Lonely is the Night

I chose the title of chapter 9 from the song Dean was listening to on last week episode 9:14- Captives. Dean looked so sad, so alone. I had to name my chapter after the song he was using to DJ his pity-party. Yea season 9 is tearing up my heart even my boys the Ghostfacers in 9:15 –Thinman, couldn't help put my heart back together again. I hope doing this chapter will help a bit.

Disclaimer: As always I do not own Glee or Supernatural or their characters. I just own the fact that I am a huge Jensen Ackles fan!

"Here sit here." Sam Evans gently guided Mercedes on the couch. She could feel Agent Ryan's green eyes squinting with anger. Mercedes was confused by Sam E.'s recent behavior, he was caring and gentles which he always was with her but he seemed to forget they were no longer a couple and he completely forgot that he had a fiancée. Puck and Jake were acting stranger than the absent-minded Sam E. They were exhibiting the classic symptoms of zombies. They had come to see her in the hospital but they were just there physically. Every question was answered with a grunt. Jake had dark circles around his eyes and Puck was pale.

Tina her friend that was supposed to be the weird friend was as close to normal out of her friends now.

"I am going to fix you some chicken noodle soup in a minute." Tina offered taking Mercedes purple duffel bag to the guest room.

"Thanks," Mercedes mumbled in defeat, she was not sure if Chicken Noodle soup was a remedy for almost dying.

Mercedes had been outvoted by friends and family to stay at her apartment by herself. Her three options were to stay at her parents' house for the week, stay at her own apartment with either Tina or her mom staying with her or stay at Tina's apartment. Mercedes did not want to stay at her parents' house having her already ailing mom fretting over her and her brother fretting over both of them. She didn't want to stay at her one bedroom apartment with Tina or her mom. The lesser evil was staying at Tina's in her guest room. Her parents would be satisfied with the arrangement and they wouldn't stop by every five minutes.

Agent Murphy kept rubbing his forehead as if he was trying to unknot a headache. He would turn and give his partner an evil stare every five minutes. Mercedes wondered if it was her who was causing tension between the partners.

"Mercy is there anything else I can get for you? " Sam E asked?

"Agent Ryan, may I speak to you in private?" Sam asked?

"I will be right with you, Agent Murphy." Dean replied swallowing his anger. He could not talk to his little brother right now. He felt like he could take the kids head off for the stupid stunt he pulled. Sam could have been the one with the missing heart instead of Tiffany.

"Agents thank you so much for taking care of my girlfriend." Sam E. kissed Mercedes hand.

"Girlfriend?" Dean rolled his eyes; he was going to have a chat with Castiel about removing the chump's memory.

"Sam, what are you talking about? You have a fiancée. We haven't dated since high school." Mercedes said.

"High school, what are you talking about we are still in high school. I'm taking you to the prom next week remember. I thought for a minute we wouldn't be together you know because of Shane and all but it worked out okay. "Sam E. explained.

Sam gave Dean we need to talk now look! Dean nodded in agreement.

"Castiel, get your ass down here now!" Dean yelled! Sam and he were ducked off in one of Tina's neighbor's garage.

"Dean, he was only trying to help." Sam pointed out.

"He was a real help. Did you see the sheriff and deputy of Mayberry? They looked like extras on that Brad Pitt movie." Dean pointed out.

"World war Z?" Sam asked?

"Yea, that's the one and they are not the survivors. What did he do to them?" Dean shook his head. He needed Castiel to hurry up he wanted to go back upstairs so he could keep an eye on Mercedes and Sam.

"Dean, I have thought that we have looked at this thing all wrong. We need to find who unleashed Uthra but what if the clue is in the first couple or even in the second. Whoever summoned Uthra had to have a target and I'm sure before Uthra became a free agent it murdered its target." Sam processed.

Dean twisted his lips, "Okay, we have to talk to Joe Hart again."

"Sam, Dean, how may I help you." Cas appeared.

"What is wrong with Samuel Evans and the Puckerman brothers?" Dean skipped the greetings.

"Sorry about that. You know I lost my grace and had to steal another angel's grace. Every angel's grace is unique. I might have overestimated how much power to use to erase Sam Evan's memory." Castiel admitted.

"Great another good thing that would have been useful information after the fact, let me see if I got this straight; angel grace is like trying to wear another man's costumed made tailor suit?" Dean asked?
Cas made a confused look, "I guess."

"What about the Puckermans? They are out of it. Will that wear off because if not this town will need a new Sherriff quickly." Sam asked?

"Honestly, I do not know if they will be okay. I attempted delicate procedures that would have been difficult for me if I had my own grace. I tried to erase their memory while they were still in panic mode, I usually wait until the disbelief moment while in panic mode you have to right for the exact right moment or they get stuck in a certain mode. I have never been off before." Cas said.

"We have to figure out a way to restore them to an actual functionally mode. sheriff Puckerman's wife does not come off as the understanding type she will destroy him in his current state." Sam said.

"Cas, with Sam Evans memory lost will Uthra no longer hunts him? This guy hasn't betrayed love yet." Dean reasoned. He could feel a bit of pressure off his shoulders. He won't have to keep Sam Evans around. He would just have to watch over Mercedes and Sam.

"Don't know." Castiel shrugged.

"Mercedes would be out of danger if she believes she is still in love with Sam Evans if that is the case." Sam followed his brothers' logic.

"Cas, I really do you need to look after Mercedes. I cannot think of a reason to convince her without creeping her out to let us stay around 24-7, that and we need to follow-up on some leads to stop this damn thing." Dean said.

"I will come and get you if Uthra comes anywhere near here." Cas promised. Sam started to question Cas what happened at Sam Evans hotel when he was supposed to be helping him protect them. He knew if he questioned Cas than Dean would have Mercedes handcuffed to him until they caught Uthra.

"Castiel, I am not playing if a hair is out-of-place by Uthra, I will smite you." Dean threatened.

"Sam, your brother is bonded by Mercedes because of her angel blood. I am certain it will get worse, we have to stop them from getting any closer." Cas ignored Dean's threat. Dean was a very resourceful hunter but Cas knew he could kill Dean with a slap with his strength. Dean was his best friend he had no plans of disappointing Dean.

….

"Santana, for real she is okay. She's mad she cannot stay at her own place alone now or else she is okay. Now there is something wrong with Evan's. He keeps talking about taking Mercedes to the prom in a week. It's like he lost his memory." Tina said over the phone to her friend.

"He probably had a mental breakdown when Wheezy got attacked. You know he has always loved her." Santana paused, "Speaking of Sam's how your Agent doing? "

"You don't have to remind me that he is a rent – a- man. I know no reason not to enjoy him while he is here." Tina sat on her bed. Mercedes was sound of sleep in the guest room. It took a lot of convincing to get Sam E to the right hotel; he kept trying to go to Kurt/Finn's childhood home. "I am staying with Finn this year." He had argued. Agent Murphy told him that the Hudson's were out-of-town and they had put him up in a hotel room.

"Tina, you say you know he cannot be your man but I have a feeling that you are falling for him." Santana told her. Tina looked around her room not saying a word.

"I take your silence as a yes." Santana said, "Lady Chang, Mike and you were a great couple. I think you are holding on tight to this guy because he is the first guy since Mike passed that you have slept with. I think you are confusing your physical attraction to him for an emotional one too. Tina he will be leaving the second his case is over and I do not want you to go in hiding for another two years. I think you need to stop sleeping with your rebound guy."

"Agent Murphy is not my rebound guy." Tina said.

"That's the other thing. Even if he now wants more than friends with benefits you will not be able to give him that. He really is nothing but the rebound guy. For both of your sakes let him go." Santana said.

"He understands me. He lost someone he loves too." Tina went inside her closet. She reached in the back of the closet to get out of one Mike's old t-shirts a ragged green one that still had a faint scent of Mike. Her hand touched the dogged cover of a book in the small box of Mike's things. Tina tuned out Santana pulling out the book. Tina always was fascinated by the world of mythical creatures. Mike was more of a logical thinker. He did like one Scfi book series: Supernatural an underground graphic novel by Carver Edlund. Mike had the series, he had actually loved the books so much that he had once planned to go to a weekend convention about the books. Mike had the tickets but at the last-minute his grandma got sick he sold his tickets on eBay. Tina had given most of the books to Mike's little cousin who also liked the series. Tina only kept two of them to remind her of Mike. She looked at the cover; the main characters looked like an over-flatted steroid using romance book heroes. Tina smiled thinking of what Mike had said, "Do you girls really like these types of guys? You know the steroids make them sterile." Tina had hugged him tight feeling his own nicely built body. She didn't need anybody except his. "I can't speak for other girls but I prefer my heroes looking like Michael Chang Jr." She had kissed him.

"Tina, Tina is you still there?" Santana reminded her she was still on the phone.

"Santana, I promise I will not get too caught up in the agent but I have to go. I will call you later." Tina promised.

Tina climbed inside her bed carefully with the book in her hand. She sniffed the old T-shirt with a smile. Santana might have had a point, Sam might be a rebound and when something bothered Tina she only knew one person to turn to Mike. This one was her favorite out of the series Tall Tales about the brothers Dean and Sam investigating weird happenings at a local college. Tina laughed as she read the outrageous over the top version each brother gave family friend, Bobby, of what was going on.

Tina tried to picture the brothers as they were pictured on the cover. Her mind refused to picture them as that instead of a buzz cut brown-haired cartoon buffed Sam, Agent Murphy kept coming to mind. For the braid my hair blonde with the same cartoonish build Dean she saw him as Sam Evans. Tina laughed she couldn't believe she had forgotten the series, she laughed harder remembering how she had told Mercedes that Ryan & Murphy were not real agents. That would be funny if Agent Murphy & Ryan were really Hunters like in the book. It would really explain a lot.

….

Winchesters

"Okay back to the drawing board let's start with the first couple, Sharon Nance and Franklin Jameson. Why would anyone want to attack them? What would they get out of it? Frank gave Sharon up for 5 million dollars but he hasn't gotten it yet. "Sam wrote notes on the board.

"What about the child? How can we find out if he really belongs to Frank and not her husband? That is a reason to get rid of Frank or Sharon. Was Frank dating anyone else yet?" Dean said.

"What if the person didn't know Uthra killed in couples?" Sam made additionally notes.

"I think Frank and Sharon was the test run couple. I think Finn and Rachel were the real targets. I have a feeling about them. I heard those Broadway girls are ruthless. We need to find out who benefited from her death." Dean put up a smiley headshot of Rachel Berry.

"Dean, after this case is done I was thinking of us staying in Lima a little longer." Sam approached the subject carefully.

"I thought you couldn't wait to get out of here. It's the little Oracle huh?" Dean asked?

"Her name is Tina and you cannot tell me you don't want to stay for Mercedes." Sam said.

"I bet it is someone in the Glee club." Dean ignored Sam's question.

"Tomorrow we will find out who all in the Glee club still lives in Lima," Sam said, "We should start with the original ones that were there when Finn and Rachel went."

"Sam, if you want to stay an extra week in Lima, okay." Dean plopped on the bed; his investigation was over for the night. Sam bites down on his smile.

…

"Awesome." Dean declared angrily.

Tina looked at him closer. She had a nagging idea that wouldn't quit bothering her since the agents showed up. Awesome was the catch phrase of the character in the supernatural book. After finishing the book Tall Tales in the morning a lot of information came flooding back to her about the main characters mostly the Impala.

"Sam, may I talk to you for a minute in my room?" Tina whispered.

"Sure." Sam stood up shadowing her tiny frame. He followed her into her room.

Sam noticed the worn out book on her bed the moment he entered her room.

"Damn Chuck Shirley" Sam thought. Chuck was the drunken prophet assigned to write the "Winchester Gospel". Chuck had disappeared sometime back unlike his books that seemed to make appearance at the worst possible times. Those books were the reason Sarah and other people they had helped were dead.

"If I ask you a ridiculous question will you tell me the truth?" Tina asked?

"Tina, please don't ask me." Sam said without taking his eyes off the cover. He hated the book on the cover were the ridiculous version of them and what was supposed to be Gabe in a janitor outfit laughing. Where Sam and Dean's physic was embellished Gabe was underdeveloped he looked like a skinny weasel of a guy with a menacing smile the only thing that showed the real Gabe.

"You didn't even flinch when I told you I thought it was a werewolf. I thought you were being polite but that wasn't it was it? You know for a fact it's not a werewolf because you have dealt with werewolves before. "Tina stopped as more information washed over her. This couldn't be the guy in the books because that would make him Sam. The same Sam who lost his mom, his fiancée and the guy who had kill the girl he loved, Madison.

"My job makes me a believer." Sam could see Tina's mind going over information the books provided. Sam took comfort in the fact that she was unable to know what happened to him after Dean went to hell. At that moment Tina questioned her logic of accusing him of being a fictional character. Dean in the book was not alive.

"You know what I'm sorry there is no way you are who I thought you were." Tina kissed him.

…

"Are you comfortable?" Sam E. asked fluffing a couch pillow for Mercedes.

"I am doing okay. " Mercedes tried to enjoy Sam E's company. The truth was if she hadn't met Agent Dean Ryan Sam E's company would have been more welcoming. Sam Evans was amazing but as amazing as he was there was something phenomenal about Dean. She couldn't get him out of her head the way he pursed his lips together in duck lips when he was trying to make a point. The way his jeans bragged his bow-legged shape. Her favorite thing about him was how his jewel colored eyes were a mixture of pain and playfulness. Mercedes never believed in first sight yet this was the closet she ever got.

"Mercedes." The parade of ex-boyfriends continued with Brian the brain in the doorway.

"Bry, what are you doing here? "Mercedes asked?

"Small town I heard what happened. Your brother told me you were at Tina's. Don't be mad at Marshall he talked before he realized we were on a break" Brian said, "Tina just let me in. I was surprised I know she is not a fan."

"Tina is doing a lot of things I would have never thought she would do." Mercedes agreed. She examined Brian thinking about the discussion she had with Tina when she was thinking of breaking up with Brain. Tina had told her to think about it, that she was chasing a clone of her favorite uncle.

"I am glad to see you." Mercedes was surprised on how much she meant it.

"Where's your new body-guard? " Brian looked around for Dean. His eyes rested on Sam E who was quietly watching the interaction of Brian and Mercedes.

Mercedes cheeks blazed a crimson red, "He went out for a while. His partner is not too far tough." Dean had promised not to keep her under 24-7 surveillance as long as one of Puck's men was stationed out in front of Tina's apartment building and Agent Murphy and he were able to stop by daily. Mercedes parents were satisfied with the plan. Mercedes had mulled over the 24-7 surveillance at her apartment with Dean protecting her body. She was safer for both if they were not alone.

"Sammy could you give Brian and me a chance to catch up?" Mercedes had not figured out how to react to Sam Evans strange behavior. She was concerned for him.

"I have to run some errands for Carole anyways. If you need anything give me a call." Sam E kissed her lightly on the lips, leaving the apartment.

"I bet he was in the shadows waiting for his chance. Where is his Barbie doll?" Brian asked?

"I don't know what's wrong with him it is as if someone erased the last ten years of his memory. He thinks we have a prom in a week. I convinced Dr. David Karosky to do a home calls to see him. He thinks that Sam could have witnessed something horrific maybe the murder of his fiancée Tiffany and to protect itself his mind blocked out the last decade. Tiffany went missing after my attack. I don't know what to do I don't want to say something that will damage him any further." Mercedes exhaled.

"Sam Evans is not your responsibility you know that right? " Brian pointed out.

"He's my friend." Mercedes simply answered.

"How are you going to pull off going to prom? How did they convince him not to go to McKinley?" Brian quizzed her.

"Schools out until they find the killer. The prom is an issue we will have to cross when we get there. Look Brian I am doing the best I can for him but I'm scared whatever attacked me will come back for him and me." Mercedes said.

"Do you remember that night? Did you see his face?" Brian asked?
"I don't remember that night at all, that's why I am trying hard to be patient with Sam it is like someone hijacked your mind. I am missing a day poor Sam is missing who knows how long." Mercedes said.

"I should have been with you that day, we shouldn't have broken up. I should have been by your side." Brian admitted, "Cedes' I got a promotion at work. You were the first person I wanted to share the news with."

Mercedes searched his big brown eyes she wished he had shown her this side of him before.

"Congratulations, I am so proud of you."

"My new promotion requires me to leave Lima. With the murder of my cousin it was a no brainer I am leaving. This branch is located in New York. Mercedes, I know right now things are rough for us but I want you to go with me." Brian pushed up his glasses.

"Brian, I don't think I …." Mercedes started.

"Mercedes don't answer yet. I am not moving for another three months I want you to take time to think about it. I know you need time to think about it." Brian left out that the two biggest distractions, Sam Evans and Agent Asshole should be gone.

"Brian"

"No, do not answer yet. Gary's death made me realize life is too short to make your wants not vocal. I want you." Brian turned to walk out of the apartment.

…..

Tiam

"I have a confession to make." Tina laid her head on Sam's bare chest.

"Yes." Sam ran his finger down Tina's arm.

"Sounds stupid I know but Mike used to read these books called Supernatural. I read them too because he loved them. Well after reading last night I thought Agent Ryan and you were actually the main characters. I mean many similarities. Their first names are Sam and Dean like yours and the Impala they drive just like yours. I mean Agent Ryan catch phrase is Awesome." Tina explained.

"There is a reason there are so many similarities," Sam breathed in; he wanted to tell Tina the truth bad. He knew he couldn't if he wanted to protect her.

"There is." Tina sat up on her elbow to look inside of Sam's gorgeous hazel-green eyes.

"Carver the writer shadowed us for a while to make his characters more realistic, we are the inspiration behind the brothers." Sam fudged the truth a little.

"You are the inspiration of Sam? I could see that. Are you part of the secret agents that investigate the unusual things like aliens and spacecraft? Is the Heartbreaker Killer a scientist experiment that went wrong? How much of the book is fiction and how much is true?" Tina asked?

"I have never read any of the books all the way through." Sam truthfully replied. They had skimmed through most of the books and read an unpublished copy.

"They are great. Carver is a genius. My favorite is Tall Tales my favorite part is when Dean relays his story to Bobby mocking Sam, I guess you. Dean this is a serious case blah, blah, blah." Tina said in her fake male voice.

Sam found it about as funny as he did when it was happening not at all.

"The Trickster is great! My other favorite story is the Mystery Spot where Sam is caught in a loophole and his poor brother dies over and over again. I bet your family loves he series." Tina chatted on.

"Tina, one fact that Carver got right is the only family Sam and Dean got left is each other. Let's talk about something else." Sam turned his head away from Tina.

"Okay." Tina agreed.

…..

"She woke up yelling Winchester." Dean's voice hit Mercedes ears.

"Sounds like she was visited by someone in her dream. They probably wanted to get a message to you." A low growl voice said. Mercedes was sure it was Agent Brennan but she could not bet on it. Mercedes prepared herself to make her presence known than stopped. Dean would skin her alive if he found out she had left the safety of Tina's apartment. After Brian left she had to leave the apartment to take a walk to clear her mind, she hadn't `made it too far when Dean's voice stopped her.

"Dean there is something I should tell you. Something I just found out." Agent Brennan said.

"What is it Cas?" Dean voice sounded tired.

"Mercedes can help us defat Uthra. I found out by another angel that Mercedes voice can extract him from his makeshift body. If he is extracted from the body he will automatically be returned to Juno. She won't have a reason to attack Lima and the killing will stop," Agent Brennan said.

"I told you no Castiel, I will not tell you no again. Mercedes not knowing is what is keeping her safe."

"She could save a lot of people her mom included if she knew." Cas pointed out.

"Castiel, you could save her mom too! Please it will damage her if she knows that she had the power to help people and didn't use it. Trust me sometimes having the power to save a person is not healthy." Dean thought of all the times and things he had done to save Sam. He thought of all the damage he had done when he had let an angel named Gadreel passing himself off as another angel name Ezekiel.

"Dean her breaking those cars window is the tip of the iceberg of what she can do." Castiel said.

"Let me think about it. How do you think I should start to explain this to her, I knew your great great – great grandfather he looked great for his age he only looks thirty years of his thousands and thousands year oh and he was a great big dick. How that is possible well let me see he was the angel, Gabriel that was murdered by his brother Lucifer while he was trying to save my life. Cas do you think she will believe me? Or should I bring up her great-great-great grandma Terpsichore the muse of music. Surprise you are related to sirens and we need you to sing the killer to death who by the way belongs to Juno the Roman Goddess not the movie version of 16 & pregnant" Dean made his famous duck face.

Mercedes head started to hurt what the hell was Dean talking about?

"I can teach her how to use her angel grace and siren powers together." Cas offered.

"No, you barely can use your grace or have you restored Sam Evans to an adult yet? The Puckermans yeah let's leave that alone." Dean said, "Look Terpsichore hid her child for a reason, Gabe's enemies are immortal. I do not want Mercedes in any additionally danger. We still don't know if Uthra will attack her again."

"You cannot be with her every second. If she knows what to do then she might save you or did you forget he attacked you first?" Castiel said he was worried about his best friends; they were the definition of sacrificing.

"That's why you are here." Dean huffed.

"Oh my God, you are crazy! " Mercedes stepped from besides the building that was hiding her. She could not bear to hear anymore rants of the guy she had begun to fall for.

"Damn it Castiel." Dean cursed at Cas.

"Stay the hell away from me!" Mercedes ran upstairs toward Tina's.

Dean ran after her, "Angelface, Mercedes let me explain."

"Tina! Tina! Call Puck I think…. Tina!" Mercedes frantically searched for her best friend. The conversation hadn't made any sense but what if Dean and company were the killers. Agent Brennan came out of nowhere he could have pretended to harm Dean so Dean could get inside info from her. The angel talk probably was code for something. Why hadn't she paid closer attention? Her Uncle Derrick had tried to find more about the agents protecting his niece after hearing about the attack. There was a couple Agent Murphy and Ryan in the FBI but none were partners; he had promised a visit the second he wrapped up his case.

"Tina!" Mercedes screeched she could hear a mirror stating to crack.

She flung open Tina's bedroom door to save her to be greeted by a tight pale ass that belonged to Agent Murphy.

"Get off of her you psycho," Mercedes jumped on his back.

"Mercedes, what is going on?" Tina helplessly tried to cover her body up.

"They are crazy! They are not real FBI agents." Mercedes tightened her grip around Sam's neck.

"Cedes' please let go of him. We can talk about this in the living room." Tina tried to keep her voice steady.

"Mercedes! Mercedes!" Dean found her in the bedroom, "Mercedes let go of his neck." Dean could see the restrain his brother was showing. Sam could flick Mercedes off of him like a gnat but he was protecting himself just enough to protect his airwaves.

Dean peeled Mercedes off of him. Mercedes slit her eyes at him running towards the kitchen.

"Get dressed playboy!" Dean flung clothes at Sam.

"What did you do?" Tina screamed.

"Nothing." Dean ran after Mercedes.

"Stay the hell away from me!" Mercedes pointed the biggest knife in the kitchen at his throat, "I don't know who in the hell you are or what sick game you are playing but I am not scared to kill you."

"Mercedes put the knife down!" Tina ran in the living room with a half-dressed Sam on her heels.

"Ty, I overheard him talking to that other guy about I can't even explain it. They are insane." Mercedes tried to convince Tina she was in danger.

"Dean Do you want me to erase her memory?" Castiel teleported inside the apartment.

"No." Dean and Sam exclaimed, the last words Mercedes heard before fainting.

Thank you for being patient with me with this crossover fiction! It is a challenge but I do enjoy writing it! I think so far this has been one of my favorite chapters writing! I try to remember about Uthra but I had a lot of fun with Tina/Sam in this chapter. I guess it is because season 9 Sam Winchester is breaking my heart so I like focusing on him not being mean to his brother. I didn't mean for Tiam to steal the chapter. I almost forgot about Brian and Sam Evan's guest appearance has lasted a whole lot longer than I had planned but guess what he is a lot of fun to write.

Now I need your help what Glee character do you want to be the one who summoned Uthra and why? Please PM me with ideas! I thought I knew who I wanted it to be but as the story has developed I am no longer certain! Thank you again!

Love ya,

LudaNeet