Series: Leaving Town Alive 3/?
Title: Breaks
Fandom: One Tree Hill/Supernatural
Character(s)/Pairing(s): Haley James (Scott)/Sam Winchester, Brooke Davis/Dean Winchester
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: None
Notes: Follows on from Leaving Town Alive and Untitled and is a sequel to a yet to be written multi chaptered fic...Why am I writing the sequel first....well it's a lot easier writing fics that follow along the recent Supernatural storyline then it is to start the origins fic...Just so you know Haley and Brooke are sisters and Bobby's nieces and have been working with the Winchesters since season 1/2, but there's more history then that....
She understands now, why her uncle and her sister had wanted to protect her from this, why Dean had insisted she not go anywhere near Sam, why they had all tried to keep her away.
She races into the hotel room with Brooke hot on her heels just in time to see Sam stop Dean from doing the one thing that could save his soul.
He chooses Ruby, a demon over his own flesh and blood, and the look on Dean's face mirrors the one on her own, defeat, cold and hard defeat.
They've lost him, lost him to the darkness inside of himself he will never be able to control, lost him to the demon beside him, who none of them bar Sam had ever trusted.
Yet he insists he's doing what he's doing for the greater good, that what he's doing is noble and just, that he's doing it for them, because he loves them and for the world because he's the only one who can and Haley can't decide what she hates more, the fact that every word that comes spewing out of his mouth is a lie or the more disturbing thought that Sam believes every word he tells them fanatically.
Sam orders Ruby to run and she obeys like always, but not before throwing one last victorious smirk over Sam's shoulder and if Brooke wasn't grasping onto her arm in an effort to console/control her, Haley would have jumped the demon girl and clawed at her until nothing was left but blood and bones.
As soon as the brunette demon leaves the accusations fly, both Haley and Brooke step back as the brothers hurl words at each other like daggers, their eyes filling with tears along with the men they love.
Before anyone knows what's hit them, Dean whispers the three words guaranteed to cause Sam the maximum amount of pain and break a little piece of himself in the process.
"You're a monster"
Sam throws the first punch, Dean throws the next and both James girls know there's no point in getting in the middle of it, this fight, the Winchester mini-battle has been a long time in the making and not even the hand of God would have a chance in stopping it now.
It's over as quickly as it started, Sam gets the upper hand and starts to squeeze the life out of his older brother, the girls are going to intervene but the taller brother seems to get a hold of himself and pulls back looking down at Dean who looks at him like that very action has just confirmed everything he said.
A moment passes and Sam turns to leave, his brother's voice stopping him just as he reaches the door.
"If you walk out that door, don't even think about coming back"
The words said with conviction stop the younger Winchester for a minute and his eyes glaze a little looking down at his brother with both determination and trepidation.
His mind is made up, she can tell by his stance, the self assured way he holds himself, there's no going back after this.
He looks to her but she turns away, his betrayal still fresh in her mind, the truth of Dean's words ringing in her head and shaking her to her very core.
Sam says Dean has never known him and the same can be said for her, because he isn't the man she's loved all these years, who she's shared herself with and given everything to, he's someone else, something else, a monster just like his brother said.
She makes her choice, cuts the last piece of string holding the two of them together and with a fleeting look into the man she loves eyes, she kneels next to his brother, her allegiance sworn, her side in the upcoming battle determined before she makes the decision for herself, her uncle, her sister, and her best friend, the three people besides Sam who she would die for have chosen their sides and her lot is with them.
Sam leaves without a backward glance and she cries bitter tears as she helps Brooke with the other broken Winchester on the ground in front of them.
The next time the four of them are in a room together it won't be because they're trying to save Sam, it'll be because they're hunting him and Haley might not get the chance to die for him, but she may just die because of him.
Uploading a few today :)