A/N: Requested by BornThisWay210f, who gave me the song

Rachel walked into the choir room carrying a guitar case. Her ex-girlfriend looked on curiously. "I didn't know Rachel played the guitar." Brittany said.

"Neither did I." Santana whispered.

"Guys, Rachel has prepared a song for us." Mr. Schue said.

"I'd like to dedicate this to Santana." The Latina raised an eyebrow. "San, I know its been two months snce we broke up, but I can't get you out of my mind. I miss you and... I love you." Rachel said as she began playing.

Slept in this room together
But now you're gone
And it's so quiet I turn the TV on
We lived in this room together
Remember, we painted the walls
Now time doesn't stand still
Though it crawls, it crawls

Santana listened closely. "San-" Brittany said. Santana gestured for her to be quiet.

And baby I'm afraid to sleep
Cause if I do I'll always dream of you
Dreaming always deep
I miss you so why did I let you go

Rachel and Santana made eye contact and Rachel held it as long as possible before she looked down.

I never realized how much I was in love with you
Til you started sleeping with some one new
Last night i dreamed again
December and you were there
I cried and you kissed my face
And you still care, you still care

Santana had been missing Rachel, but she hadn't wanted to risk ruining the friendship they had formed after their unexpected relationship had ended.

And baby I'm afraid to sleep
Cause if I do I'll always dream of you
Dreaming always deep
I miss you so why did I let you go
Oh oh oh
Baby I'm afraid of sleep

Rachel couldn't even remember why she'd broken up with Santana. She only knew that it was the worst decision she'd ever made and it was her greatest regret.

Lying alone in the darkness
With a memory in my head
There's a big hole where my heart is
And a lonely feeling rolling around my bed

Santana couldn't help but smile at the emotion in the performance. She knew that Rachel honestly meant every word she sang.

And baby I'm afraid to sleep
Cause if I do I'll always dream of you
Dreaming always deep
I miss you so why did I let you go
Oh oh oh, oh oh oh
Baby I'm afraid of sleep
Oh oh oh, oh oh oh
Baby I'm afraid of sleep
Baby I'm afraid of sleep

Santana got up and walked as Rachel played the last of the song.

We slept in this room together and now you're gone…

As Rachel strummed the last notes, Santana placed her hand over Rachel's stopping the sound of the guitar. Rachel looked up with questioning eyes and Santana leaned down. Closing the gap, Santana melted into the familiar embrace. "I love you too." Santana breathed against her lips.