Very quick re-write, which I like a lot better. Set during the Maddison Baby timeframe (not the drama, just the baby)
Square
Square peg. Round hole.
Blue, square peg. Yellow, round hole.
No hammer.
Addison looks tiredly at the old toy, films of dust still undisturbed where her fingers didn't brush it.
It's hard to fathom that Savannah has something like this in her attic, but then, some people keep Huckleberry Finn in their attics.
She thinks about that Yankee onesie. Doesn't wonder, just thinks, and it appears jarred in her mind.
She leaves the toy there, and goes back down to Savannah, ready to watch Breakfast at Tiffany's and eat pancakes.
Some things just go together.
And some things don't.
Reference: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn had two manuscripts. Mark Twain gave one of them to a friend of his, and it turned up, randomly, in the attic of a house in LA or somewhere equally strange that wasn't even properly urbanized when Mark Twain was around, much less populated with houses that had attics. There was this whole legal thing about royalties that was really boring, and in the end it got published.