MLP: Friendship is Magic – One Night

Genre: Romance
Ship: Fluttershy/Rainbow Dash
Author: Sinystra
Language: English
Disclaimer: Original Characters © Hasbro and Lauren Faust, Story © Sinystra

Short Explanation: In my stories the characters from MLP are not ponies. I write about them as kind of 'magic humans', they have human bodies, no cutiemarks, but pegasi have wings and unicorns have their horns. All of them have a normal human skintone (not like it's in the Equestria Girls movies). If you don't like that imagination, ignore it, create your own or don't read, okay? Thank you.
Too, it's a fanfiction – that means that in that case the characters might be a bit different to the characters in the show. Of course I want to write them as believable as possible but it may happen!

Also: I want to say that english is NOT my native language. If there are grammatical mistakes I am really sorry, I will work on it. Please feel free to tell me about them. I hope the story is still readable – it's an exercise for me to write in english.

The second chapter is not like the first one translated from german, so it may be a bit better written..? I would love to get some (constructive) feedback!

Here we go~

Chapter Two – Uncharted

Eventually Rainbow drew back. Silence. "Not good?" she asked then. Something different was in her voice now, Fluttershy didn't recognize what… she never heard that kind of tone from Rainbow before.

"I- I… uhm…" What should she say? She didn't even know what to do before… how should she know now?

"Because we're both girls? Is that the problem?" Rainbows voice sounded more thoughtful, but still with that strange undertone. She raised one hand and touched Fluttershy cheek gently.

"Nevermind. I just wanted to try that kind of thing. Just forget about it." she then said quickly and stood up from the bed. She stretched. "I mean… sometimes one tries stuff like that… and it's not as if one of us has a boyfriend or something like that…"

"…Dash…" Fluttershy said quietly. "What?" "A- actually…" "Yes, what?" "… I liked… it…"

Rainbow looked at her. "You did?" "Uhm… yes, I guess…" Again it was silent. Before Rainbow could start to speak again, Fluttershy stood up from the bed, too. "It's just, that…" She took a deep breath and looked at the floor. A hand touched her chin and lifted it, forced it in a gentle way to look up and into Rainbow's eyes. "What is it? Tell me."

"…I… I don't want you to think of me as… a sissy… as someone you can't take serious… I know I am afraid of a lot of things, but what scares me the most is that you could… that you would…" Fluttershy spoke fast so she would not lose the courage, but Rainbow interrupted her again. "Stop it, Shy." she stopped. Rainbow stepped to her and hugged her. It had been ages since she did that for the last time – grouphugs with their friends excluded – and back then they were younger.

"You knew me and how I talk! As if I would mean that serious – you should know that I don't think of you like that." She looked into Fluttershy's eyes again. "I know that you are very brave inside. Not everyone wears that part of his attitude outside, and…" She ended the hug, but left one arm wrapped around Fluttershy's shoulders while she stroke trough her hair with the now free hand and smirked, "…not everyone can always be as awesome as me on the outside!"

Fluttershy had to smile a little. "…well… it was just that…" she started, but realized a moment later that it was really hard to finish a sentence while talking to Rainbow Dash in general. "Buuut, what you said sooner, wait, wait… you said that you like me! And that you liked the kiss!" The rainbow haired girl lifted one of her eyebrows and looked straight into Fluttershy's eyes.

Now Fluttershy was sure that there was a glowing in that deep pink. "Uhm… yes, I guess…" she tried to answer, but Rainbow, fast as always, pushed her a little, so that she fell back onto the bed again.

"Then – let's do it again!" Before Fluttershy could say or do something, Rainbow kissed her again. This time the kiss lasted longer and felt even warmer than the first one.

Fluttershy could taste a rest of the cherry juice Rainbow drank earlier, but besides that there was another taste, completely new to her, but good. Rainbow was laying half on top of her so Fluttershy couldn't move a lot, but it felt strangely fine for her.

"You liked that one, too?" Rainbow asked after she stopped kissing the other girl and smiled at her. "…I guess…" "So, that means I am a good kisser, right?" Rainbow sat next to Fluttershy who was still laying were she pushed her and chuckled. "I guess?" Fluttershy answered again and sat up slowly, too. She felt strange because of what was happening, but not in a negative way.

"That was your first kiss, wasn't it, Shy?" Rainbow asked and looked at her. "…uhm, yes. It was." the rosy-haired girl said and started plucking on the corner of the blanket.

"Mh… I'm sorry about that." Rainbow said and she actually looked like she was, the smile was gone. "But it was my first one, too. If that helps." she added.

"Really?" Fluttershy looked at her surprised. "But I thought when you were dating Soarin last year, you…" Rainbow made a gesture as if she was throwing something away. "Naw. We were out a few times and it was all fun and stuff, but he's totally in love with Spitfire – just didn't notice it yet. Soarin and me were never a couple." She sighed. "Sure, I maybe had a little crush on him, but I guess that was just because of that whole Wonderbolt-thing, you know."

Fluttershy made big eyes. "I can't believe it – you never kissed someone?" "As I said! Would I lie to you?" Rainbow laughed. "Well, actually…" Fluttershy began, "Nah! About such a thing! I would not lie to you about such a thing, it actually isn't kind of a big deal, is it? After all?" Fluttershy frowned a bit. "Uhm, I don't know. It isn't?"

Rainbow sighed and let herself fall backwards into the soft pillows.

"I guess not, at our age? I mean, it's normal to have dates and relationships… Twilight's with Flash, even if she's not admitting it, Cadence and Shining are married, AJ is dating that guy, what was his name again..? Ah, not important."

"Well… but…" Fluttershy didn't really know how to phrase her thoughts. Everything was spinning inside her head again, but in another way than because of the wine before.

She just got her first kiss, but not from a prince in a polished armor like she somehow imagined when she thought about it as a child, but from… She looked at Rainbow Dash and was about to think the words 'a princess'. Then she imagined how Rainbow would laugh at her if she knew her thoughts at that moment.

"What is it? What are you thinking?" Rainbow asked quietly, she sounded as if she was thinking about something, too. "Uhm, I…" Again she couldn't finish her sentence. "Hey, we could start dating, you know?" Fluttershy forgot immediately what she was about to say. "…d-dating?" The rainbow-haired girl turned her head and looked at her. "Yes… well… you know, I liked the kisses, and you did, too, maybe we should figure out what that thing with us could become…" she said slowly, as if she thought about every single word before pronouncing it.

Fluttershy felt joy about that thought at first, but at once fear overcame her. "Rainbow Dash… we… we are both girls…" Her voice sounded shivery as she imagined how everyone would react to her and Rainbow dating… "Yes, I know…" Rainbow Dash looked at the ceiling. She sighed. "Well, I think in my case nobody would be surprised, half of the people already think I'm a lesbian." Something bitter resonated in her voice.

Fluttershy grabbed her hand. "You say that like it's a bad thing! I mean… I… uhm… of course it's not, it's just that…" Rainbow let her take her hand and looked at it. "But you don't want to be called one, right?" Fluttershy remained silent. "Me neither, but not because I would be ashamed. If I was a lesbian, it would be okay, you know. But I really had crushes on guys and imagined relationships and… more." She shrugged her shoulders.

"It's just that I had all of that with girls, too. I guess I just don't want to determine myself. I don't care what gender someone has, after all I fall in love with the person and not the gender. And I hate it to get judged by people if they don't even know anything about me or my life. I hate those people who always have to put everything inside their boxes…" Suddenly she sat up.

"Oh, Rainbow Dash likes sport, she is self-confident and sometimes rude and says what she's thinking, not interested in jewellery or frilly clothes and is not drooling after every hot guy – she must be a lesbian, or maybe even better: she wants to be a boy herself! And of course such a lesbian couldn't let her fingers off her best friend!" she shouted out in a slightly pitched voice as if she wanted to imitate someone.

"As if there wasn't more than one way to be a girl!"

Fluttershy winced. Obviously Rainbow has had a few drinks at the celebration, too.

"…Dash…" Rainbow looked at her. "Sorry. That's not your fault. But I get it if you don't want the people to gossip…" she shook her head.

"No, wait." Fluttershy grabbed Rainbows hand a little tighter. Rainbow stopped to talk. "…you are right… I am afraid of what everyone is gonna say…" Fluttershy took a deep breath. Finally one of her thoughts got clear and she felt a little ashamed of bringing up that topic at all.

"…I never thought of beeing with another girl, you know. I always liked you and liked it to be around you, but this… this is new for me… and I am afraid, yes…" Rainbow said nothing and let her speak, exceptional.

"But if you are with me, I can fight that fear. It always was like that. I… uhm… I liked the feeling of being so close to you… and I don't want to let my fear hold me back…" Fluttershy leaned forward and this time it was her beginning the kiss. Rainbow seemed a bit surprised but responded it immediately. She wrapped her arms around Fluttershy and pulled the other girl closer to herself.

"Let's make an agreement, Shy." she wispered when they ended the kissing. Their faces were just a breath away from each other. "Which kind of aggreement?" Fluttershy asked, she felt that her face must have been completely red and her heart beat faster as if when she had to give that speech in front of the whole village a few weeks ago again.

"We continue this…" Rainbow kissed her again, but this time only for half a second. "But we won't show or tell anyone until you're ready… until we're ready, okay?" Fluttershy nod. "Okay." Rainbow smiled and again there was that glowing in her magenta-colored eyes Fluttershy could even see in the dark.

"Well, then…" She let herself fall backwards once more and pulled Fluttershy with her. "…let's continue…"

They were laying besides each other, facing, and although it was mostly dark they stopped and looked into the eyes of the other one for an instant.

Rainbow's lips were soft and she seemed to be careful in an unfamiliar way as she now not only started to kiss Fluttershy on hers, but also kissed her cheeks and her neck. Her hands went down to Fluttershy's hips and stroke her skin gently while pushing her shirt slowly upwards.

"Is that okay?" Rainbow Dash asked and Fluttershy sensed her warm breath touching her neck's skin as she spoke. She nod. "Y- yes. It feels… good…" "That's great, because I've no idea what I'm doing."

Fluttershy had to remember what the other girl said before – that it was her first kiss, too, and so this situation had to be the first kind of a situation like this for her as well.

Maybe the remaining applewine played its part, too, as Fluttershy raised her hand and stroke through Rainbows hair, removing the tie and setting the colorful streaks free.

When Rainbow's hands slid slowly above her skin at her waist she didn't panic as she expected from herself but started to feel an entire new kind of relief. It felt pleasant and calming, and somehow Fluttershy saw her fears getting smaller and smaller.

Rainbow moved once again and climbed above her, placing her hands left and right besides Fluttershy's upper part of the body now. She kissed her on the lips again, and this time she opened her mouth a bit and let her tongue touch Fluttershy's lips cautiously but also a little claiming.

The rosy haired girl hoped that she did what Rainbow wanted as she opened her lips a bit, but it seemed so. Rainbow let her tongue slowly slip to Fluttershy's and started to rub it slightly and still a bit insecure, as if she were ready to back off at any moment.

It felt new and somehow strange, but good. Fluttershy could taste more of the flavor she noticed before, a little bit of cherries, too, but mostly it was just Rainbow Dash. She could not remember if she ever tasted something comparable.

She started to reply the things Rainbow was doing with her tongue, or tried it, and immediately Rainbow's movements got faster and more confident.

Fluttershy wrapped her arms around Rainbow and tried to pull her closer slightly. Following that pull, Rainbow let herself sink down so she was laying completely on top of Fluttershy's body now, her ellbows placed left and right of it and her hands next to her face.

The kiss got deeper and more intense. Rainbow started to let her fingers stroke through the silky hair of the other girl, consistently touching her cheeks gently.

Fluttershy let her fingers slid over Rainbow's back, the top the girl wore did not really cover much of her skin anymore. Rainbow's skin felt even and flawless, but soft too. Fluttershy knew that her friend was not heavily tanned, but because she always flew above every cloud her skin was something a magazine Fluttershy once read described as 'sunkissed'.

Although Fluttershy spent most of her time outside with the animals she took care of she still had a relatively bright skintone; maybe because she was in the forest mostly, were the trees were like a shelter from the sunrays.

As Fluttershy touched Rainbow's skin she immediately had to think about that magazine-description and she liked the thought of Rainbow's warmth as the warmth oft he sun.

Rainbow's hands moved again to Fluttershy's waist and touched her under the shirt she wore. She did not stop kissing while she pushed the shirt more upwards until she reached Fluttershy's bra.

She ended the kiss und looked into the turquoise eyes oft he other girl once more. "…Dash…" Fluttershy said hushed.

"Hm?" "I thought about it… I, uhm, please, don't get me wrong, I like that… but I know that we both drank some of that wine and I would like to experience those feelings… without it…" She stroke through Rainbow's hair and touched her cheek carefully.

"…is… is that okay with you..?"

Rainbow shrugged. "Well, althought I am not the patient type usually I think that you're right actually." She laid down next to Fluttershy and pulled the blanket above the two of them.

While she kissed her one last time she wrapped her arms around the rosy-haired girl and then snuggled up to her. Fluttershy smiled and took one of Rainbow's hands in hers.

"Good night, Dash." She said and closed her eyes. "Nice dreams." Rainbow's voice said, followed by a yawn. It did not last long until both girls fell asleep.

To be continued..?

Thank you for reading!

I would appreciate every (constructive and polite) feedback!

(...)