New chapter up! Thank you for all the kind feedback on my last two chapters! This one is mostly dialogue, but I still think it's pretty good! Still more to come! :) xoxo

Peter and Olivia (the other Olivia) were driving to Walter's house to tell him the truth about Olivia and what had happened Over There. The first few minutes were filled with awkward silence, until Olivia spoke up.

"I know this won't excuse anything, Peter, but I'm sorry. I'm really—"

"I'm not going to forgive you."

"I know."
"But I will tolerate you. Enough to work together to help get our Olivia back here, at least."

"That's fine."
"You know, Walter's going to be really upset."

"I know."

"He's very sensitive. He's not like Walternate."

"I know."

They were at the Bishop house now. They got out of the car and walked inside to find Walter sitting on the couch and watching TV. He looked up at them and smiled.

"Peter! Olivia! So nice to see you two! Look, there's a special on the Discovery Channel on giraffes!" he looked up and saw no smiles on their faces.

"Oh, oh, I see. Well, I can stay downstairs if you two would like to, you know, do what you kids do upstairs…" he chuckled.

"Walter, we need to talk to you." Peter said.

"Is it about those new coconut mango ice pops I sent you to the market for? I'm so sorry, Peter, I didn't know they discontinued them in 1998—"

"Walter, sit down." Olivia spoke up. Peter turned off the TV and sat on the couch with Olivia across from Walter.

"Listen, Walter…I don't know how to say this, but…we brought back the wrong Olivia. From Over There, I mean."

"What? Peter, you were always making jokes at the wrong time, figures you would joke about THAT topic—"

"Walter, I'm not joking."

"Peter, I'm sure after a long day, you must be very tired. This is funny, isn't it, Olivia?" his chuckling stopped when he saw that Olivia wasn't laughing. In fact, there were tears in her eyes.

"Peter…Peter, this can't be true…" Walter was trembling now, Peter knew he was on the verge of tears.

"Walter, I'm so sorry." Olivia sniffled.

"This is all my fault…" Walter cried. "How could I not know it wasn't her…how could I be so stupid…"

"This isn't your fault, Walter. If it's anyone's fault, it's mine." Olivia reached out a hand to touch his shoulder, but Walter immediately moved away.

"Don't touch me!" he cried. Peter had never seen him so distraught. He didn't know what to say, so they just stayed quiet for a little while and let Walter cry. From afar, it looked just like the old family, but there was one person missing. The most important member of them all—Olivia.