Hi guys! :) Sorry its been awhile. I had insane writers block. I also have two new ideas for Fanfics. So. yay! I would like to point out that I am not exactly computer Savvy, so I have no idea how to reply to reviews. Someone asked me if they could translate my story to German and to that I say YES! :) Go for it! Just give me credit and ill allow it! :) Thanks for all the reviews and alerts and favorites. Every time I get one I do a little dance! Enjoy this chapter! 3

Disclaimer: I do not own Glee!

It had been two weeks since Rachel and Puck started "dating" and the plan was actually working much to Rachel, Puck, and Kurt's surprise. Puck and Rachel were getting a bit restless because neither Finn nor Quinn had acted on the relationship. The only real progress they had was when Quinn had told Rachel she wouldn't understand why she was acting so weird.

Kurt knew that Finn was not liking watching Rachel and Puck be all couply because no matter how hard he tried to hide it, he could tell he had feelings for her. Kurt could also tell that Quinn was extra bitchy lately but then sometime he would catch her playing with her necklace and staring off into space. He was pretty sure that Rachel being with Puck had hit home for Quinn. He also noticed that Rachel and Puck were friends and he was so happy that Rachel finally had some friends. Sometimes he wasn't so sure that it was pretend.

"Rachel, can I ask you a question?" Kurt asked one day when they were on the phone.

"No, you can't borrow my Kate Spade scarf. My dads payed so much for it." she said and rolled her eyes. "Besides, the mustard color would wash you out."

"No, I don't want your scarf and leave the fashion stuff up to me, Babs." he said.

"Oh, then what?" she asked.

"You and Puck?"

"What about us?"

Kurt sighed, "Do you like him? As more than a friend?" he asked casually hoping she wouldn't get mad but instead she giggled.

"Oh, Kurt, you know last week I thought maybe I was smitten with him but then I saw his permanent record and decided it was too big. I need a man that is not going to be in jail for the rest of his life." she said matter-of-factly.

"Oh, alright then. I have to go! Beauty sleep calls." and he hung up and she saw Kurt blink his bedroom light twice, which signaled as "I love you" and then he was gone.

Rachel sighed and blinked hers once in reply and put her pajamas on. She thought about going to the backyard tonight but decided against it. She went to see if Finn was out there and it turns out there were two heads instead of one tonight. She opened the window very quietly and listened to the voices.

"Are you in love with her?" she heard Finn say and she waited for the response of the other guy.

"It's only been two weeks." It was Puck. Finn was asking Puck if he was in love with her! Puck better not screw this up. She waited with baited breath.

"I guess." Finn said.

"Are you in love with Quinn?" Puck retorted.

There was a pause for about a minute and then Finn finally said, "I think so."

"Well, if you think you are, then you probably aren't. When you're with Quinn do you feel alive? When you look at her, does nothing else matter? Does the whole world stop when she walks into the room? Do you get lost in her beautiful eyes? Do you picture her in your arms forever?"

Puck was rambling and Rachel wanted to slap him so hard because she knew for a fact that he was talking about being with Quinn and while it was really sweet, she hoped Finn wouldn't notice.

"Wow, Dude. Is that how you feel about Rachel?" Finn asked.

Puck contemplated the answer and quickly realized that he was talking about Quinn with Quinn's boyfriend.

"Uh, yeah, that's how I feel." Finn's face fell in the darkness. He didn't feel all those things with Quinn.

"I'm happy for you, man. I'm happy you found a girl who had changed your world. She's a keeper." Finn said with a smile

Rachel sadly smiled for Finn and for Puck. She knew Finn never answered the questions so she didn't know he felt but she knew Puck really loved Quinn and she was going to get her back. The plan would work. She shut the window and let her mind drift away with thoughts of her dads.

Finn went back to his room confused as ever. He didn't realize Rachel had such a powerful effect on Puck and he was confused about Quinn too. He didn't know what to do. No matter how much he tried to deny it, he had feelings for one Rachel Berry. But he also had feelings for Quinn too. Or did he?

He wished he could tell someone about all these feelings. He couldn't tell his best friend that he had feelings for his girlfriend and he couldn't tell his girlfriend about his feelings for someone who isn't her and he couldn't tell Rachel because well, they were just friends. He decided to go to the next best person.

"Kurt." he knocked on his step-brothers door and there was no answer. So he opened the door and walked over to the bed and sat down. He pushed Kurt violently. "KURT, wake up!"

"NOT MY WICKED SOUNDTRACK." he screamed. Finn started laughing at his brother.

"Finn! Thats not funny! Its 2 am in the morning! What are you doing in my room?" Kurt asked annoyed.

"I need your help." he said

"i told you that I would help with your English paper later." he snapped.

"No. Its about Rachel." Finn said and Kurt shot out of bed.

"What about her?" Kurt said.

"Well, Puck and I were talking about love and he said some pretty crazy stuff about like the world becoming better when Rachel comes into the room and her eyes are beautiful.I think he loves her." Finn said.

Kurt couldn't believe his ears. Puck loved Quinn. Maybe he meant Quinn.

"Anyway, he asked me if Quinn made me feel all those things and I realized that she doesn't. I don't love her like I thought I do. I think I love Rachel but…"

"She's with Puck." Kurt finished.

"What should I do?" Kurt's mind reeled at his brothers question. For the first time, he didn't know how to continue with the plan. He knew that Rachel and Finn liked each other but he didn't know for sure about Puck and Quinn. He didn't want to do anything drastic until he knew for sure.

"Rachel's with Puck and apparently he loves her, so leave them be. For now, i know it may be hard but you would have to break up with Quinn and is that what you want?"

"Well, i like Quinn."

"Finn, you need to figure out what YOU want first. Now get out of my room, ill see you tomorrow."

Finn walked out and dug his face in his pillows and fell asleep.

The next morning, Rachel rolled out of bed, literally. Her phone was vibrating on the floor and she rolled over in time to pick it up.

"Helllllo." she groaned into the phone.

"Hey, Babe." Puck said with a smirk.

"Noah, you don't have to call me babe when no one is around. Rachel is just fine." she said rolling her eyes.

"I know, Berry. Listen, I have to talk to you." he said in a more serious tone.

Rachel suddenly remembered that she heard him and Finn talking last night.

"About what?" she said still playing dumb.

"It's about Finn. Call Kurt and meet me at the Lima Bean in 20 minutes." he said and hung up. She sighed and looked at the time. 7:30 AM on a Saturday. Kurt is gonna be so mad. Especially since he only gets 20 minutes to get ready She gets up and throws a button at Kurt's window. She waits a few second and when there was no answer she climbed out of her window and stood in front of his window.

"KURT ELIZABETH HUMMEL! WAKE UP RIGHT NOW." she pounded and screamed.

Finally he trudged to the window with a huge scowl. His hair was plastered to his head and he had pillow marks on his face. Rachel giggled at the sight of her best friend.

"No. Stop it. Rachel. It's 7:30 AM. What do you need?" he said

"Look, I will tell you about it on the way there, we now have 15 minutes to meet Puck at the Lima Bean. Get ready!"

"No, I will not be a third wheel on this date." he said closing the window.

"Wait! Kurt, its about the plan. We need to go."

Kurt then suddenly remembered that he talked to Finn last night and told him he loved both Rachel and Quinn.

"Oh, my gosh! Rach! I need to tell you something!" he began excitedly.

"I need to tell you something too. But it can wait. Get ready! Meet at my car in 15!" and she climbed in her window and shut the drapes.

Kurt sighed and tried his best to look presentable. On his way to the bathroom he ran into a very tired looking Finn.

"Kurt, its Saturday. Why are you up?" Finn said and scratched his head

"Finn, I have a very normal routine. I usually go running with Rachel in the morning."

"How come i've never heard of this before?"

"Um, because you're never awake before 11." he said and rolled his eyes.

"You're right. Have fun with Rachel." he said and then Finn suddenly remembered waking Kurt up and telling him about Rachel.

"Kurt! Pleas-"

"I know, Finn. My lips are sealed." and he walked out of the house.

"Kurt, you're ten minutes late. Noah won't stop texting me and telling me we better hurry or he was going to start doing his homework." Rachel said as she got into her car.

"Maybe, we should make him wait, he could get a good grade out of it." Kurt said.

"Let's get you some coffee." Rachel said.

They pulled into the Parking lot and Kurt was so happy he could get out of the car and free of Rachel's early morning singing. They spotted Puck in the corner and surprisingly reading a book. He looked up and saw them laughing at him and he threw the book at the guy at the next table.

"Hey Guys. Rachel, I know what you like so I ordered you your Chai Latte and Kurt, I texted Blaine and he told me your usual foofy gay drink." he said in monotone.

"Thanks, Noah, you're so thoughtful." she smiled, sometimes Puck did have a sweet side.

Kurt scoffed and took a drink, grateful of the caffeine that was making him see straight again.

"I love Quinn."

"I heard you last night."

"Finn loves Rachel."

They all said at once. Rachel first heard Puck and she smiled and then she heard Kurt and she just hung her mouth open.

"Wait, Rachel, you go first, then Puck then I'll go." Kurt said.

"Well, last night I couldn't sleep and usually I go outside and talk to Finn but I decided that probably wasn't best and so I went to the window to see if he was out there. I heard you and Finn talking, Noah. I am glad that you didn't say Quinn's name and Finn thought you were talking about me. That would've ruined the plan, although it could've helped a lot. Whatever. I applaud you, Noah." Rachel said.

Puck smiled sadly at the thought.

"I'm in love with Quinn, Rachel. "

"I know, Noah. That's why we are doing this." Rachel touched his shoulder in comfort.

"Okay, my turn. So, last night I was sleeping and then Finn comes in and wakes me up. At first, I was really mad. But then he said something about being in love with Rachel. So, i told him had to break up with Quinn and that you and Puck wouldn't just break up. He said that he still liked Quinn and I said that he needed to decide what he wanted." Kurt said.

Rachel thought about this. She was angry at Finn. How could he claim to be in love with her and also love Quinn? He doesn't know what he wants, yeah right! He just wants to have Quinn and I under his terms. She couldn't stand that.

"Rachel. Are you okay?" Puck asked.

"No, I'm not okay. Finn is so dumb! He can't do this to me! He keeps me hanging on and I can't take it anym-"

"Rachel, he's just confused." Kurt added

"No. I want out.

"Out of what, Rachel?" Puck asked nervously.

"Out of the plan." was all she said and took a drink of her latte.

ooo! A cliff hanger! :) I am newly a fan of Puckleberry, but I promise this is just a friendship! Let me know what you want to see and what you think. What do you think will happen? ;)

Review and i will love you always.

Love. Love. Love.

Nicolette