My " what if" muse paid me a visit today so I present you with a brand new chapter of Unsaid. Enjoy : )
Josh was pacing in his room. He was very worried. Just this morning he received a mysterious text from Andy. It simply said "We need to talk. I'll be there at 11.00". He knew this meant trouble and he was freaking out, trying to think of what he could have possibly screwed up to deserve the "we need to talk" punishment.
"Maybe she just wants to talk" Kyle tried to reassure him "When Amanda said…"
"For crying out loud Kyle Andy is not Amanda. We have outgrown the third grade stage of our relationship" seeing Kyle miserable puppy expression Josh quickly apologized" Sorry man I didn't mean to diss you and Amanda. I am just nervous"
"I understand" said Kyle smiling but looking slightly confused
After a few minutes of silence and lots of pacing Kyle finally decided to break the tension by satisfying his curiosity
"What do you mean third grade stage?" asked a curious Kyle
"Nothing man forget it" said Josh dismissing the issue but after seeing Kyle looking almost desperately curious he relented" It's just that you have going with Amanda for three months now right?"
"Yes"
"And you are next door neighbors right?"
"You know that the answer is yes Josh. What do you mean?
"Well aren't you taking it kind of slow?"
"What do you mean slow?" said Kyle not understanding where Josh was going with this
"Well you just seem to spend your time holding hands and smiling at each other" said Josh as if explaining to a small child. He hoped he wouldn't have to give the birds and bees lecture to Kyle
"We kissed several times" said Kyle finally understanding what Josh meant" Isn't that what couples do?"
"Three months in a relationship? No" said Josh laughing" After three months you should be at least at boob town"
"Boob town?" repeated Kyle confused
Josh laughed nervously. He really shouldn't be doing this he was going to be in so much trouble. But Kyle was like a dog with a squeaky toy. Once he got curious about something he wouldn't let go
"Well you see it's…Andy!!"
"Andy is boob town? "said a very confused Kyle
"No I mean she is coming!" said Josh pointing out of the window" Sorry man we will talk about this later ok?"
Kyle nodded and with a quick "Good luck" left the room. Josh felt relief for a moment that he wouldn't have to deal with this but he quickly got anxious again. Andy was coming to have a "talk" and this made him extremely nervous. Apart from the Kyle distraction he hadn't been able to think about anything else since he woke up and read her txt
And then came the moment of truth. Andy came in through the door. She looked more beautiful then ever.
"Hey" said Josh uncertainly
"Hey" responded Andy as well avoiding to look him in the eyes "There is something I have to tell you"
Josh gulped nervously.
"What is it?" he said fearing he knew the answer
"There is someone else" said Andy making his worst case scenarios come true
And at that precise moment when Josh was left speechless and horrified Jessi entered the room in her usual abrupt manner
"Hi guys" she said with a hesitant smile
"Jessi this is really not the time" snapped Josh
"No she should stay" said Andy
"Andy I really would prefer it if we discussed this alone"
"Josh you don't understand" said a hesitant Andy and then did something unexpected as she gently took Jessi's hand and brought her closer" It's about me and Jessi"
Josh was stunned for a moment as his brain nearly crashed. He had no idea how to react to this
"You are dumping me for a girl? For Jessi? For a girl Jessi?" he said incredulous
"No…I don't know" said a confused Andy" I just ....I have feelings for her. I have feelings for both of you and it I thought it was fair if you knew"
"But you are into Kyle" said a stunned Josh turning to Jessi as he was still trying to make sense of this crazy situation "Everybody knows that!"
"Kyle is still hung up on Amanda" said Jessi shrugging her shoulders" and Andy is very soft. She makes me feel nice"
Jessi then proceeded to flash a brilliant smile in Andy's direction and started to play with a lock of her hair. Something which send incredibly confused signals to Josh who was both insanely jealous and was also experiencing the usual boy reaction of seeing two hot girls together
"Enough" said Josh finally trying to concentrate" Please tell me. What does this mean for us? Who are you going chose?"
"Chose?" said Jessi not understanding as she looked at both Andy and Josh
"Yes chose" said Josh in a mocking tone. He usually liked Jessi but he couldn't help snapping at someone who was after his girlfriend" As in if she wants to be with me or with you. Not such a hard concept is it?"
"But why?" asked Jessi again
"Well she can hardly go out with both of us now can she?" said a sarcastic Josh who was getting tired of Jessi's question and simply wanted to hear from Andy.
"Why not?" noticing Josh inquiring or more accurately what the hell look Jessi continued" Monogamy is just one of many possible ways in life, and judging by average relationship and divorce rates in the country not a very successful one. It is logical for three people to share a relationship instead of destroying their prospects of happiness by limiting their choices to only one partner"
Josh jaw dropped after he heard this. Andy looked touched and gently caressed Jessi's cheek
"Do you really mean that? You would be ok with it?" she asked with a big smile
"Yes. If it makes you happy it makes me happy. And Josh is not physically unappealing. And he is fun. Not some short annoying dumb blond" finished Jessi smiling, happy to have found both a solution to the problem and managing to squeeze in a shot against Amanda
Andy hugged Jessi tightly and then still embracing her turned to Josh and said:
"And you Josh? Are you in?"
"Are you guys serious?" asked Josh who felt like he was in the Twilight zone" What you suddenly woke up thinking hey threesomes are awesome?"
'I was actually referring to a polygamous relationship but you are right. Sexual intercourse is an important bonding process. We should have sex. Right?" she said turning to Andy
Andy smiled back and took off her jacket
"You know I am in but what about you Josh? Are you ready to share me?" she asked with a very naughty smile
The answer if Josh had time to think about it would have been a no. He loved Andy and he didn't think he could ever share her with someone. But at the moment his upstairs brain wasn't exactly in control. In fact he was currently in full fledged teen boy mode as he was finally starting to realize that this was not in fact a dream but reality .A reality where two incredibly hot girls wanted to have sex with him, at the same time. So his answer was
"Oh god yes"
As soon the words left his mouth Jessi stepped forth grabbed him by the shirt and literally threw him on the bed. Josh pinched himself again to make sure he was not dreaming. Even his wildest fantasies hadn't prepared him for the sight on Jessi and Andy slowly approaching his bed .When they took off their shirts leaving them only in their bras and jeans Josh nearly fainted. And just when he thought that his heart couldn't take it anymore they brought it even a step further as they got on the bed and started crawling in the sexiest of ways towards him. As he saw Andy tear off a condom wrapper with her teeth Josh was already completely paralyzed and knew he was in heaven.
They were both next to him now. Their faces almost touching his. They leaned in even closer putting their lips on either side his face and then suddenly ….
"April's Fool!" they shouted and collapsed giggling on the ground
Josh stared at the laughing girls incredulous. He couldn't believe that he actually fell for that. But then just as he thought that his day could not get anymore crazy the door burst open and his mother appeared in an angry huff
"Josh what have you been talking to Kyle about and oh…" Nicole stared wide eyed at the two half naked girls near his bed and then looked even more angry at him
Josh groaned. Today was not his day
I hope you enjoyed the story. This was quite amusing to write. Poor Josh eh?:)
So the Easter vacation is coming. Well technically it's already here and hopefully this will give me more time to write. Chapter number 3 of Now and Forever should be up tomorrow and with some luck in the weekend I might be able to update and maybe even complete a few other stories. So stay tuned :) And as always I would love to hear your opinion on my stories. You guys are great reviewers : )