Author's Note: Um… heyyyy guys. So, let me just start off by stating how horrible I am for updating this story more than a year later. I know, I know, I'm a mess. No excuse in the world can make up for that. I will be honest and admit that I had been so busy, and then life kept happening, and more and more time went on and before I knew it, a year had passed. But, I couldn't help how much I enjoyed this story, and I still had so many ideas planned for it, so I decided that it would only be right to update it. I'm not sure who's still willing to stick with this story, but I swear that I will finish it to its completion, and I will not keep you guys waiting like I did last time. Well, without further ado, here's Chapter 11 of Decisions.

"You," Enzo growled as the veins in his forehead practically began to surge through his head. Angelina took an instinctive step back as she slowly processed what was happening in front of her.

"What the hell is the matter with you?" Damon scoffed as his eyes trekked Enzo's distressed state. Stefan jogged back into the house with a questioning look on his face, wondering what was taking everyone so long.

"Oh, I don't know, Damon. Let's start with the fact that you fucked my girlfriend. And then, to make matters worse, you and her both failed to mention to me that something went down between you two. And last, but definitely not fucking least, you got her pregnant!" Enzo barked, watching as everyone within the house went wide-eyed.

"What did you just say?" Stefan gasped.

"Oh, shit," Angelina muttered as she stared between the two. She had no idea what she had gotten herself into. Damon froze in place at Enzo's words. His hands began to tremble as he slowly tried to piece together what was just said to him.

"Uh-uh, Enzo, there's no way that—

"Oh, just stop lying, already!" Enzo interrupted as his fists clenched and unclenched. "Do you recall taking the vampire cure? Well, according to Angelina, the only way that Bonnie could have conceived that baby was with a vampire who took a dose of the cure."

"Damon… this can't be true… is it?" Stefan whispered. Damon slowly allowed his eyes to fall to the ground as the realization hit him. He did take the cure. But, he had no idea that it really had taken any effect on him. He didn't feel different after taking it, so he never could have guessed that it gave him the ability to have children. His eyes met Enzo's again, and an uncomfortable jolt surged through his body.

"It only happened one time," was all he could let out. The mixture of pain, anger, and betrayal was written all over Enzo's face, and he didn't dare try to explain how he truly felt about Bonnie in that instant. He knew that Enzo would not be able to handle it.

"I can't fucking believe this," Enzo spat as he quickly stormed out of the house, abandoning the rest of the dishes for the baby shower in the kitchen.

"Congratulations, Mr. Salvatore. Looks like you've won yourself an infant," Angelina sang as she brushed past him, following after Enzo. Damon still couldn't believe his ears. Eliza was… his?

"I don't think you realize what this means," Stefan finally spoke up as his eyes remained on an immobile Damon.

"I feel sick to my stomach right now," Damon admitted as his eyes found Stefan's.

"How could you do this to Elena? To Enzo? To Bonnie?" Stefan breathed.

"To Bonnie? I didn't do anything to her that she didn't want me to. It was mutual," he blurted.

"When did this even happen? And how?" Stefan inquired.

"She was broken up with Enzo. It just… happened," he told him as his mind reflected on that very vivid day that everything had went down between them.

"And that's all it was? Just a hook-up?" Stefan wondered. Damon slowly nodded his head, even though he knew in his heart that it was so much more than that. Stefan scoffed and shook his head. "You're lying."

"How would you know?" Damon asked, offense to his tone.

"You told me you loved her," Stefan reminded him. Damon cursed himself mentally, recalling on the drunken day that he had allowed those words to slip. He gulped loudly as he plopped to the ground, grabbing at his hair with his quivering hands.

"Bonnie means the world to me," he whispered painfully, avoiding Stefan's gaze. "I tried to fight it. I tried to tell myself I was just lonely, and she was just there. But when she disappeared, I couldn't help but think about her all the time. Wonder what could have been between us, if things were different. And all this time… she was gone, with my baby."

"Enzo is crushed right now," Stefan said after a minute.

"I didn't ask for this to happen," Damon responded.

"Well, it just did. Now, what are we going to do?" Stefan asked. Damon slowly rose to his feet and took a deep breath.

"I guess we have a baby shower to get to," he choked out.

…

Bonnie fixed up the photo area as Caroline laughed heartily with Eliza on the couch. She simply couldn't get enough of her mesmerizing eyes.

"Where is everyone?" Bonnie commented as she moved to sit next to the two girls.

"Good question," Caroline said as she reached for her phone. She dialed Stefan's number and placed the phone to her ear. The phone rang once before Stefan picked up.

"Caroline," he greeted with panic to his tone. Caroline scrunched her eyes.

"Babe, why are you guys taking so long?" she whined.

"Caroline, something is terribly wrong," he answered. Caroline's stomach dropped at his words. She handed off Eliza to an oblivious Bonnie as she hurried into the kitchen for privacy.

"What is going on? Don't tell me you idiots dropped the cake," she snapped.

"Eliza isn't Enzo's," he blurted. Her eyes widened as she almost lost grip on the phone in her hand. She quickly shot a glance at Bonnie, who was utterly lost in thought.

"Come again?" she squeaked.

"It's Damon's," he affirmed. Caroline couldn't take it anymore as she clamped her hand to her mouth.

"Get the fuck outta here," she whispered in horror.

"Me and Damon are on our way there," he told her. "Enzo stormed away when he found out, and we can't find him anywhere."

Seconds later, the door burst open. Enzo came barging in with a fiery glare as Angelina followed close behind him. Caroline gulped as she clutched the phone tighter to her ear.
"I think I just found him," she whispered as her voice shook with fear. She hung up the phone shortly afterward and neared the living room area to hear what was taking place.

"Since when were you going to tell me about you and Damon?" he immediately yelled as he watched the flicker of horror cross Bonnie's features.

"What?" she breathed.

"Dear, God," Angelina scoffed behind him.

"Angelina discovered how Eliza was conceived. The father of that baby is a vampire who took the cure. The only vampire around here that took that cure was Damon. Which means, that you two were sneaking around behind my back!" he hollered. The intense bass in his voice startled Eliza, and she began to cry helplessly.

Bonnie couldn't move. She couldn't breathe, she couldn't speak—all she could do was stare at Enzo with a look of guilt and horror.

"I'll take her," Caroline interrupted as she made her way across the living room, grabbing Eliza from Bonnie's arms.

"Enzo, I can explain," she finally let out. Her voice trembled as she stared into his scorned eyes. She had never seen him so infuriated.

"Save it, bitch. I can't believe I wasted all of my time bringing your ass back here just for this to happen. You were better off gone," Angelina spat. Bonnie focused her attention on the fellow witch as her eyes narrowed.

"Look, I don't know who you think you are, but—

"Just tell me one thing," Enzo interjected, stepping in between the two ladies. Bonnie's face softened again when she laid eyes on Enzo. "Do you love him?"

"I love you," she answered sadly. He shook his head as the hard glare remained on his pained face.

"Answer the fucking question," he demanded. Bonnie's eyes pooled with tears as her breaths began to come out hollow and uneven. She couldn't lie to Enzo anymore. While she believed in her heart that Eliza was his, she couldn't help that voice in her head that consistently told her otherwise. She also couldn't ignore that voice that reminded her of just how much she actually did love Damon.

"I do," she choked out. She didn't think it was possible for Enzo's face to reflect so much pain as it previously had, but she was wrong. The look on his face was a completely new barrier of hurt. She hated herself.

Just when Enzo was about to respond, Damon and Stefan had stepped into the apartment of which the door was already wide opened. They had heard everything.

"You love me?" Damon whispered, watching as the pained look on Bonnie's face changed to petrified. As she stared between the two heartbroken men, she swore on her life that she had never felt as much pain as she did at that very second.

Author's Note: This chapter was super short, because I was curious as to who is still sticking with this story. If you're still out there, could you please leave me a review? I would appreciate it more than you guys know!