mr. Schue"

"Yeah, that, whatever. Why are you nervous? You know this is a safe space. What's on your mind?"

Will was a bit worried about putting stress on his students seeing that is was male on male interaction, but at the same time, he did want to figure out what was going on with himself and this could just be the solution.

"Its nothing!"

"Ok Puck, but if you ever need..."

"Yes, yes, you're here to talk. I get it. Can we start?"

The dance number was a bit awkward. Heck, any dance number with two guys would be awkward. Especially with two guys trying to figure out themselves while thinking the other is totally comfortable with them self.

Will wasn't as nervous whilst he and Puck were rehearsing. Things seemed to be moving in a good direction. He guessed that was because he tried to create a routine with little to no actual body connection. There were mostly hand clasps.

"This isn't so bad... Why does it feel so weird with Finn though... I don't even feel anything right now. And I think I'm being a bit more intimate with Puck than I ever was with Finn... Well except that whole bathroom incident."

Will wasn't concentrating and his and Puck's feet intertwined and Will collapse on top of Puck. Their chests crashed together creating a loud thud and they both cringed and moaned in pain. Will slowly raised his body only to collapse again as he was still weak, mostly from the shock his body was going through from the fall. He tilted his head up and something clicked. He stared into Puck's hazel eyes as they stared back into his. Both Will and Puck felt a connection, but nothing physical-other than the actual fall itself. Puck then broke the tension.

"Mr. Schue, I'm gay. At least I think I am."

"Are you sure Puck? You have never been one who seemed interested in guys"

"I think I love Finn. He's my best friend, we do everything together, he's always been there for me. When my dad left, when my mum was constantly working to keep the house together, through the break ups, he's always been there for me."

Will was still laying on top of his student.

"Um, that sounds like love, but are you getting confused with what kind of love. Because that sounds like brotherly love and not as if you're physically attracted to him."

"How would you know Mr. Schue... You've never gone through all that stuff. And he's the only one that's really been there. Not even Santana kept so much interest in my life. I know she loves me, but she also loved the sex."

"Ok Puck, we're gonna be adults here and keep this to ourselves, ok? This is solely to help you, especially since I'm not your legal guardian or guidance counsellor or anything of the sort."

"Ok Mr. Schue, you know you can trust me. What are you gonna do?"

Will leaned in a smacked his lips against Puck's. Puck's eyes opened wide as he was in complete and total shocked. He pushed Will off.

"What the hell Mr. Schue?"

"I'm sorry Puck. I just wanted to see if you were really gay"

"Mr. Schue, while I am flattered, you're like twice my age. Not to mention you're not gay and you're my teacher. Everything there is completely inappropriate!"

"I thought we were being adults?"

"Yeah, but it was... It was just weird and unexpected. And for a straight guy, you seemed so comfortable with that kiss..."

Puck tried watching Will in the eyes but his teacher glared away. Puck inched in closer to see his reaction. To him, this had turned into a game. To Will, it had turned into a nightmare.

Will began to sweat as the situation became a bit compromising. Ok, more than a bit, but he was still certain he could manoeuvre his way around it.

"I was just trying to help Puck" he stated still laying on his chest.

Puck had one hand behind his head as they lay there, his other was pointing straight up, but he then used it to put on Will's waist and he grabbed a hold on his teacher's t-shirt. He then moved his other hand and gently laid his head on his teacher's apartment flooring. He planted his hand on Will's cheek which made Will shiver a bit and it raised his pours. Will still kept his eyes everywhere but in the direction of Puck's. Before Will could comprehend what was going on, he felt the boy's mouth against his again and Will just felt his body giving in so he kissed back. The kiss grew more passionate and aggressive as the time went on.

"This aggressive enough for you Mr. Schue?!" Puck stated whilst they were still making out.

Will was so engrossed he simply moaned yes in agreement. Will rolled over so that Puck was now over him. Their mouths didn't disconnect.

"This does feel good, but I still don't feel how Finn makes me feel. Am I only attracted to him? Is Puck doing something wrong? That can't be it cause he knows how to use his tongue"

Will moaned all while he was thinking.

"Ok, wait, wait!"

Puck pulled away.

"What's wrong?" Will began to feel the guilt in this situation. He had taken advantage of his student. All his ethics, he watched them get flushed down the toilet.

"What's wrong?! I'm sorry. We shouldn't have done this" Puck stated. "I love Finn, I feel like if I've cheated on him. I mean, I told you we do everything together. I think I should go."

"Wait... Puck."

Puck raced up, grabbed his things and headed for the door. Tears began forming in his eyes, as he thought about what he did. Puck had never kissed another guy before. It was the only thing special between Finn and himself and all he could think of is that they had nothing special again.

"Wait...!" Will shouted.

"BAM!" The apartment door shut and Will was left standing there.