The door to the house swung open and a man with a shotgun bound through the door. Hotch instinctively reached for where his gun would be but realized his clothes and gun belt were all the way across the room. The man immediately looked and pointed his shotgun at Hotch and JJ.
"You the FBI in my driveway, wait, what the hell are you doin' on my couch?" questioned the man. Hotch tried to roll off JJ and go for his gun but the man who he figured was Henry shot a warning shot less than a foot in front of him. "Get back by the couch" screamed Henry as he looked like he had an idea. Hotch retreated back to the couch with an almost scared look that JJ had never seen. Henry looked at the rope he had near his dining room chair and then back at JJ and Hotch. He grabbed the rope and started walking towards Hotch. He pointed the gun at JJ and threatened, "If you move while I'm tying him up I'll blow your head off!!!" He tied Hotch up while he was still naked and then moved on to JJ. After he was done tying them up he grabbed a roll of duct tape and taped both of their mouths. He had hogtied both of them and took Hotch first. He went through the front door out to and old horse trailer that he threw Hotch into, right on his stomach, which made Hotch let out a violent scream. He then went back into the house for JJ who was already crying. She landed on Hotch when she was thrown into the trailer, which made her landing softer but made Hotch wince in severe pain. Henry then shut and locked the door and went to hook up his truck to the trailer.
As the trailer jolted forward it made JJ and Hotch fly backwards. The whole ride they rolled around in the trailer, which was filled with old, sharp pieces of straw that kept poking their naked bodies. As the truck squealed to a stop, JJ and Hotch rolled to the front of the trailer. Henry came back and opened the door. He came to the front of the trailer, and using his massive muscles, picked up both JJ and Hotch at the same time. He brought them into what looked like an old, abandoned, industrial building. The weirdest thing was that there weren't any other buildings around.
Henry carried them through a door, down two sets of stairs, and then through what looked like a hand dug tunnel, into a room with just one bare light bulb hanging from the roof. There was also a surgical table (with blood still on it) and a bunch of tools that look like they'd be used for torture (which was consistent with the marks that the bodies of the victims had on them). There was also a camera on a tripod and a gym mat in one corner. He threw both Hotch and JJ down on the mat and ripped off the duct tape across their mouths.
"Go ahead and scream, there's no one around to here you," said Henry, laughing. JJ was now sobbing violently and Hotch was doing all he could to calm her down. Henry walked over to an old computer and started typing. After ten minutes, JJ was reduced to a small eek of a cry and the printer had just started up.
Henry grabbed the paper and walked over to Hotch. "I'm going to start the video and then your going to read this to all of your little friends at the BAU, OK" said Henry smiling.
"I'll never read anything for you, you bastard!" yelled Hotch.
"I think you will," laughed Henry as he pulled JJ aside and put a knife to her throat. "You wouldn't dare kill an FBI agent," said Hotch. Henry responded by making a little cut right between JJ's neck and shoulder.
"OK, OK, just don't hurt her," said a very worried Hotchner.
Henry walked over to the video camera and said "Good, good. And now 5,4,3,2, and start reading".
Hotch started reading… "Hello, this is Agent Hotchner, I have been kidnapped while at a suspects house. He is holding JJ and I and will only give us back if you drop off money. The amount will depend on whom you would like to see. Drop $50,000 if you would like to see one of us back, and $100,000 if you would like to see both of us. The money must be dropped off in the food court of the town mall within 1 hour or else you won't ever see us again. Thank you and goodbye."
Hotch heard the click of the video camera turning off and then Henry took the tape and picked up a manila envelope from a cabinet. He scribbled the letters BAU on it, slid the tape in, and sealed it up.