Disclaimer: I still don't own Supernatural or its characters. I and am not making any money on this…I'm just having fun!

WARNING: This section contains a scene of non-consensual sex. It's not too graphic, but if that kind of thing bothers you…you should skip this chapter.

Secrets

Chapter 21 – Battle of Minds

Dean struggled to his feet, reaching for his gun, but once again he felt himself thrown against the wall. He could see Melissa struggling against her sister's mind control, but she could not do anything but obey.

Trisha moved into the room, her eyes blazing as she advanced on Dean. "So you thought you could kill me…well, I'm going to make you watch while I finish with your brother. Make sure you take notes, because I'm going to do the same to you when I'm finished with him."

Dean struggled, but he couldn't move from where Melissa had him pinned. He looked at the terrified young woman and begged. "Melissa, fight this!"

"You're wasting your breath Dean. She will always do my bidding. She has no choice; it's her punishment for failing me when I was young. She made me what I am today." Trisha moved to sit beside Sam. She pulled the blanket and sheet off Sam and smiled at the bandages that Dean had applied to the deeper wounds.

Dean looked at the crazed woman sitting next to his brother. "You had choices; don't blame your bad choices on your sister." Dean struggled as he watched Trisha run her hands down Sam's chest.

"My my…first we need to make sure that you can't get away again Sammy." Trisha moved to get rope and quickly tied Sam's arms and legs to the bed again. Grinning as she heard Sam moan in his sleep.

"You leave my brother alone you bitch…I'm going to kill you!" Dean yelled as he struggled. His eyes filling with tears as he saw Sam's eyes open and fill with terror.

"Well good morning sunshine…I hope you've had a nice nap. But you've been a really bad boy and need to be punished. The yellow eye man told me you rejected him yet again. No matter, we have plenty of time to help you change your mind."

"I'll never change my mind…you'll have to kill me." Sam whispered, swallowing as he felt her hands running over his body. Once again, he could only move so much from her wandering hands.

"It would be a shame to kill you…such a beautiful body. You're good enough to eat!" Trisha laughed as she felt Sam responding to her playful touches. She moved her head closer and nibbled on his neck, moving her hands over his chest and down to the waist of his boxers.

Sam bucked as he felt her violating him, tears flowing from his eyes as he looked towards his brother. "Get off of him you bitch…I swear to God, I will kill you!" Dean watched in horror as the woman moved to work on Sam's badly torn chest.

"You know Sammy…I have been looking to find someone like you; someone that could take the pain and still resist…just like I had to. You are one of the strongest men I've ever met Sammy, my equal in almost every way…but there is one area that you can't resist me…an area where I have all the power. Shall I show you Sammy?"

"Go to hell!" Sam said through gritted teeth as he felt her hot breath on his neck. Trisha laughed as she nibbled on his ear, biting it with her teeth and smiling at she heard him gasp.

"Mmmm…I can feel you responding Sam…you can't resist me. Let's get rid of these bandages shall we?" Trisha moved her mouth over the first bandage, grabbing the edge between her teeth and ripping it off as she ran her nails down Sam's sides. "Pleasure and pain Sam, two sides to the same coin…which side do you prefer hmmm?"

"Argh….stop it please!" Sam cried as the pain from her pulling off the bandages became almost unbearable. But Trisha continued until all the bandages were removed on his chest and Sam's wounds were bleeding again.

Dean felt his eyes well with tears as he watched his brother's torture and humiliation. He looked to Melissa and once more tried to reach her. "Melissa, please…you have to fight her!"

Trisha raised her head from Sam and smiled, as she replied. "You waste your breath Dean…but don't worry; when I finish with Sam…you'll be next. I'm sure we can have some fun!"

"In your dreams sweetheart…too bad you can't get it the old fashioned way." Dean taunted trying to distract her from his brother.

Trisha just smiled. "Don't worry Dean; I'll get to you soon. But first, I think I want to go for a little ride." Trisha smiled as she moved to straddle Sam's hips. Sam groaned from the pain that her added weight caused to his battered body. He turned his head as she leaned forward. But she grabbed him by the hair and forced him to face her. Sam pulled in a sharp breath…he could swear he saw her eyes tinged with yellow as she placed her lips against his.

Melissa watched in horror as her sister began to ravage Sam. The tears were falling from her eyes but she was helpless. She thought about Andy's plan and hoped that once he woke, they'd be able to do it…but she decided that she would amend it slightly. She just hoped that Andy would understand. She saw Andy moving slightly out of the corner of her eye. It would have to be perfect timing or else Trisha would be able to avoid it.

Andy woke to the sound of Sam's moans and Dean's anguished screams. He blinked, but was careful not to move too much. He knew that he would only have one chance to put his plan in motion. He saw Melissa looking at him, hope in her eyes as she realized that he was awake. He winked as he gathered himself, ready to run for the rope as soon as Melissa had immobilized Trisha.

Sam felt sick, his body betraying him even as the pain in his body escalated to new heights. He wasn't sure how much more he could take…he saw the horror in his brother's eyes and realized that if he gave in, Dean would blame himself for whatever happened. He had to be strong and endure it…for Dean's sake.

Trisha sat up and threw here head back, loving the power she had over them all. She could feel the yellow eyes man smiling, preparing for another attack. But then she heard a sound and began to turn….

"NOW MELISSA!" Andy yelled "You are not to listen to your sister, you are free of her control" Andy jumped up and moved to get the rope. But before he could get across the room he saw a large knife sail through the air and hit Trisha in the heart. Trisha gasped and reached for the knife, as the life left her eyes, she looked at her sister. "Melissa"

Dean had fallen to the ground as soon as Andy yelled, he rolled to his feet and was heading for his gun when he saw the knife fly past him and hit Trisha. He turned and saw the horror in Melissa's eyes as she hit her mark. He moved to catch the young woman as she fell forward. "Melissa!" Dean cried as he lowered her to the ground.

"I killed her…I killed my sister!" Melissa sobbed

Dean turned and saw the knife pulled from Trisha and head in his direction. "Stop Melissa!"

Melissa shoved Dean off and stood as the knife headed for her heart. But at the last moment, Andy shoved her. The knife embedded itself in Melissa's shoulder. "Melissa, Stop!" Andy commanded. He hated to do it to her, but he couldn't let her kill herself.

Dean stared at Melissa and Andy…both siblings who had to kill their brother or sister. He could see the anguish in Melissa's eyes mirrored in Andy's as they both looked at each other.

"You will get through this Melissa…I'll help you." Andy said quietly. "I know how it feels, believe me. But you did what you had to do to save an innocent life." Andy held Melissa as she sobbed into his shoulder. He looked up at Dean and spoke quietly. "Dean, can you help her…can you get the knife out of her shoulder?"

Dean continued to stare for a moment, fear showing in his eyes for a moment before the wall was back in place. "Use one of the blankets Andy and lay her on it. I'll get the first aid kit."

Dean first moved over to Sam and quickly untied the ropes that were holding his brother to the bed. He noticed that Sam was refusing to meet his eyes. "Sammy, are you ok?"

Sam's breathing hitched in his throat as he struggled to roll onto his side. "Dean…please…help me…I think I'm going to…Oh God" Sam couldn't stop as the convulsions hit. Dean seeing the problem helped Sam roll to the edge of the bed, holding his shoulders as the spasms continue long after Sam's stomach was empty. "Easy there Sam…you know this wasn't your fault right? You have nothing to be ashamed of…you beat her Sam and you beat that bastard!"

Sam sighed, tears flowing from his eyes as he tried to get the pain back under control. "I know Dean, it's just…God, another one is dead." Sam looked up at Dean and Dean sighed as he saw the anguish in his brother's eyes. "Sam, there is nothing you could have done…I know you tried, but we can't save everyone."

Sam sighed and lay back on the bed, his eyes closing as he gave into the darkness. Dean sighed as he rose and headed over to help Melissa. "Well, things are looking up." Dean smiled as he saw Andy's questioning gaze. "We don't have to carry them out of here…we have Trisha's BMW."

TBC

Raven524: Ok, I hope this wasn't too graphic…but felt it was needed. Now Dean can get Sam some help, but will it be that easy? Hmmmmm…guess we'll have to wait and see. Thanks again for all the reviews! You are all wonderful!