Yo sorry I'm so late I was just in school…and well you people know the rest.

DISCAMER:I do not own anything but, my story, so don't pi-get me angry (innocent look is casted)

Hawkfrost's pov

Firestar glared at Hawkfrost and started talking.

"Hawkfrost, explain why you are here." he asked still glaring at the tom who tried killing him with Brambleclaw and tried to take over the clans as Tigerclan and Darkcan.

Hawkfrost looked amused. "Well Starclan. For some reason gave me my life back to start over." Hawkfrost was not telling going to tell him the full truth because there would only be more questions for him. So he had to tell a lie.

"I find that very hard to believe that star clan would give you another chance." Hawkfrost looked around and saw a small brown she-cat who was hutched over. Her eyes were clouded as if she were grieving silently. But she was still giving him a suspicious glare from across the clearing.

"Mousefurs' right why did star clan give you of all cats another chance when they hardly give ordinary cats who are loyal like us , give you a river clan traitor another chance at life. Firestar he is obviously lying to us." Dustpelt snarled at Hawkfrost looking ready and tense for a battle.

"Calm down everyone ." Firestar said flickering his tail to silence the cats beneath him. Once everyone was silent he looked at Brambleclaw whos' eyes were closed as if he were thinking about something.

Hawkfrost felt Ivypaw, who was next to him bristle. What was she so angry about? Hawkfrost shook that thought away and continued listing to Firestar as he spoke to him.

"What Mousefur says is right our not telling the truth. But, sometimes we do not always have too ." Firestar looked at Brambleclaw who's eyes were now open and was staring at Hawkfrost to.

"I think we should let him stay." Brambleclaw said looking at Firestar who stared at him in shock. "Why?" Firestar questioned.

"Well for starters he's my brother and second of all we can't send him back to Riverclan. They'll ask why he was buried on Thunderclan territory instead of Riverclan. Thus causing a battle over a warriors body and we don't want to start a battle. Besides Tigerstar was born in Thunderclan, left to leader Shadowclan and had a mate who was in Riverclan. Thus, making his blood Riverclan, Shadowclan, and Thunderclan." Brambleclaw said. Hawkforst was impressed by how wise his brother had gotten over these moons.

"Then why can't he go to Shadowclan!" Spiderleg said gto Brambleclaw. He was glaring at the brown tabby deputy with questioning eyes. "Do you only want him here because he's your brother?" Spiderleg questioned him.

"Spiderleg have you forgotten how it was Hawkfrost who tried to KILL Firestar and tried to use Brambleclaw?" Leafpool ( warrior) spoke up from the back of the crowd.

"Leafpool is right Spiderleg. But, if we send him to Shadowclan there will be questions and we will have no clear answers to give Blackstar. For now he will stay in Thunderclan until I can decide what to do with him. He will be a prisoner each of you will take shifts guarding. The first shift will be watched by Thornclaw. This meeting is dismissed." Firestar said walking back to his den.

Ivypaw's POV

Ivypaws watched as everyone went back to their dens and Hawkfrost walk with Thronclaw to the prisoner den. Once Hawkfrost dissapred in the den she walked into the apprentice den. She saw Dovepaw already in the den awake and looking at her. Rolling her eyes she sat down in her nest.

"Hey Ivypaw." Ivypaw heard Dovepaws voice and looked at her.

"What?" Ivypaw asked.

"What happened?"

"What do you mean what happened?" Ivypaw asked looked at Dovepaw.

"I mean what happened. To us. Why don't we talk anymore? Why don't we play together anymore. Why aren't we real sisters anymore!" Dovepaw asked her standing up to her full height.

"What happened! What happened was you Dovepaw everyone around here thinks you're a gift of Starclan! Everyone loves you Whitewing, Birchfalll, Firestar, Even Brambleclaw and all senior warriors! You get to go to every single gathering! But. Whenit comes to me no one cares. No one asks me to go with Firestar on patrols all I want is to be noticed and no one can give that to me… That's all I ask for is to be noticed. Like you. To be loved…like you." Ivypaw said standing up and walking out of the den.

"Ivypaw wait!" Dovepaw said behind her but, she didn't turn around. She just kept walking until she heard the soothing and clam voice she had grown to get accustomed of.

"Hey Hawkfrost."